Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I hate to oversimplify but this is America and I don't want someone I've never met to have the right to tell me what I can and cannot do with my own body. There are plenty of wonderful countries some of the PPs can relocate to if they wish to have such decisions made by others.
No problem. We'll keep it simple. You have a choice...whether or not to have sex. Don't have sex until you are ready to handle the responsibility that comes with it, i.e, the possibility that you could produce a new life.
Unfortunately, no one seems to follow through on that when it comes to their own daughters. I have seen too many pro-life Catholics who, when faced with a pregnant fifteen year old, take them to the clinic because they don't want her to screw up her life. She of course promised to not have sex until marriage, but that just translated into sex without contraception. And the irony is that the parents end up doing penance by devoting themselves even more to the pro-life cause. It's crazy.
So when I see a poster who says what you said, I say to myself that you probably had sex long before you were ready to be a mother. You just got lucky, and now that you are safely past those years, you are telling people to do what you did not.
If you want to write back and say you first had sex at 25 with your future husband, by all means do so. But I bet it's not true.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
I really can't understand why people say it's "so obvious" that a fetus is meaningfully different from a 1 year old, since, as someone said, life is a continuum. If it's life, it's life, We give different categories of human life different legal rights and responsibilities, as someone said, but there is only only category that we say has no rights whatever due to no act of its own.
Thanks again for sharing your views.
OP, a lot of people who are pro-choice nevertheless do see a difference between the morality of aborting an embry, or a fetus before 13 weeks gestation, verses a second or epseiclly third trimester abortion.
Some of us who have had a miscarriage of a fetus at 6 or 8 or 10 weeks gestation really have a gut sense that this "cluster of cells" just isn't a "person" and yet we would very much agree that a fetus at 39 weeks gestation (or 28 weeks -- capable of possibly living on its own once born) is a "person". But there's a huge difference between the cluster of cells at 5 weeks or 8 weeks gestation, and a fully developed fetus at 37 or 38 weeks.
It's obvious to me that an embryo is different from a 1 year old, in terms of rights which we should give it, which is in my opinion, to sya, no rights. But a 38 week old fetus should not be aborted... and I think most laws do not allow it to be (I could be wrong).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:OP - consider checking out Project Rachel offered through the Catholic church.
You DON'T have to be affiliated with the Church or even Christian to attend.
Is your DH your best friend? He should be, you married him for better or for worse. You should be able to share everything with him
That means the good, the bad, and the ugly.
Eh, I question the motives of this poster.
I don't see what this information adds or doesn't add to your relationship. Why is it necessary to "share" this information? Does it affect him? Is it relevant? Would it change the way he feels about you?
You had a life before him. It is irrelevant. See a counselor and deal with your grief on your own.
If he asks, tell him. If he doesn't, then deal with your issues on your own.
(plus I'm one of the VERY few actual screen names I've seen on here!)