You TA’ed in one department for a couple semesters in 1990-something and decided that means you know the capabilities of all the Black students that were at UVA at the time across disciplines. Come on. |
I was speaking about the kids I’d interacted with. I’d be surprised if it was that different in different disciplines, but you’re correct, I didn’t have insight there. |
You are delusional if you think diversity will decrease because of the SC ruling. Just look at California which abolished AA in 1996. California schools are the most diverse in the nation. Some are even majority Asian and Hispanic. The demographic information is online, just look it up. |
Exactly. People have implicit bias (or are flat out racist) that stops them from inviting black students to join their study groups. |
You know how the state of California has a really large Hispanic and Asian populations? |
The UC system still suffers from a lack of diversity at its top schools and why there are clusters of Hispanics at lower ranked UC schools. They have a lot of date to back it up since race has not been a factor for over two decades in CA - https://www.npr.org/2023/06/30/1185226895/heres-what-happened-when-affirmative-action-ended-at-california-public-colleges |
Wait, you are saying Asian American adds to "most diverse". Berkeley is over 40% asian american and only 4.4% black. How is that diverse? |
Interesting finding here since the anti-AA posters swear campus life will be roses for URMs since everyone else will be assured they “earned” their spot. Most do not want to attend a university where there's not a critical mass of same race peers," said Mitchell Chang, the associate vice chancellor of equity, diversity and inclusion at UCLA. That's because attending a school made less diverse by an affirmative action ban, "puts them at greater risk of being stereotyped and being isolated," he said. |
And if you can’t believe an associate vice chancellor of equity, diversity and inclusion at a California school, who can you believe? |
The stats below speak for themselves: UC Santa Barbara is: 29.8% White 25.2% Hispanic 17.3% Asian https://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/university-of-california-santa-barbara/student-life/diversity/ UC Irvine is: 36.1% Asian 25.9% Hispanic 13.2% White https://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/university-of-california-irvine/student-life/diversity/ UCLA 28% White 26.3% Asian 22.6% Hispanic https://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/university-of-california-los-angeles/student-life/diversity/ UC San Diego: 33.1% Asian 21.9% Hispanic 19.3% White https://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/university-of-california-san-diego/student-life/diversity/ |
Can’t non-white students initiate study groups? I would not rely on being “invited” if I felt a study group would be beneficial. |
Some of you pretend you’ve never been in school before. When it came time to pick teams in PE class, you were hoping to be picked by the captains who looked the biggest and strongest, even if you had no idea how skilled they were. It continues in college. Would you accept an invite for a study group if you assumed the student was the slowest one in the class? Let’s see if eliminating AA ends that stereotype. |
I am a black student who also graduated in the early 90s. You are full of shit. I can assure you that there were a much higher percentage of white students admitted to UVA who by your definition weren’t qualified to be there. Also I’m going to need more information. What specific class was this? |
|
DH and I are both black UVA alumni. We will not advise our kids to apply to UVA or any school with a lack of diversity. A welcoming, diverse and supportive community is most important to us.
The SC ruling will result in less diverse campuses by self selection alone. |
| Asian study groups *never* invite blacks to join them. |