I just said mother bc that is who was referenced in the post I responded to. Of course I’d blame the father too. |
+1000. Becoming a parent made me a) realize how poor a job my parents did and b) resolve to do almost everything the opposite w my own kids. I had never thought that much about parenting before getting pregnant w my first. Before having kids I didn’t fully understand just how lacking my parents were and how strongly I felt about wanting to do so much better for my kids. |
Some do. Some parents cause more problems than they solve. |
Not in this case OP forced her crap religious homeschool garbage on her kid he has a right to be pissed. His education was subpar not because of homeschooling because of her crap so called morals |
You sound like a bigot, hope you don’t have kids. |
|
NP. I’ve been to several “family” sessions with DC. I always get the lion’s share of the blame, for several reasons.
One, XDH is a complete mess emotionally and financially (really, the stories are nuts but I don’t want to out him, he’s in enough trouble) so when his name comes up, DC and the therapist say “that’s too bad,” roll their eyes, and move on to me. I was the parent who held things together, and so I wasn’t popular. XDH had ADHD among other issues. But worst is XDH didn’t want to do any hard parenting, including academically or consequences for a police violation. I’ve had 1-2 of DC’s therapists tell them they were lucky to have me. But it always comes back to how awful I was (once I threw a shoe at a wall! When I smelled pot in my living room I complained about it!). I’m over it. PP who said some therapists cause harm are right. |
This is a really bad approach. Your parents didn’t give you what you needed. But your child may need something totally different than you did. Maybe even the things your parents did. Each child needs something different— makes it very challenging when you have more than one kid. I encourage this Pp to not just do the “opposite” of her parents but to figure out what her child needs (not focus on what she needed as a child). |
That's a good point -- it sounds like the OP here did the opposite approach (she says she gave her kids the childhood she wanted) and look how it turned out with her son. |
You misunderstood. My child may very well feel disgruntled when he grows up, but I am not doing anything which would cause him to need therapy. |
You dont think you are doing your child any harm but you might be. Do you really think your parents thought they were doing harm? Like Let's do x so you can tell their therapist how awful we were? |
That's great, but you may overcorrect your parents errors and make some new mistakes, on your kids that your parents didn't. Parental mistakes are not intentional. Most parents try their best within their abilities and limitations. |
There are bad therapists, just like there are some bad parents. All are human. |
i read that book twice and had a completely different takeaway. they had way too many children and the chaotic, abusive environment destroyed the kids -- the brothers fighting to the point of almost killing each other, raping their sisters, etc. while the parents ignored them. those incidents are all documented in the book. and at the end, the sane sister who saw signs of it in her own son, got him therapy and an interventional school and turned his life around I think proved that the parenting actually matters. |
The first child was born in 1945. It was a different time. It was more common to have large families. |
Excellent post. I did not have a great childhood. My mom had undiagnosed mental illness and was verbally abusive/emotionally neglectful. Today I have a very healthy, positive relationship with her. I've been in therapy and I worked through the crap from my childhood. Humans are complicated. She did the best she could and also, she caused a lot of emotional damage. Both can be true. I've forgiven her for things in the past without ever addressing it with her. I remember a therapy appointment after I'd seen a documentary about Pink. Cameras followed her on her tour and showed her balancing her tour and family. There was a part when her daughter told her she really wanted to go home and see her friends. Pink told her ok and she and her husband made arrangements for him and the daughter to go back home for a while. I thought it was a wonderful example of a healthy relationship...daughter could express herself, mom listened. My therapist smiled and said "it is wonderful, but also, her daughter could sit in a therapist's office one day and talk about how hard it was to be on the road with her mom and all the things she missed." Not to sound all Oprah, but it was a bit of a lightbulb moment for me. Even under the best circumstances, parents do things that affect their kids. It's just part of parenting. As adults we have the responsibility of making the best with the hand we were dealt and letting go of things that hold us back or keep us from being the best version of ourselves. You can't just blame your parents forever. |