Exactly. If my child was headed for the street and I grabbed his arm to stop him from being run over, the potential to leave a mark is there, maybe even a bruise. Other parent could disagree and say Larlo would have listened to the word 'no' so grabbing his arm was wrong. Mandatory reporter could then report to CPS, and some CPS worker with a chip on his/her shoulder could consider action abusive. |
Correct. The damage done to my kids when I was reported for suspected child abuse by husband who wanted a divorce but didn't want me to have any rights to kids or money, was horrendous. My kids were not removed, I was not arrested, because it was clear to the CPS worker that my husband/inlaws were lying. I could have left with the kids right then and there had I wanted to. Instead, I settled for winning the battle. The war is TBD, but it's been fun knowing that they were found out and could have been arrested themselves. |
Ok so in a worst case scenario a CPS investigation is started and since you have nothing to hide and don’t routinely bruise your child (right?) it’s an annoyance and potentially an expense. A mandatory reporter ignores those bruises and loses their job and a kid potentially loses their life. Why is that a preferable outcome to you? |
Lady you're not making the point you think you're making. |
Yeah that is something I’d feel terrible about and never talk about flippantly like that. |
Just wanted to add that my father was physical with me when he was angry and my mother did nothing. I am in my fifties and have still not forgiven her. (Not that she asked.)
I have spent years in therapy trying to understand why my mother did not protect me. I have very little to do with her now. (Dad is dead). |
But-your dc would have marks/bruise on his arm, which is consistent with your story of grabbing him at the street. OP's kid's marks are on the NECK. I can't think of a scenario where a parent grabs a child's NECK to keep them safe. And CPS knows this! |
I think you might be confusing this for another thread with an abusive DH, I don’t think this OP specified her DH grabbed her daughter by the neck. But I think a therapist would (should) report either way. |
People can get locked up now for spanking their kids. It’s a new day when it comes to disciplining children. |
PP here- yes, I believe you are correct, I confused threads. I think I am so shocked by both threads that it's blurring together. |
PP here - subjecting myself and my kids to CPS would be a last resort. I wouldn't do it in this circumstance. |
Be that as it may, CPS is not going to do anything about the intimidation part, which he is already seeking help for. I’m not sure why you think that joint counseling won’t help him with anger management. It’s entirely possible that the couple’s counselor will recommend anger management for him. It’s also virtually guaranteed that if the first thing the counselor does is call CPS that that will pull the plug on him seeking help unless it’s court-ordered, which is a whole other level of events (that this incident would not trigger anyway). |
Agree. DH needs help and I’d be furious but this is not CPS-worthy on its own. |
You are painting everything with the same brush and totally missing the point that this is simply not a situation in which a shield is being systematically abused. Do you think CPS is there to track and supervise and monitor and help prosecute people who on one very bad day make a mistake they regret, acknowledge and seek help for? They aren’t. They’re there to identify abused children. I get it, you aren’t trained to differentiate, and it shows. But you also should have the mental flexibility to understand that the guidelines are created to take responsibility off the reporter and therefore can catch a lot of things in their dragnet that are simply not why the agency exists to intervene in. If you can understand the difference you can understand why some people are saying that for where they are on the spectrum their current intervention (private counseling, not agency inquisition) is appropriate. |
^child |