I only responded that way because the pp said taking care of children is not respected. I said DH respected me. I respect myself. I feel I have high value and my time is valuable. Therefore, my caring for my children is both valuable and respectable. I know it may not sound like it on an anonymous forum but DH and I are quite humble and down to earth. We come from humble beginnings. Both of us are loyal to a fault and have friends from all different backgrounds from various times in our past. I have friends who work out a lot or cook a lot. I just like to travel a lot. Half the time we travel with our friends so they also like to travel. |
|
"Is there value to the work a SAHM does?" is maybe the stupidest of all SAH vs WOH DCUM threads I've ever read, which is saying a lot.
That being said, this NYT Magazine article is on-topic and an interesting perspective: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/17/magazine/waged-housework.html |
You trotted out an ivy league degree and your wealth as a reason you feel you should be respected, not because you are a caregiver. Give me a break. People who are down to earth don't brag like this to try to indicate they are worthy of respect. If you were truly secure in yourself, you wouldn't go on like this. And I'm a pp who advocates for giving more respect to all caregivers, but you are just too much. |
| I think being a SAHP is just as valuable as a working parent. The goal is a happy and emotionally healthy family. Of course, sometimes it requires two incomes. |
How would you know I was valuable if I didn’t? I don’t tell people where I went to school in real life. I was just answering the thread. |
+1 |
You honestly cannot just answer the thread by saying, my DH and I both value the work I do with our kids. We are happy with our choice...or something like that without mentioning your degree and wealth? For an Ivy Leaguer, you are pretty obtuse. |
Money and a fancy degree do not necessarily a good SAHM make. |
| One way to think about it is opportunity cost. What would it cost to hire someone to do what I do if I couldn’t do it? Even if you just count childcare expenses, it’s a lot! Certainly more than I ever made when I was working. The additional flexibility built into our lives by having me around during the day to take care of errands and so forth also has a value, though it’s harder to put a number on it. |
Lol!!! This was a good one. I’m not sure you know what either of those things mean. |
OP, as someone who is one of those professions, people on DCUM (and one person in real life) tell me all the time that I'm just a cog in the wheel, utterly replaceable, and a terrible mother for working instead of staying with your kids. So, just an FYI, with any job, people are going to say you're worthless unless you're a SAHM. Which is ironic, given your post. |
| I agree this is the worst SAHM/working mom threads. |
| This thread is beyond stupid. MOST (not all, obviously) of the “noble” professions OP listed aren’t contributing to SOCIETY in any meaningful way, anyway. They ARE contributing to their own families’ bottom line, however, if that is what OP means? |
| Just as a nanny takes pride in her work, I value my own as a SAHM. After those daytime hours, we are all moms, working or not, so that's all equivalent. But my work during the day is the same as what a nanny does plus housework, I'm just not outsourcing that. |
|
Why can’t we just call it what it is - staying at home with kids is a luxury that most of us cannot afford. Yes, most working parents are jealous because we have to work outside of the home and try to balance housework and raising our children. And yes it is really annoying to hear SAHPs constantly justifying their choice and explaining over and over how very hard and important their role is. There are plenty of reasons to be a working parent, but for most of us it comes down to money. If money was not an issue, I’d guess that most moms and dads would stay home.
Staying home is like any other luxury. If you or your spouse worked hard and saved enough money to install a pool in your backyard, would you feel compelled to constantly justify the expense by claiming the pool will help your children grow up to be well rounded swimmers? Would you feel guilty for having a pool while your neighbors do not? No. Of course not. You would just enjoy the pool. If you are a SAHP, just accept that you are one of the privileged few. Own it. Enjoy it. And stop being a martyr. |