Brunch at friends house, do you take home what you brought?

[Anonymous]

A potluck you take what you brought

A hosted meal where people have brought contributions…Always ask the host if they want it and as the host always politely refuse.

Only exception is opened alcohol (leave it) or a host gift (wine, birthday cake etc)

That’s how it works in my friend circle. Who wants to be left with a table of other people food to clean up and put away only to waste it later.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

I agree with all of this—at the same time, I think the host should always offer for people to take things home. I’ve been at parties where there are a ton of leftovers and the hosts are like, “Well, we’re going to be eating well next week!” Just assuming all the food will be left to them. I think that’s unbelievably rude.

No, that’s not rude. People brought the food to the host’s party. It now belongs to the host. S/he can distribute it, keep it, do whatever s/he wants with it. Guests have relinquished control. The only thing they can claim are the dish3s they brought the food in.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

I agree with all of this—at the same time, I think the host should always offer for people to take things home. I’ve been at parties where there are a ton of leftovers and the hosts are like, “Well, we’re going to be eating well next week!” Just assuming all the food will be left to them. I think that’s unbelievably rude.

No, that’s not rude. People brought the food to the host’s party. It now belongs to the host. S/he can distribute it, keep it, do whatever s/he wants with it. Guests have relinquished control. The only thing they can claim are the dish3s they brought the food in.

I think it’s nice if the hosts stuck with lots of left overs offer food to families with lots of teens or kids to spread it around. Especially if you know there’s no way they will eat all of it. It’s not about “control” but sharing the bounty.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

It seems super rude to me, too. The host has dibs. Then the person who brought it gets to decide to offer it to other guests or take it home.

I don't know... if you are asking people to bring food to your party, you are hosting a potluck. The etiquette for a potluck is that everyone takes their items home. You can't have it both ways.

OP did not ask them to bring food; they offered or asked what they could bring. She had planned to provide all the food. That is not a potluck.

OP did not tell them no. So this is a potluck. “Just bring yourselves” is what you say if you provide all the food.

Many people will bring something anyway since they were taught to never go to someone's house empty-handed. That doesn't make it a potluck.

It does though. If you’re having a brunch and friends show up with a casserole, dozen bagels and cream cheese, box of bagels, and champagne you’re having a pot luck b/c all those foods will be servied.

1) If the rules of potluck etiquette are different (I personally don't think they are but if they are...) then it does matter whether or not it was framed as a potluck

2) If a bunch of people come to something they were invited to that was not a potluck with extra food it is even more rude to then leave with the leftovers as if not framed as a potluck the add ons are just gifts for the host.

If you’re not hosting a potluck then tell everyone to bring nothing you have everything. Otherwise, surprise, you’re hosting a potluck.

No, guests don’t get to change the rules of engagement in a host’s house. And you don’t seem to understand that people often bring dishes against the host’s express request that they bring nothing. They’re actually trying to be polite, having been taught never to arrive at an event empty-handed, but their behavior does not change a hosted brunch into a potluck. And as the host I’d do whatever I wanted with the unasked for dishes—keep if yummy, graciously send back if not so tasty.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

I agree with all of this—at the same time, I think the host should always offer for people to take things home. I’ve been at parties where there are a ton of leftovers and the hosts are like, “Well, we’re going to be eating well next week!” Just assuming all the food will be left to them. I think that’s unbelievably rude.

No, that’s not rude. People brought the food to the host’s party. It now belongs to the host. S/he can distribute it, keep it, do whatever s/he wants with it. Guests have relinquished control. The only thing they can claim are the dish3s they brought the food in.

I think it’s nice if the hosts stuck with lots of left overs offer food to families with lots of teens or kids to spread it around. Especially if you know there’s no way they will eat all of it. It’s not about “control” but sharing the bounty.

It is nice, but it’s not rude to make another choice.

[Anonymous]

OP here. This happens at all my hosted brunches or dinners with this group. It’s not a potluck. And this is like 4 groups of friends all taking their items back. Half eaten guacamole, even scooping out of the serving dish. Half bag of chips. Sometimes they ask if you’re not going to eat this I’ll take it back. But I feel like it’s rude for me to say yes please leave it. So I say they can have it back but just the fact that they take it back or ask I feel is rude and don’t know if there is anything I can politely say about it. Oh well. Thank you for making me feel normal lol!

[Anonymous]

It's rude to assume they can take it, but sometimes I will tell people to when I host. No one ever takes back unopened bottles of wine - that is animal behavior.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

I agree with all of this—at the same time, I think the host should always offer for people to take things home. I’ve been at parties where there are a ton of leftovers and the hosts are like, “Well, we’re going to be eating well next week!” Just assuming all the food will be left to them. I think that’s unbelievably rude.

No, that’s not rude. People brought the food to the host’s party. It now belongs to the host. S/he can distribute it, keep it, do whatever s/he wants with it. Guests have relinquished control. The only thing they can claim are the dish3s they brought the food in.

I think it’s nice if the hosts stuck with lots of left overs offer food to families with lots of teens or kids to spread it around. Especially if you know there’s no way they will eat all of it. It’s not about “control” but sharing the bounty.

It is nice, but it’s not rude to make another choice.

Can look greedy for a family of 2 or 3 to keep far more of the food than they can possibly eat. A dish to share isn’t a hostess gift.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

It seems super rude to me, too. The host has dibs. Then the person who brought it gets to decide to offer it to other guests or take it home.

I don't know... if you are asking people to bring food to your party, you are hosting a potluck. The etiquette for a potluck is that everyone takes their items home. You can't have it both ways.

OP did not ask them to bring food; they offered or asked what they could bring. She had planned to provide all the food. That is not a potluck.

OP did not tell them no. So this is a potluck. “Just bring yourselves” is what you say if you provide all the food.

Many people will bring something anyway since they were taught to never go to someone's house empty-handed. That doesn't make it a potluck.

It does though. If you’re having a brunch and friends show up with a casserole, dozen bagels and cream cheese, box of bagels, and champagne you’re having a pot luck b/c all those foods will be servied.

1) If the rules of potluck etiquette are different (I personally don't think they are but if they are...) then it does matter whether or not it was framed as a potluck

2) If a bunch of people come to something they were invited to that was not a potluck with extra food it is even more rude to then leave with the leftovers as if not framed as a potluck the add ons are just gifts for the host.

If you’re not hosting a potluck then tell everyone to bring nothing you have everything. Otherwise, surprise, you’re hosting a potluck.

No, guests don’t get to change the rules of engagement in a host’s house. And you don’t seem to understand that people often bring dishes against the host’s express request that they bring nothing. They’re actually trying to be polite, having been taught never to arrive at an event empty-handed, but their behavior does not change a hosted brunch into a potluck. And as the host I’d do whatever I wanted with the unasked for dishes—keep if yummy, graciously send back if not so tasty.

So let them take back the dish you never wanted in the first place. “Please, take it with you” can be perceived as nobody really even liked it anyway. Why do you even want it?

[Anonymous]

Absolutely not! That would be so tacky. It wouldn't even occur to me and I'd be shocked if anyone did it in front of me.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:OP here. This happens at all my hosted brunches or dinners with this group. It’s not a potluck. And this is like 4 groups of friends all taking their items back. Half eaten guacamole, even scooping out of the serving dish. Half bag of chips. Sometimes they ask if you’re not going to eat this I’ll take it back. But I feel like it’s rude for me to say yes please leave it. So I say they can have it back but just the fact that they take it back or ask I feel is rude and don’t know if there is anything I can politely say about it. Oh well. Thank you for making me feel normal lol!

Sounds like there is confusion in your group. You seem to think you’re hosting a brunch and they are all used to contributing something potluck style.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:You take your own food back only if the host urges you to.

Your friends lack social graces, OP.

Agree

[Anonymous]

We do not have a lot of fridge or storage space so I’m happy to have people take back what they brought. But if you are going to eat the leftovers, then just say so when the night is ending - “I’m excited for these leftovers tomorrow.” And hopefully your friends take the hint.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

I agree with all of this—at the same time, I think the host should always offer for people to take things home. I’ve been at parties where there are a ton of leftovers and the hosts are like, “Well, we’re going to be eating well next week!” Just assuming all the food will be left to them. I think that’s unbelievably rude.

No, that’s not rude. People brought the food to the host’s party. It now belongs to the host. S/he can distribute it, keep it, do whatever s/he wants with it. Guests have relinquished control. The only thing they can claim are the dish3s they brought the food in.

I think it’s nice if the hosts stuck with lots of left overs offer food to families with lots of teens or kids to spread it around. Especially if you know there’s no way they will eat all of it. It’s not about “control” but sharing the bounty.

It is nice, but it’s not rude to make another choice.

Can look greedy for a family of 2 or 3 to keep far more of the food than they can possibly eat. A dish to share isn’t a hostess gift.

So? If you don’t want the host to keep it, make less or don’t bring it. OP said it wasn’t a potluck, you did this unbidden and for no reason. Now it’s hers to do with as she wants.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I ask the host what they prefer.
What I don't understand is when other people (the guests) descend upon leftover food and take it home without invitation from the host. To me, that's super rude!

It seems super rude to me, too. The host has dibs. Then the person who brought it gets to decide to offer it to other guests or take it home.

I don't know... if you are asking people to bring food to your party, you are hosting a potluck. The etiquette for a potluck is that everyone takes their items home. You can't have it both ways.

OP did not ask them to bring food; they offered or asked what they could bring. She had planned to provide all the food. That is not a potluck.

OP did not tell them no. So this is a potluck. “Just bring yourselves” is what you say if you provide all the food.

Many people will bring something anyway since they were taught to never go to someone's house empty-handed. That doesn't make it a potluck.

It does though. If you’re having a brunch and friends show up with a casserole, dozen bagels and cream cheese, box of bagels, and champagne you’re having a pot luck b/c all those foods will be servied.

1) If the rules of potluck etiquette are different (I personally don't think they are but if they are...) then it does matter whether or not it was framed as a potluck

2) If a bunch of people come to something they were invited to that was not a potluck with extra food it is even more rude to then leave with the leftovers as if not framed as a potluck the add ons are just gifts for the host.

If you’re not hosting a potluck then tell everyone to bring nothing you have everything. Otherwise, surprise, you’re hosting a potluck.

No, guests don’t get to change the rules of engagement in a host’s house. And you don’t seem to understand that people often bring dishes against the host’s express request that they bring nothing. They’re actually trying to be polite, having been taught never to arrive at an event empty-handed, but their behavior does not change a hosted brunch into a potluck. And as the host I’d do whatever I wanted with the unasked for dishes—keep if yummy, graciously send back if not so tasty.

So let them take back the dish you never wanted in the first place. “Please, take it with you” can be perceived as nobody really even liked it anyway. Why do you even want it?

Why do YOU want it back? You have to have brought it assuming it might all be eaten. You should never bring more food than you can bear to part with.