Dad told us tween was rude and doesn't want anymore visits- how to handle?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So what was the rest of the visit like? Your son was clearly rude as he left, but tell us about the rest of the week.

Maybe she was involved but unpleasant.

Maybe she was wonderful.

Your dad clearly doesn't remember much about 11 year olds, so I hope you can find a way to keep this from escalating.


DS says it was a good visit and my dad's wife is a nice lady. He just doesn't seem to care for her as she isn't my mom. I told him that is unacceptable and he just goes "Yeah ok mom". My husband jokes that maybe my dad and his wife were "just too Asian" for DS but I don't find it funny. I think DS knows he can get the support of his dad and downplay bad behavior.



Is this visit the first time your DS has spent time with your dad's wife? How well do they know one another?
Sounds like maybe DS wasn't prepared for the expectations of his grandfather and step-grandmother. Also sounds like maybe they are forging a new relationship and that can be difficult when the child is there alone w/o parents to help. I would likely have DS write a thank you note to both your dad and his wife thanking them for having him, and maybe suggesting something he'd like to do with them in the future. Move forward and don't dwell on the past. While you can apologize, I don't know that I'd force your son to, not sure it would help move the relationship forward. I'd also try to spend time with your son and your dad together to help build the relationship.


Yes, my son has known her for about eight years. I personally like her too - I'm quite happy she and my dad met because she makes him happy. When we visited in the past, I would be there to remind DS to say goodbye to everyone and he was compliant. Now that he's growing older, he's much less compliant. Given that I wasn't there, he couldn't care less. This was his first time going on his own though I don't think that is an excuse. I spoke to my dad again and he's explain that hosting DS got a bit too much. DS would sleep late and wake up past noon time and play games on his phone even though they were trying to engage him in a conversation. I was cringing on the phone while he was telling me all this.


Now I'm a little more sympathetic to your dad's reaction. It drives me crazy when my DS tries to sleep in after noon and then is glued to his phone. Does he do this at home? If he does, then you really should have set ground rules for him, given that you know this would not be acceptable behavior in your dad's eyes. If DS tried to do this, my mom would tell him nicely to get up and get off his phone and he would comply because he gets along with her. If DH's stepdad told him, he would be resistant and would try to stay on his phone. He doesn't like DH's stepdad. When he visits DH's mom and stepdad, I set ground rules, and I explain that he needs to be respectful of DH's stepdad. Not negotiable. If I didn't explain and set clear rules, I think he'd do what your DS did. You know your dad, you really should have followed up with your son daily, if necessary.


Yes, I have told him off about such behavior as well but it falls on deaf ears. He will put his phone away at the moment but then uses it again. That's why I'm not mad at my dad because I understand his disappointment and I blame myself. You sound like a more effective parent than I am!


Then, you tell Dad to take the phone or turn it off.


What good would that do? Then the kid will be really resentful. Better to be bored than resentful. I have a grandson who is also like this and we have also stopped visits. Kids in this generation just don't value old people like us.


Not necessarily true. We take out 14 and 16year olds phones whenever we travel with them, whether it’s too a relative or not. They can use them in the car/plane, we give them back if we are going to be separated and might need to contact them, and we give them back for photo purposes only at tourist sites (one strike and you lose it). That’s it. Turns out that they read, play cards, get outside, go out to eat and have mealtime conversations, and socialize with relatives just fine. They even admitted once that after the first day, it was nice to take a break from FB, texts, social media, etc.

Set clear rules up front. And deal with a day of crankiness during electronics withdrawal. And then it’s fine— even for our ADHD son who acts like an electronics addict.
Anonymous
He is only 11 for goodness sake! It was on oversight on his part.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I think it's fine to make him apologize. BUT, I know plenty of kids who in the chaos of packing and changing camps or vacation spots, may just run out w/o thinking. I think it would be better to speak to him first and explain why it was rude, as well as that it hurt the wife's feelings. Hopefully he will understand. Then ask him to apologize.

Your father is acting like a child. Never visit again? Way over the top and, quite frankly, a dick move. I'd also have a conversation with dear old dad about his reaction and expectations. And it would be me seriously considering whether I'd want to leave my kid with someone who reacts in that way.


Did you read the part where OP said that DS slept in until after noon and then just stayed on his phone while his grandparents were trying to interact with him? Then he left without saying bye. He is only 11, but I can see where an elderly person from a culture where kids are expected to show significant respect to elders being overwhelmed by this behavior for 5 days straight. I don't see this as "a dick move," I see it as a reaction of a frustrated and disappointment older man. OP doesn't need to chastise her DS, but she can explain her father's culture and that he really hurt their feelings. I wouldn't relay what her dad actually said because it's not necessary.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think it's fine to make him apologize. BUT, I know plenty of kids who in the chaos of packing and changing camps or vacation spots, may just run out w/o thinking. I think it would be better to speak to him first and explain why it was rude, as well as that it hurt the wife's feelings. Hopefully he will understand. Then ask him to apologize.

Your father is acting like a child. Never visit again? Way over the top and, quite frankly, a dick move. I'd also have a conversation with dear old dad about his reaction and expectations. And it would be me seriously considering whether I'd want to leave my kid with someone who reacts in that way.


Did you read the part where OP said that DS slept in until after noon and then just stayed on his phone while his grandparents were trying to interact with him? Then he left without saying bye. He is only 11, but I can see where an elderly person from a culture where kids are expected to show significant respect to elders being overwhelmed by this behavior for 5 days straight. I don't see this as "a dick move," I see it as a reaction of a frustrated and disappointment older man. OP doesn't need to chastise her DS, but she can explain her father's culture and that he really hurt their feelings. I wouldn't relay what her dad actually said because it's not necessary.


+1. I think many white American parents really don't understand where The OP's dad is coming from. He gets automatically slammed when it's the grandson who appears unenthusiastic and didn't even say goodbye to his wife. Why put up with such B.S? Nothing wrong with having standards of proper conduct in your home people.
Anonymous
Nothing wrong with have conduct standards. Everything wrong with cutting the poor kid off.
There's a reason we don't do thing the old ways anymore.
Anonymous
Did she try to make your son eat German food?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Nothing wrong with have conduct standards. Everything wrong with cutting the poor kid off.
There's a reason we don't do thing the old ways anymore.


I don't know if the new ways of non-disciplining kids are an improvement. Previous generations have survived many a scolding.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:

+1. I think many white American parents really don't understand where The OP's dad is coming from. He gets automatically slammed when it's the grandson who appears unenthusiastic and didn't even say goodbye to his wife. Why put up with such B.S? Nothing wrong with having standards of proper conduct in your home people.


OP's father can have whatever standards he wants. What he can't have is those standards AND a good relationship with his grandson involving visits to his home.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Did she try to make your son eat German food?




Unt he vill like it!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Did she try to make your son eat German food?


This is OP. No, I asked my son what he ate and he said a lot of ice cream which he doesn't get to do at our house. He is honestly very small for his age and a very picky eater. My dad said they just let him be. He's Chinese so why do you ask about German food? My dad did take DS out for dim sum and DS said he tried some dumplings but didn't like them.
Anonymous
I get the impression that the DS just doesn't like being with OP's dad because of cultural preferences.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I get the impression that the DS just doesn't like being with OP's dad because of cultural preferences.


Yes, it's politically incorrect but it could be the truth. OP's dad comes across as being authoritarian which is fine in Asian culture but the child doesn't sound like he's used to it. So he's happily decamped to grandma.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Was there any activity for your 11 year old DS at your dad's (day camp?) or was he just home with grandparents all week? If the latter, it's kind of understandable he was on the phone and playing video games a lot - he was probably bored out of his mind! I don't think I'd send him by himself anymore - visit your dad with him and keep the visit short to just couple days.


This. I can't think of anything more boring for an 11 yr old. Were there any other kids around to play with? Old Asian grandparents don't "play" but there are a lot of expectations about behavior that can get grueling after a while even for an adult.

I am Asian, Korean, born there and when we have family gatherings the kids interact and play with each other. I would never send my kid by himself for a week with my parents unless they were also hosting his cousins. No wonder your DS was on the phone and playing video games.

Have your DS apologize to stepgrandma and never send him over there again. Problem solved.
Anonymous
Regarding the it saying goodbye piece.

Even as an adult sometimes i forget to say goodbye to peolple. Sometimes it’s because I am being rushed and forget, or others I don’t really have an excuse it just slips my mind. Then i realize after the fact I should have.

I was raised to be polite, say please and thank you etc. this is just a flaw I haven’t been able to fix bc it’s not intentional.

Also, maybe your son feels awkward around the wife and felt uncomfortable saying goodbye?


I also wonder if this is the step grandmother who posted earlier (sorry if this has been mentioned)
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Regarding the it saying goodbye piece.

Even as an adult sometimes i forget to say goodbye to peolple. Sometimes it’s because I am being rushed and forget, or others I don’t really have an excuse it just slips my mind. Then i realize after the fact I should have.

I was raised to be polite, say please and thank you etc. this is just a flaw I haven’t been able to fix bc it’s not intentional.

Also, maybe your son feels awkward around the wife and felt uncomfortable saying goodbye?


I also wonder if this is the step grandmother who posted earlier (sorry if this has been mentioned)


You sound like you have ADD. Who forgets to say goodbye?
post reply Forum Index » Tweens and Teens
Message Quick Reply
Go to: