OP can't police what other people post on social media, but she can look away. |
All the context indicates that OP's daughter was pointedly excluded because one or some of the moms do not like OP. Cliquishness is more noticeable to people who are more social (in real life and on the internet) and people who are generally very observant. People involved in high-demand religions (like Mormonism) or who attend popular mega churches often complain about church cliques. Private schools are also rife with them. They exist in toxic workplaces where nepotism plays a big part in promotion. Posters on this thread trying to gaslight OP are either the usual suspect excluders, or anti-social types who don't notice their surroundings. I am anti-social and not a joiner, but I definitely notice cliques and hangers-on. |
You alone don’t find social media toxic. Got it. |
| I have a kindergarten daughter and she/we aren’t part of a kindergarten clique. She has a few friends from her class. I made one mom friend but she has a son and my daughter and her son don’t really play together. I know some moms are friends AND their kids are also friends. I am not friends with any of these people on social media. |
| Pp here. I also have a son who is in upper elementary. He has tons of friends. By the time they are older, the moms aren’t as involved and kids make plans by themselves. I am not friends with those parents on social media either. My son has lots of friends and included in lots of hangouts. I really don’t care what other people are doing. |
+1 and to be more explicit: cliques resource hoard. That's the main difference between a clique and a friend group. Friend groups don't have to include everyone, and can be amorphous, and people have to figure out how to deal with their feelings about that. But a clique operates as a gatekeeper to resources or hierarchies. Parent cliques in elementary schools can be really harmful in this way. There was a strong clique in the PTA at our elementary school made ups of parents of older children, and they'd resource hoard for their kids. I had a child in a class with a bunch of the "younger siblings" from those families, and there were weird things that went on where, for instance, their kids were always selected for extra tutoring from teachers even if the child was testing above grade level. It's not even that I wanted my kid to go in for extra tutoring, but of course this group also became better friends because they spent more time together after school, and the teachers got to know them better because they were tutoring them. It created a caste system among the kids that was disturbing. We left that school to get away from it and my children are so much happier with a lot less social anxiety or stress. What OP is describing doesn't rise to that level, but the people in this thread who are rolling their eyes at the whole idea of cliques, or that they don't exist in adult communities, are kidding themselves. Either you've been fortunate to avoid communities with cliques, or you are in one and like it how it is. But yes, this happens. |
|
I have three kids. My oldest not popular at all but had a loyal best friend. My middle daughter very popular. My youngest in the middle somewhere.
There’s been a difference in how they are treated by moms of their classmates. My oldest had a really good friend and his mother was older and not at all interested in their social life. My middle daughter just the opposite. Since kindergarten she was invited to so many homes whether they were friends or not. Once around 9 years old she was the only girl invited to a birthday party. The boys’ mothers would tell me their sons wanted to marry her. They invited her over to help “civilize” their sons. (Not lying!). She had friends whose mothers had no problem leaving one girl out of a party, something I would never allow. By high school these mothers who so desperately wanted their girls to be popular would allow alcohol parties. They were just pieces of sh#t. The worst mother would beg me to allow my daughter to go everywhere with them. She did all of her daughter’s homework. Her daughter now has a drug habit that’s pretty bad. My youngest has friends who do their own thing but I’m much older and experienced now and won’t hesitate to call them on any hurtful exclusion or bullying. I know they have a right to go out with anyone they choose and I have a right to tell them they suck for leaving one child out. |
Maybe they see each other a lot more than than see OPs daughter. Maybe the girls and the moms just don’t feel a strong connection with OP and her DD. It doesn’t really matter. The point is, it is simply a gathering a friends. It doesn’t make them a clique bc they didn’t invite you and you feel you are entitled to be there. It isn’t exclusive since OPs daughter sometimes plays with them outside of school. But maybe other kids do too and they weren’t there either. |
And in school-based parent cliques the most hoarded resource is information. |
You have no idea if this is a clique or not. Your defense of this is bizarre. |
Neither does OP. When her daughter is included it is a group of friends, when she’s not, it’s a clique. The difference is simply if you feel entitled to be a part of something and aren’t, then it gets labeled a clique |
What you call "entitlement" may simply have been a feeling of belonging. Everybody likes to belong and few people like being confronted with the evidence that they don't belong or were excluded. It's better to be inclusive than exclusive. If you're keeping your group small and private you should also not blast it on social media or things like this happen. It used to be common manners to not talk to people about parties they weren't invited to now people do the opposite because hurt feelings are a natural byproduct to those left out. |
OMG, read your post. You sound insane. This was not happening, you just have a chip on your shoulder because your kid wasn't as smart as other kids. |
This totally happened at the elementary my kids were at verified by parents whose kids spanned over 15 years. You sound naive. |
OP did say “4 or 5 girls” in the opening post, which made me think that there was at least a little wiggle room here. It might seem like a minor detail, but if it’s 4 or 5 girls, that means that this is not always the same exact group getting together for everything. If OP had said these kids were in 4th grade, I would think differently of the whole situation. These kids just finished kindergarten and are pretty young to be tallying who is going to which play dates. OP said her daughter is “clueless” but OP is the one who is mad at being left out. OP, what is your goal here? Is it to help your daughter cultivate friendships? Or to be included by the other moms of your daughter’s friends? Getting mad at being left out will accomplish neither. |