Unhappy With Summer Pre-College Program

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:OP why haven't you named the program? At least you can help others avoid it.


I'd understand if she doesn't want to out her kid right now. However, I'd love to see a thread with reviews of pre-college programs.


Great idea to start this new thread at the end of the summer!

omg. We should have a forum called "Reviews." Individual threads could be like:

Pre-College Programs
Summer Day Camps
Summer Sleepover Camps

and could even branch out into Best Store-bought Ice Cream and stuff like that


Actually, I did search here and all over the internet for info about this program, and I couldn't really find any. Info about these programs can be spotty. There are the big ones like Yale Global Scholars that are well known and Stanford and those really high profile programs that have that cache, but there isn't as much info on the other ones. It would have been very helpful for me. I don't want to discuss the name now, but after this is done, I would totally give an anonymous review without all of this personal stuff to help other parents understand the feel of the program. I wish I had been able to find that information before. Instead, I just went with the reputation of the school and because it was sponsored BY the school and not a third party. Looking back, that might have been the mistake. I would never do this again without talking to actual parents who had sent their kids to something.

There already is a forum for this - camps and classes.


My child is also going to a pre-college program that I chose after doing way less than my normal research. It was particularly hard this summer because most pre-college programs haven't been in person since 2019. Don't beat yourself up, OP. You couldn't have known.
Anonymous
Omg did you ever stop to think that it’s just your daughter? She hosted a game night and two kids showed up with one leaving fairly quickly. Camp hosted something and only two kids showed up. The kids are there, but they just don’t want to be bothered and that is fine! You say yourself that your child is weird and different. Well, what do you expect then? If you see it, others will too and would shy away from her. You need to back off. I can not imagine being this involved that you are calling and emailing that your child has no friends. It sounds like this is all you talk about when you call her. Focus on something else.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Omg did you ever stop to think that it’s just your daughter? She hosted a game night and two kids showed up with one leaving fairly quickly. Camp hosted something and only two kids showed up. The kids are there, but they just don’t want to be bothered and that is fine! You say yourself that your child is weird and different. Well, what do you expect then? If you see it, others will too and would shy away from her. You need to back off. I can not imagine being this involved that you are calling and emailing that your child has no friends. It sounds like this is all you talk about when you call her. Focus on something else.


Wow. Is your kid as mean as you are? My child would 100% prefer to hang out with OP's "weird" daughter than someone as hostile as you.
Anonymous
Op, I have been reading this thread on and off today during downtime at work. Your daughter is lucky to have a thoughtful and supportive mom like you. As someone who flirts with the spectrum, I get what your daughter is dealing with, but if she is saying she wants to stay that is a good sign. She is likely getting a lot out of the academics and research experience. That is genuinely fun for some kids. Lab-based research experience wouldn’t have been my idea of summer fun, but stuff like language immersion was my jam. You have given her sound advice and I admire her for following it. It is hard to put yourself out there!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Omg did you ever stop to think that it’s just your daughter? She hosted a game night and two kids showed up with one leaving fairly quickly. Camp hosted something and only two kids showed up. The kids are there, but they just don’t want to be bothered and that is fine! You say yourself that your child is weird and different. Well, what do you expect then? If you see it, others will too and would shy away from her. You need to back off. I can not imagine being this involved that you are calling and emailing that your child has no friends. It sounds like this is all you talk about when you call her. Focus on something else.


Wow op please don’t listen to this person. This is how we get mean kids. Ugh. This post makes me truly sad.

What I came here to say is I would be so disappointed too and I am GENUINELY impressed that your daughter is confidently sticking it out, tried the game night (that is huge! Many teens would never be willing to suggest that) and is just trying so hard. I think she will learn a lot from this experience even though it’s not what you hoped she would. She’s learning how to persevere and she’s also showing you that you’ve helped her gain a lot of confidence despite being awkward sometimes because she isn’t calling you begging you to pick her up. I’m sorry it isn’t what you hoped and it really does sound truly bizarre that they wouldn’t have some programming?! I mean WEIRD. I did a fellowship where we stayed in dorms the year after college - I was quite literally 21 years old (and met my husband there!) and they still had a ton of social programming!! Any program where kids are all staying in one space you would expect some programming, let alone young high schoolers.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Omg did you ever stop to think that it’s just your daughter? She hosted a game night and two kids showed up with one leaving fairly quickly. Camp hosted something and only two kids showed up. The kids are there, but they just don’t want to be bothered and that is fine! You say yourself that your child is weird and different. Well, what do you expect then? If you see it, others will too and would shy away from her. You need to back off. I can not imagine being this involved that you are calling and emailing that your child has no friends. It sounds like this is all you talk about when you call her. Focus on something else.


Wow op please don’t listen to this person. This is how we get mean kids. Ugh. This post makes me truly sad.

What I came here to say is I would be so disappointed too and I am GENUINELY impressed that your daughter is confidently sticking it out, tried the game night (that is huge! Many teens would never be willing to suggest that) and is just trying so hard. I think she will learn a lot from this experience even though it’s not what you hoped she would. She’s learning how to persevere and she’s also showing you that you’ve helped her gain a lot of confidence despite being awkward sometimes because she isn’t calling you begging you to pick her up. I’m sorry it isn’t what you hoped and it really does sound truly bizarre that they wouldn’t have some programming?! I mean WEIRD. I did a fellowship where we stayed in dorms the year after college - I was quite literally 21 years old (and met my husband there!) and they still had a ton of social programming!! Any program where kids are all staying in one space you would expect some programming, let alone young high schoolers.


Thank you. OP. As for the person who asked if I’d considered that my kid was just weird…of course I had! Lol! I said that we’d been working to build up her confidence. But I can honestly say that she’s not weird in a “takes up all the oxygen in the room” kind of way. She’s just really quiet and shy until you get to know her, and then is very funny. She’s never had a problem keeping friends…just needs help getting there. She lost her friend group during a school switch in COVID, and it hasn’t recovered. I said point blank that if there were opportunities and my kid didn’t take advantage of them or just didn’t connect, I would never blame the program.

I said that one part of this was figuring out what kinds of colleges she might want to apply to, and this has certainly clarified that. I don’t know if I’d say my kid has a disability or not…I guess very high functioning ASD is a disability of sorts but it’s not one the world accommodates very well. And she shouldn’t expect it to because it won’t. My kid masks it very well, but it probably is getting harder as relationships become more complicated. All of the social opportunities in the world won’t make that 100% easier, although they definitely help. So, that’s really clarified the importance of a college with a strong built in social safety net and one that tends to attract quirky kids.

Thank you for the well wishes!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Omg did you ever stop to think that it’s just your daughter? She hosted a game night and two kids showed up with one leaving fairly quickly. Camp hosted something and only two kids showed up. The kids are there, but they just don’t want to be bothered and that is fine! You say yourself that your child is weird and different. Well, what do you expect then? If you see it, others will too and would shy away from her. You need to back off. I can not imagine being this involved that you are calling and emailing that your child has no friends. It sounds like this is all you talk about when you call her. Focus on something else.


Wow op please don’t listen to this person. This is how we get mean kids. Ugh. This post makes me truly sad.

What I came here to say is I would be so disappointed too and I am GENUINELY impressed that your daughter is confidently sticking it out, tried the game night (that is huge! Many teens would never be willing to suggest that) and is just trying so hard. I think she will learn a lot from this experience even though it’s not what you hoped she would. She’s learning how to persevere and she’s also showing you that you’ve helped her gain a lot of confidence despite being awkward sometimes because she isn’t calling you begging you to pick her up. I’m sorry it isn’t what you hoped and it really does sound truly bizarre that they wouldn’t have some programming?! I mean WEIRD. I did a fellowship where we stayed in dorms the year after college - I was quite literally 21 years old (and met my husband there!) and they still had a ton of social programming!! Any program where kids are all staying in one space you would expect some programming, let alone young high schoolers.


Thank you. OP. As for the person who asked if I’d considered that my kid was just weird…of course I had! Lol! I said that we’d been working to build up her confidence. But I can honestly say that she’s not weird in a “takes up all the oxygen in the room” kind of way. She’s just really quiet and shy until you get to know her, and then is very funny. She’s never had a problem keeping friends…just needs help getting there. She lost her friend group during a school switch in COVID, and it hasn’t recovered. I said point blank that if there were opportunities and my kid didn’t take advantage of them or just didn’t connect, I would never blame the program.

I said that one part of this was figuring out what kinds of colleges she might want to apply to, and this has certainly clarified that. I don’t know if I’d say my kid has a disability or not…I guess very high functioning ASD is a disability of sorts but it’s not one the world accommodates very well. And she shouldn’t expect it to because it won’t. My kid masks it very well, but it probably is getting harder as relationships become more complicated. All of the social opportunities in the world won’t make that 100% easier, although they definitely help. So, that’s really clarified the importance of a college with a strong built in social safety net and one that tends to attract quirky kids.

Thank you for the well wishes!


It sounds to me like you and your DD are both doing really well navigating a challenging - though entirely age-appropriate- situation!

Cheers to both of you. I’d see this as a dry run for freshman year in college, and I agree that it’s a fantastic sign that she’s making an effort and is willing to keep trying. Sounds like your girl is resilient - that’s huge!!

My best advice is to just relax and take it day by day. Try not to coach her too much. She needs to find her own social style and being away from home for a month is a great time to try that. (If she ends up spending more time than you’d like by herself, it’s ok. She’s not unhappy and it’s just a month.)

The only coaching I’d offer is to look for ONE person at a time to talk with or try to engage at meals or group events. It can be hard for the quieter, slightly quirky kids to walk up to or join a group. It’s overwhelming for some (too much stimulation) and intimidating to most. So look for the person standing by themselves or walking in solo and approach them. Much easier way to build little social wins!

Finally, please do report back. I’m rooting for your DD!! 🙂
Anonymous
Everyone saying the parent shouldn’t have signed up their kid for something academic doesn’t know what they are talking about. Yes, if it’s all parent driven that’s no good but I did an academic type program every year as a tween/teen and it was all me finding out about and asking to be signed up and I loved all the programs I attended. I found “my people” and had a great time each time.

As for the program OP’s kid is doing, that really doesn’t sound great. Is this one of the more prestigious programs OP? Some of those actually do sound like they help with college admissions but they also sound more hard core in terms of research and academics and less focused on the social. I also read about some (I researched these a lot for my kid) that were more academic focused sounding and less fun, like I recall reading about some at CMU that sounded like that, and possibly even the UMD one.

My kid just attended a one week program where they did have an activity every night and kept the kids pretty busy. In general, I think one thing I looked for was a sample schedule for that gave an idea of how days would be spent.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I'm sorry, OP, but why on earth would you send a kid to a month-long "pre-college" program when they're gonna be in real college before you know it?


OP here. It's just a term that's used for academic programs held on college campuses. They sort of give high school students a little "taste" of college. Some people do them thinking they will help with college admissions, which they almost always don't (with a few exceptions). We did it as a way to:

1. Give our kid a little independence. (Force a little independence...)
2. Help her think about what kind of college she'd like to attend. (Did she like a campus experience? Would she rather be in a city? Big? Small? Just thinking about what she liked and didn't like when she starts more seriously considering schools next year...)
3. Meet some nice people.
4. Take an interesting class. There was also a research component that was interesting to her for what she thinks she wants to study.

If you have the money, they may or may not be worth it as an experience. But as some people pointed out, they are far from a necessity. I had very good experiences with then when I was in high school, and I made some cool friends and broadened my horizons--which is what I am hoping for with my kid. I do need to think about that first reason and realize that even if I'm not thrilled with the program so far, this does foster independence, and I should try and let her work through that.



I'll rephrase: why on earth are you having your kid do anything academic in the summer at all?


Not OP, but presumably because her child wanted to. The kind of child who signs up for CTY enjoys learning and academic challenges.


Yea, she really seems to be enjoying herself . . .

Besides, OP has said nothing to suggest that "her child wanted to." It sounds like the mother signed her up because SHE did it in high school and liked it. And the whole CTY thing is rarely, rarely child driven.

If I were a college admissions person, not only would I view spending summers doing this not to be an advantage -- I'd hold it against the applicant. Doing things like this with your summer does not a well-rounded and interesting person make.

Shut up. You’re not helping. (Not OP, btw)


Sorry. I happen to think the whole thing was a terrible idea. And I just don't understand it.


OP…my kid WANTED to. She originally wanted MATH camp, which I thought sounded horribly boring and didn’t pan out anyway. I suggested an art program because she loves art, but she didn’t want to show people her work. I thought the kids would be more likely to be fun and accepting at a creative program, but she liked the research aspect of this. So, I didn’t force her at all. Done.


NP - you don’t owe anyone an explanation for this. PLENTY of kids get excited about an experience like this instead of sports camp or traditional summer camp or whatever. For my daughter the Great Books Summer Program (essentially literature and poetry camp!) Was life-changing. She goes to public school and had never experienced seminar style learning before or so many kids who loved what she loved. And after 2 summers it was on to debate camp - the ultimate in dorktastic fun. She loved it all!


Debate camp was my jam as a teen. Dorktastic fun off the charts. Although, interestingly, in terms of what OP is saying, the debate camps were a lot less structured than other programs. I don’t recall much in the way of organized social or bonding activities but we did have roommates and were working together a lot for the debate classes so got to know people easily.
Anonymous
Don’t beat yourself up too much OP. My kid really struggled socially in high school and we had plenty of “misses” with activities and summer programs, but all of these things were learning experiences and he has really come into his own in college and is doing great that he just looks on these as blips in his past. Try not to catastrophize this. You took a swing and a miss; don’t give it the weight of thinking that this portends anything bad for her future. It’s the program and circumstances, not her. Tell your daughter you a proud of her for making the best of a disappointing situation and don’t dwell on it too much when she comes home.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:OP here. Well, I am bummed hearing that there are other programs doing more fun things. While some parents might have seen a program like this as more academics in an attempt to create more of a pressure cooker, that wasn’t my intention. In fact, I saw the academics as taking a secondary role to the entire experience. But I think this wasn’t the right program for that. So, I’d caution parents considering these kinds of programs to really dig in more to the specifics. My kid isn’t sporty and hasn’t held a job. She’s a nerd. I don’t say that in a mean way…just that all people are different and you can’t really force your child to be something they aren’t. You just try to bring out the best in who they are.

Next summer, unfortunately, she’s required for school to do an 8 week long internship + an in person class for a specialty center she’s in. So this was really the only summer she had to do something like this. I wish I had pushed her more into something that I knew would be creative. She’s really into science and art. I think an artsy kind of program would have been a lot more fun—but she just resisted showing people her art, and they want to see that you’re actually interested.

We got a letter from the program director that explained that our kid had an easier course load than a lot of the students because of the specific class she’s in and the research she’s doing, and that many students were just really studying and overwhelmed by the academics. I have no idea if that’s true. But it’s pretty depressing. They said there were some more activities coming up, but I can’t say I have a lot of faith. It’s pretty clear that they are super focused on the academics and that’s really it. I would not have chosen this program if I realized that.

But she seems to want to stay for now. So hopefully she ends up taking something away from it, even if it’s just more independence. The research might get better too. She thought it was cool to be in a lab and get to see how things worked in the field she’s interested in, and that was a big draw. But initially the grad students had no idea what to do with her so she was just sitting there. It seems like that’s getting better. I’m just going to keep encouraging her.

Thanks, everyone…except the haters. Lol.

Do your research if you’re considering something like this! These programs are expensive!!!!


Well, I'm glad that you can afford the privilege to keep your kid in the upper class. Except it's not working.
Anonymous
I hear from university staff that these "pre-college" summer programs are basically a way to get funding during the summer while the college kids are somewhat on hiatus. They are big cash cows. Just because it is a brand name does not mean that it is fantastic. I would do a fun summer camp instead like Camp Calleva.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I hear from university staff that these "pre-college" summer programs are basically a way to get funding during the summer while the college kids are somewhat on hiatus. They are big cash cows. Just because it is a brand name does not mean that it is fantastic. I would do a fun summer camp instead like Camp Calleva.


Yes. This has been discussed as nauseum on the college forum. Some are run by the school, some by for profit companies, so you have to check. They will generally not give you an admissions boost, but they may be a way to demonstrate interest in the school or a particular subject matter. They also give your child a feel for the school and campus life. They are definitely expensive. Worth it? Depends on the kid and your financial situation.

Ok. I think a summarized most of the discussion for you.
Anonymous
OP, how did the rest of the program go?
post reply Forum Index » Tweens and Teens
Message Quick Reply
Go to: