You clearly didn’t comprehend a single post you replied to. This can of worms was opened pages ago and you’ve been actively commenting on the worms. |
| Must be immigrant trying to fit in |
+1 - I find the OP's post off-putting and arrogant. If you are an adult with an 8-year-old, it is no longer relevant that you and DH were high achievers throughout high school and college. The fact that you included that aside in a post about sports speaks volumes. Welcome to DC, where everyone who was at the top of their high school class comes together to pit their kids against each other! You fit right in. |
Yes, I did read this thread. Ppl tried to explain why they overschedule, but not how it could possibly be a good thing. |
I believe that you read the words, but you didn’t comprehend the ideas being conveyed. Multiple posters implied (which is as good as an explanation for competent, intelligent adults) why it’s sometimes a good thing, you just didn’t get it. |
I noticed a lot of posters do that. |
At 8 years old in tennis you can see a child’s unique talent and drive and have them go to a professional school. At 8 years old in soccer if the child is mediocre but enjoys it she is right where she belongs. Be happy your child enjoys it and don’t ruin it. |
My daughter in the 4th grade had a friend whose mother scheduled her every waking hour. She came with us to a cookout that was near a Fourth of July carnival. She had never gone to one and I’d never seen her so happy. By, middle school she had turned awkward and uncomfortable in social settings. She never had a minute to experience life outside of supervised training. |
I grew up with kids like that. It was really sad, parents i guess think they're helping their kids, don't realize it's hurting them. |
It is very odd and immediately makes me question where the person is coming from. |
For every story like that, other kids went from D1 athletics to running Fortune 500 companies. I was nationally competitive in a sport that required intense training from a young age - my peers who I trained with are a neurosurgeon, a big law partner, and a trust fund kid with a "job" working in their family office and a busy public social life that mainly involves giving away money. You should probably keep your judgments and predictions of the outcome of high-achieving kids to yourself because it's pretty complicated to predict the trajectory of a fourth grader. |
I think that every parent wants their kids to be successful, but not at the expense of their childhoods. |
So, are you saying that it's worth it? Fir kids never really getting a chance to be kids. |
Absolutely, but "at the expense of their childhoods" is subjective. Look at Alyssa Liu - she spent her childhood figure skating, then retired at 16 after winning a bronze medal at worlds and a 6th at the olympics because she was burnt out. After two years off the ice, she missed the sport and returned to figure skating in 2024 and just won 2025 Worlds. In the press conference following Worlds, she said she didn't regret anything that brought her to where she is today. She's also a student at UCLA, and it is a well-known fact that Alyssa is social, extroverted, and almost always has a smile on her face. Nathan Chen is a student at Yale, living a relatively normal student life. Sarah Hughes is getting her MBA at Harvard and sits on several boards. Vera Wang went on to have a pretty great life after figure skating. Michelle Kwan is the US Ambassador to Belize. This is the sport I follow, and the examples I share are all public information, but others could insert relevant examples from other sports. If you can't agree to let people make reasonable judgments for their child based on what suits that child, then it's your problem. Most of us know our children better than strangers. There are bad parents everywhere who make poor decisions, but I doubt sports parents index high in that area relative to the general population. Most sports parents are in tune with their child's needs, and we try to act in their best interests. Like I'm sure OP will do for her daughter. |
I would hope that parents are acting in their kids best interest, but let's face it, some aren't and there are many stories like the above poster shared about kids not being happy about their parents making them do all these activities. I personally grew up with some of them, so yeah, I feel bad for them. Not worth it at all. |