No, it's about as moronic as saying that people who get butt implants get all the same exact bodily benefits without any of the "suffering" of actual training and fitness. I hope pp was trolling, because if serious, they're really deep into the delusion. |
Huh. So you really are furious about these drugs. Well, I wish you some peace. That must be hard. |
Nope. And where you getting "furious" from? Do you know what that word means?" You do you, but it's not the same, no matter how you spin it. Peace out. I'm going to bed to wake up at 4:30 for a 5am run, which I embraced and taught myself in the journey of losing and maintaining a 60lb weightloss. It will suck with the humidity, but damn will it feel so good to do something with my body I couldn't do before. Have a nice weekend. |
The people that can now exercise and run will have that same feeling now that they have lost weight with Ozempic as well. As they say win-win for all the weight losers. |
FWIW, I’m a fat woman and I really, really want Wegovy and others in this class of drugs to be safe. I am concerned about the mental health effects of these medications, though. One of my old friends from high school has bipolar illness and just shared on social media last week that she admitted herself to inpatient treatment for suicidal ideation and severe depression recently. As a result, she stopped taking the Wegivy she had begun taking. Her clinicians for her brain illness said that they had had several patients on that class of meds have extreme emotional dystegularion followed by suicidal symptoms and had to stop taking them as a result.
I’ve been following a lot of the very promising research on ketogenic therapies for bio polar illness and depression, and it’s clear that diet changes can have a huge impact on brain function and cognition. It scares the heck out of me that these medications could worsen my depression, but I am SO envious of those who have had success with them and wish that for myself. |
You could always start a low dose and stay there rather than moving up. And I mean this with love, but the bipolar people I have known, especially when they have been have been hospitalized, the “news” they bear from doctors is best taken with a grain of salt. |
+1 My DH and I have lived this up close with a bipolar relative whose had also been hospitalized. There is a very large gap in what our relative says on social media about health and what the doctors say and what reality is. That having been said, I would search out an endocrinologist who has been treating diabetic patients with this class of medication for ten years or so, and ask your specific question. They might have insight over their patient populations. This is a powerful drug. People are starting to use it off label for alcoholism too. It makes sense that for some people, there are some mental impacts, but there are also mental impacts of untreated obesity, particularly given the “willpower” narrative. Good luck. |
+1. “Natural” weight loss isn’t unnecessary suffering. It’s an opportunity, actually! Also the point above about these tools making us beholden to Big Pharma made me realize that, every time I go to the grocery, I’m beholden to Big Ag. I’m going to hunt & gather from now on. |
I run & lift weights and neither have any real effect on my weight. I’ve always been skinny with or without exercise. You can (and should!) enjoy the benefits of exercise without tying them to weight gain, loss, or maintenance. |
But weight loss is a big motivator. I've always been skinny, too, but I started exercising after I had my first child and wanted to lose the pregnancy weight. I continue to exercise because it helps with my mental health. I don't know if the continued exercise is why I remain thin, but I suspect it helps. |
It might be but I think the key to not getting fat is not getting fat. Ride those genetics and don’t get fat. Truly once the cascade of metabolic and potentially neurological changes (https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/12/health/obesity-changes-brain-wellness/index.html) happens, it’s a different thing entirely. |
three cases of patients on the drugs thinking about suicide or self-harm. No one monitors this among gen pop not already under the care of a doctor. |
Have you ever had a consensual relationship with anyone, or did the damage inflicted on you by Society At Large for your involuntary corpulence prevent that? And does finding “cute clothes” (sz 14 at Loft) for the time being make up for it? |
Sorry, but it's not all about you. You don't get to ignore the experience of people who successfully lost and maintained large weightloss all on their own. You want to take a drug or get surgery? Go for it. I wish you success. But the benefits of doing it on your own are incredible and unparalleled - that's WHY it's so hard. That's WHY so many people have not (yet) been able to do it. And the confidence gained from doing it on your own is incredibly valuable - who are you to dismiss it, if you have not experienced it? Go do your own journey and enjoy it, but don't pretend like the 2 are comparable. Losing weight (and maintaining) on your own is incredibly hard, and of course it's different and more valuable in some ways. |
^p. This is because you believe that somehow morality is wrapped up in being thin and fat. But in order to believe that, you have to believe that all fat people are lazy sloths and all thin people are rugged and hearty.
And that's not true |