Hang in there, OP. I'm the PP with the 10 month "helpful" relative. I'm having flashbacks reading your posts. Her not leaving the house ever and expecting to be waited on. Saying how glad she was that I was back from the hospital after giving birth because she didn't have any clean clothes and the laundry had really piled up while I was gone. Sending me on errands because I was going out anyway (to be with my preemies in the NICU and drop off breastmilk). I could go on and on with the outrageously selfish and unhelpful behaviors. I very gently suggested that she leave early on but she cried and said she couldn't believe she had flown all this way to help and I was throwing her out. She had helped raise me and I was mortified that I had made her cry. So, I caved and she stayed on... and on and on. After repeatedly asking for help and not getting any, I praised her cooking to anyone who would listen and finally convinced her to cook dinner several times a week. Her choice what to cook. I also ended up hiring a nanny for my older child and upping the housecleaner to three times a week to get through that time. In the end, I was very direct and very firm: You have to leave. You MUST go. I managed to get her out with only minimal drama. But when she got home, she called to let me know she wanted to send another of her relatives to stay with me and help. I lost my shit and we have not spoken since. I deeply regret yelling at her even though she did deserve it. If I had it to do over again, I would have found a way to vent my frustrations. I probably should have posted here instead of blowing up at her. Not sure where you guys are from but I come from a culture where it is important to respect your elders. From that perspective I say don't ask her to leave. Work around her and get help if you need it. Hold your tongue and count down the days. Wine helps. |
| Don’t ask her to leave if it rocks the boat. But don’t act like the hostess. Give her direct things to do beginning everything with “I’m glad you’re here to help. Please make the salad.” That reminds her that she’s supposed to be fulfilling a promise to you. Don’t do extra for her like PP mentioned as in running errands, doing her laundry. For that you say “I simply don’t have the time. We already need help with these things. Thanks for handling it yourself.” |
| Is she at least helping take care of your DH? |
| My mom came when my kids were 10, 6 and a 3 yo who had to be taken to the hospital 9 times in 4 months, admitted 6 times, the last for 5 weeks in a hospital over an hour away because the closer hospital couldn't help him anymore. My mom stayed for 2 months of the 4 months. It ruined my relationship with both my parents. I did therapy for 4 years, for 2 of those years, my mom and I did family therapy which was recommended by my therapist, but with a different therapist in my mom's town with me on the phone. After the 2 years, my mom quit the therapy and now we just email and my dh calls her for me. There is a mom like the mom described here in the book "Leave Me" by Gayle Forman, highly recommend. |
You MUST share more details of this story and how it led to ruined relationships. |
| previous poster: My 3 yo had uncontrolled seizures. Dh and I had to take him to the hospital together because someone had to sit in the back with him. So my mom had to stay with our 6 yo and 10 yo. I kept the nanny the whole time (I work FT at a demanding job) so my mom was only on duty after 6 pm. |
|
I think you have too many expectations of how your parents can help you n your house.
My mom and dad came from another country and helped with my newborns for several months. I had hired help for cleaning and also outsourced other stuff, so my parents were invaluable with supervising. If my mom asked if she could help, I handed her and dad the task of holding the baby and sitting on the couch and watching TV. My toddler was more than happy to snuggle with them and watch cartoons. Of course, having additional people meant that we were buying more groceries, cooking more, doing more laundry etc. But by and large, their presence was a moral support to DH and I, and our kids were more than happy snuggling with them and reading books or watching TV. They cannot be expected to take over the running of your household. I would often request if my mom could fold laundry while watching TV, and she was happy to do that. Another thing she was very good at - chopping vegetables at the dining table. I would make their breakfast and coffee, and then take a big basket of washed veggies and also put the cutting board, knife etc on the dining table and say that if she wanted to help, could she cut the veggies because I plan to cook XYZ for dinner. As they became more comfortable in our home, they were pitching in a lot more. My dad would love to walk down to the nearest grocery store every day, he loved to iron all the clothes while watching war documentaries on history channel, mom loved to massage and bathe the babies. My kids are super close to my parents because what they got from them was a lot of patience and willingness to spend time with them. My parents would sit for hours in toy room with the kids while my children played. They watched their serials while my kids napped snuggled with them. I knew my kids were loved and protected. I knew that my mom and dad would keep an eye on the people who came to clean the house, I knew they would iron every last scrap of cloth in the house (my kitchen towels were also ironed!!). Basically, the successful grandparents visits are ones where the grandparents are spending time with the kids at home, and keeping an eye on things. Our parents are not great at functioning like hired service providers. They need a lot of instructions and usually balk at doing things that they fear they will mess up. And each time they visited, I had to ease them into using all the appliances, turning on the TV, explaining them the various faucets etc of the bathrooms etc. What we take for granted is overwhelming for them. |
You sound like a healthy, well-adjusted adult. |
This is a completely different situation and irrelevant here.. |
Oh, ok. I will try and address the concerns of everyone who hate their parents and ILs. Y'all have horrible parents and ILs. They are basically leeches who live to make your life miserable. Throw them out of your house and never ever speak to them again. Happy? |
Np..thanks for such a great reply, i get impatient sometimes...this is such a great reminder |
I mean… it sounds like a nice visit, but pretty much none of what you described is actually help. Great for maintaining and building relationships, sure, but that’s not the kind of help most new parents require. And I am glad you were in a place financially where you could outsource a lot of things and have grandparents focused on guiding the help and snuggling kids, but we weren’t in the same place when we had our first - all the house stuff was on us. So having my MIL in the house was basically just having another person to cook for and clean up after. It was extra stress for me at the time that I did not need while also recovering from delivery, struggling with breastfeeding, and going through the baby blues. The second time around I wore the baby in a sling while taking care of my toddler, outsourced the cleaning, and life was so much easier without an extra adult to worry about. |
Not horrible. Just ones who cannot be counted on to help out in any practical way. When they visit, they play with the kids. The kids have fun. That’s all we expect. When we need real help, we pay for it. |
Are you kidding? Folding laundry, keeping small kids preoccupied and helping with meal prep is not actually help? Most new parents would be very happy with that kind of help. |
This is just sad. |