Anonymous wrote:Tru dat, Muslima...except we aren't seeing poor people living in SE DC or Appalachia take up weapons and commit jihad, right? So it's gotta be something else.
Anonymous wrote:I think it's a matter of time, sadly.Muslima wrote:Damned if you do, Damned if you don't, my goodness, get a grip. They are exercising their right to freedom of speech by marching and saying what they believe in and what they are protesting against. Would you be happier if they murdered more people?
Anonymous wrote:Muslima wrote:Yes, you certainly can, just like I can use mine to say how ridiculous and idiotic it is for a bunch of cartoonists not to have anything better to do than sit in a room and caricature people highly-held in regard by different groups of people. There's got to be a more noble way of earning a living other than making minorities/immigrants feel small in your country by satirizing their iconic figures. But hey, to each their own~
you certainly can, but it stinks that you do it after the same cartoonists were slaughtered for drawing the cartoons, and by people who alleged to be offended by the cartoons. it sounds a lot like blaming, even just in part, the victims.
it would be the same if the Muslims in the Philippines were attacked and slaughtered en masse for participating to the march, and we quipped on DCUM how ridiculous and idiotic is for a bunch of Philippinos not to have anything better to do than protest for cartoons published on the other side of the world in a country where freedom of religious satire is held on high regard.
Anonymous wrote:Muslima wrote:Damned if you do, Damned if you don't, my goodness, get a grip. They are exercising their right to freedom of speech by marching and saying what they believe in and what they are protesting against. Would you be happier if they murdered more people?
If the bar of expectation for Muslim behavior is that they should protest in favor of the actions of murderers, rather than be murderers, we can do that. Seems a bit low, though.
Anonymous wrote:Muslima wrote:Damned if you do, Damned if you don't, my goodness, get a grip. They are exercising their right to freedom of speech by marching and saying what they believe in and what they are protesting against. Would you be happier if they murdered more people?
and we are exercising our freedom of speech by saying that Muslims in the Philippines would spend their time more wisely if they protested against the thousands in Syria, Iraq and Nigeria who desecrate Islam and commit blasphemy against their Prophet by killing and raping thousands of innocent in the name of Allah and the Quran, instead of marching against a magazine published in a country on the other side of the world.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Frankly, I think Muslima's positions have been more consistent than some of her critics.
It is outright hypocritical to defend the right to insult Mohammed on the grounds of free speech and yet have no issue with those who attempt to restrict the right of someone who chooses to offend Jews or challenge the holocaust.
"challenge the [H]olocaust?" Didn't know it was up for debate.
Whether there is merit to the claims by those who deny the holocaust or feel the numbers are exaggerated is neither here nor there. We are talking about free speech and freedom of expression which is what those who defend the cartoons depicting Mohammed say is the essence of the issue.
How does one make this argument and then in the next breath not condemn any laws that restrict the right of those who choose to question the holocaust or in some other way offend Jewish sensibilities?
Here is a historian who was jailed for denying the holocaust:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/4733820.stm
At least one of his fiercest critics had the intellectual honesty to defend his right to say what he wished about the holocaust and opposed his imprisionment.
"I am not happy when censorship wins, and I don't believe in winning battles via censorship... The way of fighting Holocaust deniers is with history and with truth," she told the BBC News website.
Anonymous wrote:Muslima wrote:I actually recognize my friends who wear a niqab, I must be a genius ~
I'm glad you recognize your friends--I'm sure their mannerisms and voices are familiar to you. That's not the point, and I feel sure you know it.