Homeless Man Killed by Fellow Passenger on NYC Subway

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If I were in that jury, I would find him not guilty. I can’t even phantom why they are persecuting him, to be honest. Waste of tax dollar money.

Nobody know how deep the choke was. Was he just restraining him or was he cutting off blood/oxygen to the brain. Hard to articulate a need to use lethal force when you are in such a dominant position and there are bystanders trying to help.

When in fear of death or great bodily injury, you do not need to rely on others to help. That's not the standard.

When you are larger, stronger, and have demonstrated that you are significantly more skilled than your adversary, it will be a tough sell to a jury that you are in fear of death.

So tired of mentally ill violent offenders praying on people who are smaller and weaker. Neely had 42 prior arrests, many for attacking weaker members of society. He knew what he was doing when he chose repeatedly to attack people like punching a 65 year old woman in the head unprovoked in a deli and punching a 67 year old women in the subway so hard without any provocation that she sustained a broken nose, a fractured orbital bone, and pain and bruising on her head. These are two that he got caught for, but how many other vulnerable people did he attack. I can't find any reports that he attacked men his size.

So Neely is not going around attacking larger, stronger, and more skilled adversaries. He is attacking and threatening elderly women and women with children in strollers. So according to you those larger, stronger, and more skilled adversaries never have a right to defend others when they are in a trapped environment and are absolutely in fear of death?

Well said. Daniel Penny is a great American hero for protecting innocent lives trapped on the NYC subway.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

You called in the police to attack some poor homeless person for daring to be in the train car with you?

No sweetie. 70% of the people on the train in DC on any given day appear homeless. 🙃

The conversation we are having here is about what to do “when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent”

So I should call 911 if I see someone acting crazy?

NO! 🙃

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If I were in that jury, I would find him not guilty. I can’t even phantom why they are persecuting him, to be honest. Waste of tax dollar money.

Nobody know how deep the choke was. Was he just restraining him or was he cutting off blood/oxygen to the brain. Hard to articulate a need to use lethal force when you are in such a dominant position and there are bystanders trying to help.

When in fear of death or great bodily injury, you do not need to rely on others to help. That's not the standard.

When you are larger, stronger, and have demonstrated that you are significantly more skilled than your adversary, it will be a tough sell to a jury that you are in fear of death.

So tired of mentally ill violent offenders praying on people who are smaller and weaker. Neely had 42 prior arrests, many for attacking weaker members of society. He knew what he was doing when he chose repeatedly to attack people like punching a 65 year old woman in the head unprovoked in a deli and punching a 67 year old women in the subway so hard without any provocation that she sustained a broken nose, a fractured orbital bone, and pain and bruising on her head. These are two that he got caught for, but how many other vulnerable people did he attack. I can't find any reports that he attacked men his size.

So Neely is not going around attacking larger, stronger, and more skilled adversaries. He is attacking and threatening elderly women and women with children in strollers. So according to you those larger, stronger, and more skilled adversaries never have a right to defend others when they are in a trapped environment and are absolutely in fear of death?

Well said. Daniel Penny is a great American hero for protecting innocent lives trapped on the NYC subway.

+100 great American hero like Bernard Goetz

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

What would YOU do about it, stud boy?

I bet you've never even been in a fistfight, not even in high school.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

What would YOU do about it, stud boy?

I bet you've never even been in a fistfight, not even in high school.

I’m not a boy.
I wouldn’t want to have to try to defend myself against someone like that, which is exactly why I’m grateful for Daniel Penny

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

You just make up your own facts now.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

So your argument is, you break someone’s nose, you deserve to die? Seems a bit harsh!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That doesn’t help in an immediate threat. Which multiple people felt this was in this situation. So spare us what you would have done in a situation you weren’t in.

What was the immediate threat here? I’ve ridden on DC metro for years as someone who only recently got a car, and I’ve been in these situations MULTIPLE times and now that we can text 911 this is what I have done. Why let it escalate until someone is attacked?

The immediate threat was that Neely was lunging at people. Witnesses said he came within 6 inches of a woman with a very young child in a stroller.
If a homeless guy was screaming that "someone is going to die today" while lunging at your child, would you just be calming texting 911 and waiting? Would you be grateful if someone stepped in and stopped the guy from getting inches away from your child?

Yes. That’s what I did. Highly effective hence my strong recommendation to do so.

You go ahead and try to get a homeless lunatic in a headlock though. 🙃🙃🙃

Nobody needs to follow your advice for the one situation that it worked out. Every situation is different and people will act accordingly.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

So your argument is, you break someone’s nose, you deserve to die? Seems a bit harsh!

Don’t start fights. Maybe that’s the lesson. Leave people alone and there won’t be any problems. But start making threats and acting aggressively and who knows whay may happen.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

So your argument is, you break someone’s nose, you deserve to die? Seems a bit harsh!

Yes, that is what one very vocal troll keeps repeating.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

So your argument is, you break someone’s nose, you deserve to die? Seems a bit harsh!

Don’t start fights. Maybe that’s the lesson. Leave people alone and there won’t be any problems. But start making threats and acting aggressively and who knows whay may happen.

This man is mentally ill, you idiot. It’s not like a normal person just picking fights.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

Yeah well like I’ve said now multiple times someone should’ve calmly texted 911 to alert authorities that a person was threatening people at random instead of sitting there like idiots for 10 minutes and what did you suggest…”inching away, hoping the doors would open or waiting for a big man to save” them while a lunatic broke someone’s nose.

Well at this point I’m preaching to other readers. I can no longer hope for the mentally dull to understand difficult subjects like when it’s appropriate to text 911

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

What would YOU do about it, stud boy?

I bet you've never even been in a fistfight, not even in high school.

I’m not a boy.
I wouldn’t want to have to try to defend myself against someone like that, which is exactly why I’m grateful for Daniel Penny

Maybe you could do Tae Bo or get a shriek alarm so you don't suffer further brain damage in the event of an attack.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because he was dangerous and needed to be subdued. Why wouldn't someone understand that?

Specifically how was he dangerous? There are 1000s of people experiencing mental health and/or substance abuses crises in NYC and other large cities. Most are a danger to themselves only. He was apparently in the chokehold for 15 minutes. That's a lifetime. Cops and EMTs could have been called and passengers could have gotten off at the next stop and alerted the driver. Several male passengers could have tried to subdue him at once until help came. Does everyone have carte blanche now to kill people they perceive as dangerous? Because if that's the case, don't venture into cities or onto subways.

It seems likely that the use of force was excessive. We need more information about why he was perceived as a threat.

Tell me, were you this upset when Michelle Go was pushed onto the tracks to her death for no reason?

+1 or about the woman who lost an eye?

Of course that was upsetting. But in this particular case, there is no indication that the guy was going to push anyone in front of the train. He was ON the train. Anyone who has lived in a city has encountered people--on subway trains and off--who are clearly mentally ill and acting weird. As a woman, I try to get off the train as soon as I can or I move to the other side of the car I am in. When you take public transportation, you will eventually encounter high people, mentally ill people, homeless people, weird-looking people, etc. It comes with the territory.

And if you’ve lived in a city and taken the subway, you know that sometimes it’s not always possible to exit your subway car when some nut job starts acting crazy or violent. The best you can do is try to inch away, pray the doors open soon, or pray there is a big guy in the car who will take on the crazy man.

You can text 911. I have done it and they got the man off the train at the next stop.

That happens like maybe once for every 200 calls. You were just lucky that the next stop had someone ready to take the crazy out.
Most subway stations don't have that. In fact, I've seen people jump the turnstiles right in front of cops. The cops don't do anything because that is not their assignment.
It's stupid.
The underground crawls vermin of all species.

Wasn’t luck. Metro was contacted obviously by the 911 dispatcher to stop the train and leave the doors open so people could alight until transit police and police arrived on scene and apprehended the man who was still on the train. Whole operation took less than 10 minutes just like any other normal police call.

10 minutes, huh?
How long do you think it took for Neely to break that woman's nose and orbital bone? I bet it was less than 10 minutes.

Yeah well like I’ve said now multiple times someone should’ve calmly texted 911 to alert authorities that a person was threatening people at random instead of sitting there like idiots for 10 minutes and what did you suggest…”inching away, hoping the doors would open or waiting for a big man to save” them while a lunatic broke someone’s nose.

Well at this point I’m preaching to other readers. I can no longer hope for the mentally dull to understand difficult subjects like when it’s appropriate to text 911

I ride the NYC subway 4-5 times a week. There’s not always cell service that allows you to text when you’re in a tunnel. Even if there is, there are often 2+ minutes between stops. So even if everything works perfectly, the cops are waiting on the next platform (which is not really typical - maybe if everything goes exactly right, but I would not expect this), and the person is removed from the train there, the whole car still has to sit with the deranged individual until the train arrives at the next station. This can be really terrifying, and it’s plenty of time to harm others if that’s what they want to do. It takes seconds.