Am I wrong in thinking that, if your DD is really at one of those schools mentioned and wants to go to NESCAC or Ivy, that her best bet would be to focus on school, grades, teacher relationships, etc. as a way to get admitted, instead of such an intense focus on lacrosse? All this focus on lacrosse as a way into college when you're blessed with the opportunity to attend such a great "prep" school just seems like a bit of a waste to me. I say this as a woman who focused on high school (and not recruiting) while playing lacrosse on a state championship high school team, then walked on at a D1 and had both a great lacrosse and academic experience in college. I just feel like all you parents would be more likely to say, boy I wish I had encouraged my DD to be more engaged at school than the opposite. From an outsider's perspective, you all just sound a little too wound up in your daughters' lacrosse. Sorry. |
Our Daughter plays at M&D now, and has already had colleges speak with us about her. She is not the best player in the world and plays for their "Red" team or "B" team. The problem with M&D is, they lock their teams and hold no tryouts if you are not on a team by the start of high school. They hold invitation tryouts if a roster spot opens up. Right, but PP's DD is in 8th now so its her last year to make a top club team. She should be focusing on trying to make M&D, Skywalkers or Capital this August. Capital "locks" their teams in the same fashion. |
It is very different today than when you were in college. Its rare to walk on at a top school these days and girls like my DD want to play lacrosse at a top school. Going Ivy and playing lax are her goal, not mine, not her dads, hers. These girls still have to have top grades and tests scores. I assure you, no one is focusing on lax at the expense of school. They have both and they get the benefit of knowing much earlier where they are gong to college so they can put all their energy into their school work and sport. If anything suffers, its their social life but, something has to give and its their choice. |
NP from above who wants to say that it is different strokes for different folks. The poster was asking for a daughter who is looking at competitive schools, Ivies and the like, so the presumption is that the student is already performing at a high level academically. The parent imo seems to be asking for advice relative to the daughter playing lax at an elite level while at high caliber college. Even though I'm a dad I'm totally behind this kid's Girl Power and I'm certainly willing to impart any information I have to help someone else achieve their goals, which means I respond on an anonymous board. FWIW we have two at Ivies playing their sports and a third heading to an Ivy next year and he will play his sport there as well. Our kids are thriving with the high level academic and athletic competition. We're not forcing it and it doesn't seem to me that the poster is, either. Honestly, I think the music parents are completely insane and don't get me started on the theater parents. Yowsa. |
|
Thanks PP. I'm the parent of the daughter asking and you and the other earlier poster are totally correct in that she is already a top student at a very well known school that sends many to Ivy and competitors. She will continue to focus on school and should have grades and scores that make her competitive for excellent schools but she really wants to find a lacrosse program that will allow her to enjoy playing at a relatively high level while also attending a college she thinks will offer a strong education. We just want to help support her in this and since we haven't gone through the process before we are wondering how best to pursue.
She will try out for all top clubs and is ready to move this coming fall depending on what options she has. Based on her current skills she should have a good shot at Capital (Blue or Orange are both fine) but she will attend other try outs and can always stay at her current club since they place girls at top D1 and Ivy all the time (just further away). Thanks again for the input, very much appreciated! |
Good luck to your daughter!! |
You probably also are aware of this but the Ivies look for players who are fairly tall. I played Ivy lacrosse in the late 80s - early 1990s and have been back to lacrosse-related functions and the current squad from my alma mater look positively Amazonian in terms of size and strength! (Smart and attractive and funny, also.) Smaller players with good skills often end up at DIII now just based on body type, so that's something to take into account as well as you are trying to be realistic in projecting a future path. |
Current Ivy women's lax parent and it is my perception that this 'fairly tall' guidance does not necessarily reflect the heights of the players we have seen over the past few years at Ivy games. It may well have been true in the past. Although there is veracity to the perception because I remember that when our girls were younger there was a school team in Baltimore whose girls comparatively always looked much taller. I think there is the same argument in many sports about using a bigger size as a way to power through versus a smaller size to be nimble and fleet. Both have their advantages. |
It's funny because I assumed this too but then I looked at the rosters of several Ivys and found it to be a mixed bag. Some schools clearly want tall (Brown as I recall) but others had several girls under 5'4", which surprised me. For D and M they tended to be taller but attack was more average height at many schools. You're likely correct in saying that tall does help though! |
|
Skill set is the number one priority for recruiters. Size does matter if you are very skilled at your position. I'll take a 6' 170 player over a 5'4" 110 if the skill set is the same. But the smaller players tend to be much quicker.
' ' |
True and infact there is a real shift going on right now in women's lax as schools try pitting the taller, larger players against the smaller, more nimble players. Will be interesting to watch it play out over the next few years. |
They had a Navy commit, but he jumped ship to another high school. |
|
Heights had a Albany commit too, but he left for St Andrew's. The Heights has had some quality players but they seem to transfer.
Anyone know why the transfers? I believe if they could keep their players they could challenge some of the top local teams. |
|
Heights had an Albany commit too, but he left for St Andrew's. The Heights has had some quality players but they seem to transfer.
Anyone know why the transfers? I believe if they could keep their players they could challenge some of the top local teams. |
I am pretty sure the goalie transferred to Landon. |