No, I'm just a woman who's 5'4" and doesn't want a guy hulking over me. The only people who use the word "manlet" are self-hating incels. Yes, lots of women are nasty about height, and it isn't right, but even they and your precious "Chad"s don't have the hatred for shorter men that you do for yourselves. "Cope" and "manlet" are classic incel giveaways. |
DP. Not trying to justify the guy ranting about women liking tall guys. But I will say that there is some background for guys being somewhat dismissive of what women say they want. A lot of us were watching in high school and college and what women said they wanted didn't seem to line up too well with the guys they actually seemed to be going out with. The good looking jocks who treated everyone like crap (except, temporarily, the girl he was trying to get with) seemed to always have an attractive girl to date. The sensitive guys with a sense of humor (but no athletic ability) were frequently dateless despite ranking high in some of the categories women said they wanted. I think some of this can be chalked up to women not feeling free to be forthcoming about some of their more shallow desires. Also, the societal expectation that men make the first move made it to where the assertive assholes were the path of least resistance for women who were too shy or otherwise reluctant to make the first move themselves. Also, as women mature, so do their tastes in men. So, there are reasons for this other than that women are duplicitous or ignorant of their true desires. But what men hear women say they want doesn't necessarily match a man's lived experience (as the kids say) of the guys women seem to date. |
| Does your wife read DCUM? There are some threads here (like the postpartum one) which give a pretttttty poor showing of men. Maybe have your son read that to understand why so many people come away with a poor opinion or the gender…and what to aspire *not* to be. |
I am a woman, a very liberal woman for that matter. But I too don't like this idea that just because some men suck we are allowed to disparage all men. I also think its very unhealthy as a habit that women share with one another to make sweeping generalizations about male spouses (god no man can empty the dishwasher!) that contributes to great household gender inequality. No one should generalize about anyone. If you replaced men with basically anything else (women, trans people, lesbian, black people, chinese people, muslims) it would be universally abhorred. It doesn't feel good to be talked about like a statistic. |
High school and college? So, like, girls who didn’t yet know themselves, perhaps were still making decisions based on peer pressure, and weren’t looking for long-term relationships? As you pointed out, women mature. Hopefully men do the same and realize that that women considering long-term relationships are no longer looking for the affirmation of peers by kissing the captain of the football team. |
A) your analysis of what’s appropriate and what’s not needs some refining. You cannot just do a hypothetical and turn the tables to see if something is okay. It’s completely different for a white person to say they hate black people than it is for a black person to say they hate white people. The implications of white hatred toward Black people are violent and oppressive. For a black person to say he hates white people…that’s just kind of understandable. B) PP didnt disparage all men! She qualified that’s she’s talking about many men, not all. But even the phrase “all men suck” is typically just a figure of speech. It’s hyperbole. It’s a way of saying “everywhere I turn I see a guy being a jerk!” It doesn’t need to be picked apart and taken literally. |
No woman is going to go for a short guy with muscles over a short guy with a good personality. |
You're not wrong. But I don't think you can dismiss these formative impressions as irrelevant. A lot of men see this maturing as a shift from selecting for sexual attraction to selecting for material gain. Men want to be the object of sexual desire and don't care so much about being a provider of resources (except insofar as that makes them sexually desirable.) It's entirely possible that men who see it this way are just flat wrong, but I don't think this perspective can be ignored entirely. |
+1. Also for the people saying "women are just as bad" - yes, on a policy level, there are lots of patriarchy-enabling women. But it's very different from the actual physical fear of men that comes with sexual harrassment/assault. In my 20s I was sexually harassed at work a lot and it really made me resent men, especially the men in the corporate world, many of whom think it's all in good fun/perks of the job to hit on younger women who can't do anything about it without putting their jobs at risk. I've aged out of it now pretty much but I still remember how angry and helpless it made me feel. |
Back on page 2: "You would not say the same thing if a man was beset by his female colleagues, bosses, peers, relatives, etc. and abstracted his negative feelings about them onto women as a whole. You'll try to justify the double standard by some hand waving about societal power, but it's still wrong. " |
Screeching about incels is a classic obese barren cat lady giveaway. |
I actually responded to that! If the gender tables were *truly* turned, if women did all the bad things to men that men to do women, if men had a harder time in life because of the prejudice of women, if their bodies were regulated by women, etc., I wouldn’t just think it was okay to say “women suck,” I’d say it myself. |
lmao you have no idea how many women on the apps say "you must be over 6 foot" when the woman herself is 5' 0" or 5' 2". I have never, ever seen a woman on the apps put an upper limit of any kind on men's height - "sorry you can't be over 5' 7" uh huh that sht just don't happen. |
Obviously some women totally do that. Some women aspire to nothing more than marrying a tall rich guy. But when you’re generalizing, it’s totally safe to say that all else being equal, women will take a good personality over big muscles any day of the week. I know that you probably won’t but if you want to see more support for my point, google “female gaze.” And these guys just have to get over their formative impressions, plus the women who do what they are afraid of and are primarily materialistic. Just like I have to get over my formative impressions of most men being gross douchebags who only value women based on how hot they are. |
I am not on the apps but I know a lot do have a height minimum. And I think that’s ridiculous, especially because I know a number of woman who met their future husbands after they got rid of their height requirements. I’m not going to say being short is an asset in the dating world. It does narrow your pool. Just like for some women, having big hips narrows their pool. That doesn’t mean lots of men (and women) don’t want a partner with big hips. And I said it above but if you’re short, that’s that and you can’t change it. If you decide you need to compensate, you need to compensate with a better personality and not ripped biceps. |