Exactly. Anyone who claims it is agony to listen to their mother's complaints over a telephone and from 2K miles away does not know what true agony is. Any "actual psychologist" who refuses to recognize that adult children can also dish out abuse isn't worth the paper their degree is written on and is just perpetuating their own biased bottom line which is ... MONEY. I'd like to know how billions of other people in the world, of varying cultures, all seem to maintain relationships with their family members. But in DCUM-land, it is always justified to jettison anyone who doesn't meet your every need, recognize your every boundary, acknowledge every misdeed, and apologize forever for every failing. |
That's a really nice suggestion. |
OP, sending you warmth, strength, and praise for reaching out when you needed connection. I hope you will continue to find what you need, even if not always at this site.
Best wishes! Take care of yourself through the upcoming holidays, too. That can be an especially challenging time in these situations. |
+1 |
I would only reinforce if she starts treating you with dignity. if she continues to behave the way she does, sending cards tells her it works and she should continue and if she wants more attention she should get really obnoxious. |
Have you actually studies other cultures? in the very "family oriented" cultures around the world, when people are not allowed to protect themselves from abusive behavior the result ranges from physical ailments (less taboo to admit so they just suffer until they are physically ill) to suicide. Everyone does not just suck it up and smile and somehow sweep abuse under the rug. There is tremendous suffering and misery. Nobody here had said children cannot be abusive, but this is not what the post is about. If your suspicion is correct and OP is abusive then they absolutely should end their relation ship. If a relationship results in mutual abuse it is unhealthy and must cease. It is not worth the cost of intensive daily therapy to fix especially when OP is this miserable. I certainly hope you are wrong and OP isn't abusive, but if she is, the kindest thing she can do for her mother is set her mom free and move on. |
Yes, be careful how you treat people. If you try to manipulate people into tolerating abusive behavior for fear the abuser will commit suicide, then you really are quite disturbed. That used to be a classic borderline personality disorder trait. If you abandon me for yiou terrible, I will kill myself!!!!!!! That is holding someone hostage. To the poster who tried to insist people cannot draw boundaries and keep stepping back if poor behavior does not change, you really need to get help. There is some disturbing reason you are telling people their sanity does not matter. If you hate your child so much that you cannot treat her or him with dignity and respect, then why would you not want to set her free? Holding someone hostage because you refuse to treat your mental illness is not OK. Please get help. |
You are gaslighting. Stop! |
OP, my mom also abused me mentally, emotionally and physically when I was a child. (PP who does not believe abuse claims, I was hospitalized and then placed in foster care as a result of one particularly nasty episode. I was eventually returned to the home and the abuse continued and got worse until I finally left home at 16.)
My mother and I were estranged for most of my life but she has been back in my life since I had kids. I informed her that I would not tolerate her doing and saying certain things but she continued anyway. These conversations would leave me distraught, in tears and bring back all of the trauma from my childhood. It was as if I was a terrified 6 year old all over again. At first, I would remind her of my boundaries but she would continue. After about three years of this repeated emotional upheaval one day I just snapped and cursed her out. I told her everything I had ever wanted to say and ended the conversation not in a nice way. And then I hung up on her. This is a big deal because I had always been very obedient and respectful. She called every person in the family crying and hysterical to let them know just what a horrible, terrible daughter I am. I was defiant and God was going to punish me. We didn't talk for six months. Then one day she called me as though nothing had happened and we had a very pleasant conversation. Since then, she has been very respectful towards me and I don't dread talking to her anymore. I'm not saying you should curse your mom out. I felt a great deal of shame over my actions but our relationship is a thousand times better so I can live with it. I am saying you should very firmly defend your boundaries. Do not stay on the phone longer than you want to. If you need to hang up, hang up. If you need to take a break then do it. She is still abusing you now but you are a grown up now and you have the power to change that. |
That's very sad to hear. |
![]() |
Maybe the point isn't to break her. Maybe the point is to make things better. For both of them. |
That's your interpretation. Where does it ACTUALLY say that in what was ACTUALLY posted? |
Right. Encouraging and supporting one another in treating each other well is a good way to do that. And good boundaries are the best way to do that. |
On what planet does that make sense? You can't "set her mom free" that is LAUGHABLE. That's like saying you should cut off your arm or leg and set it free. It does no good to you and it does no good to your arm or leg. She will never be free of her mother. Even if she cuts her off, she will always feel that missing limb. A better solution is to learn how to deal with her troubled, broken mother in a way that doesn't harm her. But posters won't let anyone make suggestions like that. Their commitment is to WINNING against the parent, not making things okay. Like toddlers. Arrested development, and should not be giving anyone advice. |