Is this gaslighting? And why does he do it?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I think the point is being missed. I could not care less about whether it's a sauce or a dip, or that he wanted to share--I always share. It was his bizarre insistence that it always comes when you order Cava and that he wouldn't stop talking about it until I said what he wanted, which is: Okay, you're right. It always comes with this dip. Of course, I didn't do that, so for almost 10 minutes, he wouldn't stop insisting that Cava gives the sauce for free and that I was wrong in thinking that I orderd it, for myself. That's why I wondered if it's gaslighting...this insistence that I was wrong, and that I didn't order it for myself. He often is refuting reality, even in little, meaningless instances like this.


I hear you. My husband is so very similar down to the mispronounced words.

I am baffled by his behavior. A counselor once told me some of his other habits sound like ADHD (such as starting several new home improvement projects before finishing one, and NEVER having the insight to see that it won't work that way... and the inability to understand me when I try to explain it). I am not sure how, but this psychotic insistence on arguing stupid points might be related to adhd?
Anonymous
I'm the pp who has similar husband. Posters who are trying to tell you a better way to order, or telling you it's a dip are being obtuse.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think the point is being missed. I could not care less about whether it's a sauce or a dip, or that he wanted to share--I always share. It was his bizarre insistence that it always comes when you order Cava and that he wouldn't stop talking about it until I said what he wanted, which is: Okay, you're right. It always comes with this dip. Of course, I didn't do that, so for almost 10 minutes, he wouldn't stop insisting that Cava gives the sauce for free and that I was wrong in thinking that I orderd it, for myself. That's why I wondered if it's gaslighting...this insistence that I was wrong, and that I didn't order it for myself. He often is refuting reality, even in little, meaningless instances like this.


I hear you. My husband is so very similar down to the mispronounced words.

I am baffled by his behavior. A counselor once told me some of his other habits sound like ADHD (such as starting several new home improvement projects before finishing one, and NEVER having the insight to see that it won't work that way... and the inability to understand me when I try to explain it). I am not sure how, but this psychotic insistence on arguing stupid points might be related to adhd?


Absolutely. Same for aspergers men. Anything to feel better after trying to hide all the self-induced setbacks, mishaps and mistakes. He will literally destroy the relationship and marriage in order to protect his image and ego. So much denial.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:No, it’s not gaslighting. Yes, Cava is definitely pronounced with two short a’s. And finally, the cucumber-dill,
is called Tzatzitki and it is a sauce. Look it up.

So you’re both wrong. And apparently you’re made for each other.


As someone with a Doc-obsessed child who loves Tzatziki, I adore this post. A bright spot in a weirdly lame thread.


And yet, you're on page 2 of it.


Oh OP, stop being so defensive, we're not your husband...


I'm OP, that wasn't me.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:No, it’s not gaslighting. Yes, Cava is definitely pronounced with two short a’s. And finally, the cucumber-dill,
is called Tzatzitki and it is a sauce. Look it up.

So you’re both wrong. And apparently you’re made for each other.


So, the short a sound, which my husband uses to say Cava sounds like the a in "have." The a in Cava, should be pronounced "ah" or "aa." As you correctly pointed out, though you don't understand what a short a is. And actually at Cava, they have a tzatziki (check you spelling)--which they describe as a dip or a spread, and they have a yogurt dill dressing--which was the product called into question last night. And we are definitely not made for each other, hence my posting here when I do in fact need to be working.


Jesus Christ this paragraph makes me want to put a bullet in my head. Are you like this in real life?!

That “check you spelling” has to be eating you ALIVE inside!!


Well, I was just pretty annoyed at the poster who was missing the point of what happened and calling me pedantic because she thought the argument was over the name of the sauce. Perhaps it was my fault because I didn't tell the story clearly. I am far from pedantic. I don't possess enough knowledge of anything to be pedantic. And I really wouldn't know the difference between tzatziki and yogurt dill sauce. But she was being a jerk, so I jabbed back. Sorry.


It's totally not gaslighting, your husband has some kind of problem, be it ASD or something else--given not being able to function in the workplace, duh. So to start with, why bother arguing with him about trivia? And what about the not working, the general functional issues? What does he do with his time? Do you want to stay married? If so, what can you do about steering him to some therapy? Have you ever asked HIM what his dx was as a kid and what the therapy he had then was all about? Seven years and you're arguing about a dressing/dip/sauce? Blows my mind.


OP, I agree with these two points of view. He has been this way for 21 years, but the last 7 unemployed I can’t imagine how that dynamic impacts your day to day. Can you answer some of the questions that aren’t clear? Particularly around the newborn losses.

You sound stressed too, so you have an emotional support system, like a therapist or good non judgmental friend?


OP here. To answer the question about loss of newborns. We lost twins due to premature labor. This was almost 18 years ago. I have actually had some other pretty profound losses since then, to be honest (I feel like I will give myself away here evenutally). I did see a massive shift in his personality almost immediately following their birth/death. That's when he went from being a generous sweet person, to a financially controlling one. He didn't become too personally controlling--like telling me what I can do generally. But he started commenting on and eventually controlling, every penny I spent. I have worked througout our entire marriage. I knew at the time that, because that was a situation that was out of his control (it was our first pregnancy, through IVF), not spendig any money was how he was getting control. I knew it was unhealthy, but he has refused therapy ever since. I went for a while during that time. Haven't since. There is no question that I have a lot of anxiety--from that, and more recent very close losses. But I am not depressed and I really do deal with my anxiety. I'm sure it is quite unpleasant for him to live with me, because about two years ago I decided to stop taking his garbage. It seemed to introduce some equity into our marriage for a little while, but lately, he's just really asserting that control again. I do really appreciate the feedback and advice here. Some of it has been so thoughtful and some seemed fueled, possibly, by day drinking on a Saturday afternoon, but was good for some laughs. So thanks!


PP. I’m glad you’re amused by Spearta 2.0 unfolding as a sidebar before our very eyes. 😊

I am sorry to share the burden of parental grief. I remember when my XH and I were spoken to by the hospital medical team. After everyone left, she pulled me aside and said a lot of marriages don’t last after tragedy like what it sounds like you experienced. I’m happy that you are on a path of peace despite any pain, and I had a different story but a similar attitude after losing my baby. My XH tried to support and go alone, but that was not his way. And that was okay. He also suffered long term unemployment, where I carried the torch (emotionally, physically with medical procedure, financially with the income, and personally by working on my own self repair). It can seem like a very lonely walk, but for your disposition you have probably learned how to identify glimmers of light in the dark, or rainbows amidst the stormy clouds. Without knowing it, you could be evoking feelings within him unintentionally. Maybe that his reaction or process is wrong (it isn’t), that he is inadequate to provide an equal value in his marriage, he may struggle with other issues that would present around 21 yrs of marriage but are made complicated by what sounds like several difficult losses.

You asked if this is gaslighting. In my case, it didn’t begin that way, but he transgressed towards it eventually. It was a defense mechanism that allowed him to function with the emptiness he *felt* within, ans a projection that was a razor thin line between function and utter failure. He did it because he didn’t know anything about the power and gift of emotional weight. Like many men, he dismissed emotions as unstable and illogical factors to trust in decision making, so they were neglected. You cannot necks to the sound of your heart. You have to value and nurture it. Emotions should inform our decisions, not rule them, and they certainly be excluded as a weighted criteria to value as part of a decision making process.

I don’t know your specifics (and this is more common than you make think so don’t worry too much about outing yourself) but I know several people, myself included that have experienced *some* level of what you’re describing. It gets really tricky here, and I think this is the most fragile part of your make or break stage. If you can connect with your hearts, you can grow and continue to transform. If you cannot do that - someone will have to sever to save themselves, otherwise you will be ad odds with your family/spouse while also grieving your child/other losses. Throw in a little bit of overreaction, forgivable mistakes made in a moment of weakness, unresolved issues and it can just explode.

You’re not crazy, but death can make some of us no longer want to live. And everyone has different coping mechanisms. That said. You owe it to yourself to alway be the best person you can be in this lifetime. Losing life reminds us of how precious each moment is. You cannot change the past and you cannot control anyone’s response but your own. This is a time where you need to make an assessment.

Do you feel emotionally, physically, and mentally safe?
Do you feel that you can continue in this relationship without changing doe the worse if nothing changes?
Have you exhausted every ounce of effort to give 100%, even if he doesn’t “deserve” it?
Have you responded to his misconduct with grace, and love, without being a doormat or abused?
Do you know what his fears are?
Do you know what he wants right now at this moment?
Have you two discussed a NEW VISION and plan for the future after devastating loss?
Can you each identify the resources you would nées independently to return to baseline functioning as an indiciduL?
How about the resources needed to baseline function as a couple?
What is your next best option if this is not possible?
Are any of the weaknesses you’ve identified with yourself and your husband (without judgment!) able to be augmented in some other way?
Is there anyone your husband admires or confides in that could step in to give him an ear, or just someone to sit silent with him, or agree with his clear authority on dip determination? Would that help or hinder your vision long term if he had that ego itch scratched? Would he fall back, or become more emboldened in his foolish pride!

In my marriage, I fought my ass off. I gave 100% every single moment. When I felt like crap, when I felt great, when he was wrong, when he was right, when it was unfair, when I looked like a fool. It was painful. And hard. But going through that process creates a beautiful growth in your own soul, and your capacity for love increases ans your capability becomes threatened if the other person isn’t walking with you in that path. Again, parental grief is a completely different ball game with rules that muck up the usual modus operandi.

I stayed until it was unhealthy to stay, because my confidence and peace became a threat amd his behavior turned hurtful in a feeble grasp at power. I realized that I could not give a near 50 year old man a tool kit to use that he never had a desire to use before. I divorced, ans grieved that loss of a future with him along with the loss of our children. However, on the other side I have never been more resilient or confident. I have hope again, and I was able to do a lot of really tough work and personal transformation without the critical eye or international attempts to dismantle from my ex. I left with a clear conscious because I have all I have.

Several years out — he is still angry. He spouts lies, acts crazy, sometimes stalks me, but my boundaries are firm and while I don’t growl at his presence, I am a stalwart protector of everything I’ve worked hard to nurture amd when push comes to shove there is no defense against good that stands. There are times I think he may be maturing but I realize that the hole he has is so painful, he can fill it with things that would destroy me, but may just feel
More comforting than the emptiness. That is his walk and his cross to bear.

Love yourself and your husband and your children enough to love your best life. That isn’t in a pretty house with a hefty account and days filled with tears, hurtful words embedded in walls, broken memories and cold sheets. Warmth is a pathway, but you both have to want it. And if after a set period of time you explore the full gamut of this evaluation of jour family life, and you decide a new course or alternative is what is best, you can trust your judgement because you operated with a balanced input of wisdom, logic, emotion, love, and compassion for your need to have empowerment and never have those things threatened from the man that took the same vow as you.

I hope this gives another perspective and can help with some of the quartions. What you and yourhusband are facing is tough alone, but 2020 is the straw bringing a lot of camels to their knees.

I wish you all the best, and pray you find special signs to affirm the truth and good grace that is still waiting d’or a full release into your life, OP.

Happy Sunday! 🤗


TL;DR

I wish I had the energy to read this entire post because it seems very thoughtful and highly informative to what the OP needs... it was just too dang long, sorry.

I hope the OP reads it all though, as it sounds like she'd benefit a lot from someone in a similar situation (but that has to be one of THE longest posts I've ever seen on DCUM).



I did read it. Wow, PP, that was a very thoughtful post. I appreciate you sharing your experience. Need to do some processing, but in short: I have tried much of what you suggest, but certainly not all. I do think fear and some inertia have kept me in the marriage and just getting by with the status quo. Honestly, I just keep telling myself I just have to make it three more years, until the youngest is out of the house, then I'm just going to walk. Somehow, it just seems like it will be easier when I don't have the kids' school keeping us stuck here. I have never liked living in DC--my husband refuses to leave because he's from here, so I just live on the anticipation of moving far, far away. Thank you again for your really thoughful reply!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think the point is being missed. I could not care less about whether it's a sauce or a dip, or that he wanted to share--I always share. It was his bizarre insistence that it always comes when you order Cava and that he wouldn't stop talking about it until I said what he wanted, which is: Okay, you're right. It always comes with this dip. Of course, I didn't do that, so for almost 10 minutes, he wouldn't stop insisting that Cava gives the sauce for free and that I was wrong in thinking that I orderd it, for myself. That's why I wondered if it's gaslighting...this insistence that I was wrong, and that I didn't order it for myself. He often is refuting reality, even in little, meaningless instances like this.


I hear you. My husband is so very similar down to the mispronounced words.

I am baffled by his behavior. A counselor once told me some of his other habits sound like ADHD (such as starting several new home improvement projects before finishing one, and NEVER having the insight to see that it won't work that way... and the inability to understand me when I try to explain it). I am not sure how, but this psychotic insistence on arguing stupid points might be related to adhd?


Absolutely. Same for aspergers men. Anything to feel better after trying to hide all the self-induced setbacks, mishaps and mistakes. He will literally destroy the relationship and marriage in order to protect his image and ego. So much denial.


The weirdest thing to me is how easy it is for him to hide it from the rest of the world. Our closest friends have no idea just how strange he is at home (except for my best friend, who is quite objective in advising me--she thinks it might help if I remind myself of how he was raised and how hard it must be for him to see his kids loved by their mother when his was/is so cold and mean, and also knowing both his wife and kids have lost respect for him). He is truly a different person when he's out with our friends and neighbors. People love him.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think the point is being missed. I could not care less about whether it's a sauce or a dip, or that he wanted to share--I always share. It was his bizarre insistence that it always comes when you order Cava and that he wouldn't stop talking about it until I said what he wanted, which is: Okay, you're right. It always comes with this dip. Of course, I didn't do that, so for almost 10 minutes, he wouldn't stop insisting that Cava gives the sauce for free and that I was wrong in thinking that I orderd it, for myself. That's why I wondered if it's gaslighting...this insistence that I was wrong, and that I didn't order it for myself. He often is refuting reality, even in little, meaningless instances like this.


I hear you. My husband is so very similar down to the mispronounced words.

I am baffled by his behavior. A counselor once told me some of his other habits sound like ADHD (such as starting several new home improvement projects before finishing one, and NEVER having the insight to see that it won't work that way... and the inability to understand me when I try to explain it). I am not sure how, but this psychotic insistence on arguing stupid points might be related to adhd?


Absolutely. Same for aspergers men. Anything to feel better after trying to hide all the self-induced setbacks, mishaps and mistakes. He will literally destroy the relationship and marriage in order to protect his image and ego. So much denial.


The weirdest thing to me is how easy it is for him to hide it from the rest of the world. Our closest friends have no idea just how strange he is at home (except for my best friend, who is quite objective in advising me--she thinks it might help if I remind myself of how he was raised and how hard it must be for him to see his kids loved by their mother when his was/is so cold and mean, and also knowing both his wife and kids have lost respect for him). He is truly a different person when he's out with our friends and neighbors. People love him.


Mine too!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:This will sound petty, but it's one example of many. I ordered Cava for my husband and me. He texted me the order, I placed it and picked everything up. When I got home, he took out the three dressings on the side and said, oh so this one is mine? I reminded him that he didn't order dressing, but I ordered three on the side, so he could certainly have one. I told him I wanted to yogurt dill. He said, "that isn't dressing,' it's dip. They give that to you for the pita." I said, "well, they call it dressing, and I know because I placed the order and ordered it for my bowl." He then went on to inisist many times that it's "dip" and that we always get that automatically because it's for dipping the pita. I mean, over and over again. He has literally never placed an order at Cava (which, by the way, he pronounces with a short a and we all know he does that on purpose to annoy us, too). His bizarre insistence reached such comical heights that my 17-year-old son got pretty frustrated and told him he thinks he's crazy. It was as if he was trying to convince me of something that he knew (and I knew) just wasn't true. He does things like this more and more frequently. What is this? Is it NPD? I cannot figure out this strange behavior and I really don't like it.


Yikes. Not gaslighting at all. Like AT ALL
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think the point is being missed. I could not care less about whether it's a sauce or a dip, or that he wanted to share--I always share. It was his bizarre insistence that it always comes when you order Cava and that he wouldn't stop talking about it until I said what he wanted, which is: Okay, you're right. It always comes with this dip. Of course, I didn't do that, so for almost 10 minutes, he wouldn't stop insisting that Cava gives the sauce for free and that I was wrong in thinking that I orderd it, for myself. That's why I wondered if it's gaslighting...this insistence that I was wrong, and that I didn't order it for myself. He often is refuting reality, even in little, meaningless instances like this.


I hear you. My husband is so very similar down to the mispronounced words.

I am baffled by his behavior. A counselor once told me some of his other habits sound like ADHD (such as starting several new home improvement projects before finishing one, and NEVER having the insight to see that it won't work that way... and the inability to understand me when I try to explain it). I am not sure how, but this psychotic insistence on arguing stupid points might be related to adhd?


Absolutely. Same for aspergers men. Anything to feel better after trying to hide all the self-induced setbacks, mishaps and mistakes. He will literally destroy the relationship and marriage in order to protect his image and ego. So much denial.


The weirdest thing to me is how easy it is for him to hide it from the rest of the world. Our closest friends have no idea just how strange he is at home (except for my best friend, who is quite objective in advising me--she thinks it might help if I remind myself of how he was raised and how hard it must be for him to see his kids loved by their mother when his was/is so cold and mean, and also knowing both his wife and kids have lost respect for him). He is truly a different person when he's out with our friends and neighbors. People love him.


Very common “masking” for ASD and ADHD. All that masking at work or at social things, however, makes them out of gas an irritable once him when they can let the act down.

Have another family vacation with you for a week or longer. He can’t keep up the act for longer than a few days. My aspie spouse started disappearing to “do office work” by Day 2 and doesn’t even respond to questions by Day 4, even if you’re sitting in a car with him pointing out sites! And then there’s all the “miscommunications” with misinterpreting what people wanted to eat, or what time— and forget about putting together a day plan that makes any sense! He’d rather bow out of being in charge of that.

One time a relative asked where he was all Christmas week in a beach trip, he nearly bit her head off. The answer was he working. Because he can’t organize or manage his time or work we’ll, he basically shuts down when an email comes in from anyone and attends to it- even in the middle of a group dinner, conversation, kid thing. It’s truly bizarre. And no he’s not Mr Important.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This will sound petty, but it's one example of many. I ordered Cava for my husband and me. He texted me the order, I placed it and picked everything up. When I got home, he took out the three dressings on the side and said, oh so this one is mine? I reminded him that he didn't order dressing, but I ordered three on the side, so he could certainly have one. I told him I wanted to yogurt dill. He said, "that isn't dressing,' it's dip. They give that to you for the pita." I said, "well, they call it dressing, and I know because I placed the order and ordered it for my bowl." He then went on to inisist many times that it's "dip" and that we always get that automatically because it's for dipping the pita. I mean, over and over again. He has literally never placed an order at Cava (which, by the way, he pronounces with a short a and we all know he does that on purpose to annoy us, too). His bizarre insistence reached such comical heights that my 17-year-old son got pretty frustrated and told him he thinks he's crazy. It was as if he was trying to convince me of something that he knew (and I knew) just wasn't true. He does things like this more and more frequently. What is this? Is it NPD? I cannot figure out this strange behavior and I really don't like it.


Yikes. Not gaslighting at all. Like AT ALL


You'd have to go back and read a few of the responses and follow ups. It's not, but you can see that there is some deliberate manipulation.
post reply Forum Index » Relationship Discussion (non-explicit)
Message Quick Reply
Go to: