Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The case is under investigation by the DA's office. The odds are high the case will be taken to a grand jury which will decide whether to indict the ex-marine. https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/04/us/new-york-subway-chokehold-death/index.html

The only reason there is a possible case is because a bystander took a video and gave it to the police.

I live in NYC. I ride the subway a couple of times a week. The homeless can be scary. You just don't know what they are going to do because so many of them are mentally ill. The PP who thinks you're safe if you just exit the car or move to the other side of the car is just plain wrong. Here's what happened to a woman who tried that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQuyDpirfgU Note this happened on the Upper East Side at 11 am Saturday morning.

In a recent case in my neighborhood, a homeless man focused his comments on a 4 year old child. He announced to the other riders that she was "Satan's spawn." He had been told it was his mission to free the world of "Satan's children." He followed the child and her mother off the train and outside. He came up to them while they were waiting at a bus stop, screaming in the 4 year old's face in a tirade of obscentities. No, he never actually touched the child, but she was certainly traumatized.

The subway is still pretty safe. These incidents are publicized because they are unusual.

Always those bleeding hearts like the one who took the video! Or was he just wanting his 15 mins of glory? Why is he defending the aggressive mentally ill person?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A lot of hot girls on social media are asking for the ex-marine’s contact info

I know it's irrelevant to the topic at hand, but I love this. This just proves that most women admire protective men like the Marine, and want to know that men will stand up for them and protect them.

You must love a wife beater.

Nope. Just men who know how to behave in dangerous situations when many people are at risk. Beta males, take note. No one is impressed with your paper signs and marching.

You can pay for your alpha male's commissary when he's a jail bird.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Kill someone or push the emergency button to let someone know what's happening?? He picked to kill someone he should be charged.

Oh? If the homeless person punched a passenger, would the conductor rescue them? Would anyone, besides this Marine?

Yet that didn't happen. Tell me again WHY was he murdered?

He wasn't murdered, but with that you're bias is showing and there is no discussion.

The cause of death is homicide.

Homicide is the killing of one person buy another.

Murder is the unlawful killing one person buy another.

Yes, and no one has determined yet whether this was unlawful or not.

[Anonymous]

So I looked at the CNN link above.
All those relatives of Neely who didn’t give a fig that he was homeless are suddenly oh so caring and want justice for him, and even went so far as to set up a gofundme! Nice cashing on his death. They should file a lawsuit against the subway! What a sick joke.

[Anonymous]

I doubt the marine woke up that day and decided, "I'd like to kill a homeless person" today. (or black person, or mentally ill person, etc. etc.).

If I'm on that grand jury I'm not indicting.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I doubt the marine woke up that day and decided, "I'd like to kill a homeless person" today. (or black person, or mentally ill person, etc. etc.).

If I'm on that grand jury I'm not indicting.

Drunk drivers don’t either yet they do with their reckless behavior.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Kill someone or push the emergency button to let someone know what's happening?? He picked to kill someone he should be charged.

Oh? If the homeless person punched a passenger, would the conductor rescue them? Would anyone, besides this Marine?

Yet that didn't happen. Tell me again WHY was he murdered?

He wasn't murdered, but with that you're bias is showing and there is no discussion.

The cause of death is homicide.

Homicide is the killing of one person buy another.

Murder is the unlawful killing one person buy another.

Yes, and no one has determined yet whether this was unlawful or not.

Not yet but we do know that you can’t assault someone for being loud.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So I looked at the CNN link above.
All those relatives of Neely who didn’t give a fig that he was homeless are suddenly oh so caring and want justice for him, and even went so far as to set up a gofundme! Nice cashing on his death. They should file a lawsuit against the subway! What a sick joke.

Tell me you don’t understand schizophrenia without telling me.

Many homeless people have homes that will take them in.

Many homeless vets have places they can stay and benefits they are too disorganized to file for.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I doubt the marine woke up that day and decided, "I'd like to kill a homeless person" today. (or black person, or mentally ill person, etc. etc.).

If I'm on that grand jury I'm not indicting.

Drunk drivers don’t either yet they do with their reckless behavior.

The two issues here are not comparable.

[Anonymous]

I feel horrible feeling the way I do, but as someone who has been threatened by a crazy person on the train, on a bus, and just on the street, I don't feel much sympathy for this crazy person.

Question for the people who do have sympathy for this crazy person: have you ever been confronted by one and do you expect to likely be that situation again? I have and I do expect it will happen again.

My suspicion is that many of you live your lives insulated from those kinds of people. Maybe that makes you more objective than me. My feeling certainly comes from concerns over my own safety.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So I looked at the CNN link above.
All those relatives of Neely who didn’t give a fig that he was homeless are suddenly oh so caring and want justice for him, and even went so far as to set up a gofundme! Nice cashing on his death. They should file a lawsuit against the subway! What a sick joke.

Tell me you don’t understand schizophrenia without telling me.

Many homeless people have homes that will take them in.

Many homeless vets have places they can stay and benefits they are too disorganized to file for.

I am pretty sure in this case they didn’t even try

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I feel horrible feeling the way I do, but as someone who has been threatened by a crazy person on the train, on a bus, and just on the street, I don't feel much sympathy for this crazy person.

Question for the people who do have sympathy for this crazy person: have you ever been confronted by one and do you expect to likely be that situation again? I have and I do expect it will happen again.

My suspicion is that many of you live your lives insulated from those kinds of people. Maybe that makes you more objective than me. My feeling certainly comes from concerns over my own safety.

Nope, many of us understand basic human rights.

Like I’ve been in a situation where I had to respect freedom of speech for white supremacists.

I took the bus as a teen from school late after practice and you sit close to the driver and there are crazy people on the bus all.the.time.

I get into my car in a parking lot late at night and while I’d love to shoot every male that makes me feel uncomfortable I can’t because… basic human right.

I actually think it’s people who never leave their house who think this is so wildly out of control that a homeless person is loud.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So I looked at the CNN link above.
All those relatives of Neely who didn’t give a fig that he was homeless are suddenly oh so caring and want justice for him, and even went so far as to set up a gofundme! Nice cashing on his death. They should file a lawsuit against the subway! What a sick joke.

Tell me you don’t understand schizophrenia without telling me.

Many homeless people have homes that will take them in.

Many homeless vets have places they can stay and benefits they are too disorganized to file for.

I am pretty sure in this case they didn’t even try

Can you pull some tarot cards for me since you seem to know things about strangers, it’s a gift.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I feel horrible feeling the way I do, but as someone who has been threatened by a crazy person on the train, on a bus, and just on the street, I don't feel much sympathy for this crazy person.

Question for the people who do have sympathy for this crazy person: have you ever been confronted by one and do you expect to likely be that situation again? I have and I do expect it will happen again.

My suspicion is that many of you live your lives insulated from those kinds of people. Maybe that makes you more objective than me. My feeling certainly comes from concerns over my own safety.

This particular homeless person had previously attacked three different women unprovoked and had a warrant for one of them. This particular homeless person did not just yell at people and scare them, he hurt people.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So I looked at the CNN link above.
All those relatives of Neely who didn’t give a fig that he was homeless are suddenly oh so caring and want justice for him, and even went so far as to set up a gofundme! Nice cashing on his death. They should file a lawsuit against the subway! What a sick joke.

+1. They see $$$ ahead