I know in ES and up - everyone has the option to be vaccinated and wear a mask if they want. If you want to enforce masks in the few preschool classes there are in the ES where they are too young for vaccine - be my guest. I think it's a bad idea for those kids' development and risk profile - but I won't stop you. |
I really can't believe the ACLU is willing to stake their reputation on this. I think it's really going to kill their reputation to have to be told that Americans in 2022, with vaccines, have a civil liberty not to be forced to wear a mask. If you don't have a right not to mask when you have been vaccinated and have gotten covid to boot - I am not really sure what liberty means anymore. You can paint me as an antimasker if you want - but I am vaccinated, boosted, and wear a KN95 when I go out - but I think in 2022 with vaccines, we really cannot mandate masking anymore. It has to be optional if liberty is to mean anything. Two years later and with widespread availability of vaccines - I think I am ready to come out as anti-mask mandater, at least in schools. The cons of masks for kids are higher than for adults, vaccines are available, and their risk profile is so low. I really think this swings towards you no longer have the right to force others to wear a mask. I didn't oppose mask mandates pre-vaccine but now I think it's time. |
It's really to soon to know. Omnicron could circle around and wallop the same people again in a month or two. Or it could not. Willfully ignored in this politicization of masks are the following points: 1.) We've been dealing with an evolving virus that has become more infectious and not less lethal for the unvaccinated. 2.) We still don't know the long-term effects of covid, but the stats we have aren't great. 3.) The vaccination is great at preventing serious illness, but its effect in preventing any illness at all is imperfect and gets even worse over time. Boosters help a lot. Is it time to get a fourth booster? Probably. 4.) Kids under five have no protection. We are blessed they don't usually get very sick, but we don't know the long-term effects. 5.) Vaccinated people who are elderly and / or infirm are actually getting sick and dying. 6.) Vaccinated people can be asymptomatic and infectious. In fact it's common. Covid is not a *hot* virus. It doesn't burn through a population like, say, ebola, killing everyone in its path. In fact a large number of people catch it, carry it, and pass it on to others without ever knowing they're sick. That's one reason it's so pervasive and devastating: it is a sleeper virus. When unleashed in an institutional setting it can have a ton of hosts. For at least half the pandemic people were arguing that kids weren't spreading it while ignoring the rates and reasons for their own community transmission. Your viral load upon infection seems to have an effect on how sick you get. Inhaling fewer particles because you are wearing a mask improves your odds and the odds of others. Our country has fumbled the mask message so badly it might be comical in a century. Like, "look what morons those 21st-ers were comical." Masks work. Good ones work the best. When there was a mask shortage people were using cloth masks with liners or cloth with surgical. Even those options can also help reduce spread. The argument "most wear cloth and it doesn't work anyway" is as true as "it will be gone by Easter." The virus changed. People 's mask habits also changed. If we are extremely lucky it might be better by THIS Easter. All versions of covid have been shown time and time again to have the potential to reinfect previously infected individuals. Vaccine efficacy also wanes. This combination alone should alarm you. . |
People like you are the reason day cares, schools, preschools have to make rules about keeping your kid home for 24 hours after a fever, vomiting, diarrhea, etc. Not to mention the difference between diseases that have known and well established cures and disease that....don't have readily available treatments. |
This. |
You do realize that Switzerland, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and the UK are dropping restrictions. France will soon as well, they say. Austria too. All these places, if they ever masked kids (in some cases 6+ and in some places 12+ were the only groups masked) are unmasking them in school. It's not like Virginia is doing some crazy weird thing. We are more vaccinated in the entire state of Virginia than the entire country of Switzerland. |
I think your first point is incorrect re: deaths in the unvaxxed. The gap between cases and deaths is widening. On point 3 - I don't think the point of this vaccine is to prevent all illness - if you want that - you're going to have to be boosting people all the time and that is not a viable strategy here - according not to me - but vaccine expert Paul Offit who I agree with. And I think your 6th point - 6.) Vaccinated people can be asymptomatic and infectious. In fact it's common. --> is true and a reason why we shouldn't have masks mandates - if it's so mild that it's asymptomatic for many people - then we shouldn't be forcing masks to prevent that. I don't see why if we don't know the long term effects - why we don't assume until proven otherwise that it will go the route of the other 4 coronaviruses currently circulating as a common cold. I like the expression - when you hear hoofbeats, think horses not zebras. |
x0 |
All of your ramblings are based on the flawed assumption that masks block the spread of Covid. We now know this is incorrect. |
The forced child maskers really can't give it up - it's purely about ego and anti-scientific, quasi-religious beliefs at this point. Right now, the so-called disability attorney (who is a closed schooler, which hurt SO MANY disabled kids, just as masks do) is on AEM pushing a hail mary lawsuit. The same people pushing for this litigation (Smart Restart) are the same people who said: (1) School was unsafe to reopen during throughout the 2020-2021 school year - they were repeatedly wrong (2) School was unsafe to open fall 2021 with the Delta variant - they were wrong (3) School would have to close down in January 2022 because of the Omicron varient - they were wrong (4) A founder is saying on AEM (the one who said in an NBC interview she sent her son to school with a CO2 monitor) that things will never go back to normal and wearing masks will be a part of our lives forever (5) On Smart Restart Twitter, that forced child mask wearing needs to happen every time there's a surge in cases for the rest of our lives (i.e., while COVID is still here) These people have been so wrong. They want children to be forced to mask forever. Their credibility is utterly destroyed and they're a laughing stock of this community. |
These people are nuts. The Smart Restart head said on AEM that she'd like to be able to sue parents if a maskless kid infects her child. LOL Good luck litigating that the lack of a Paw Patrol mask kept her little snowflake from getting a cold. |
And if we can't unmask now, then when? We have vaccines for 5 and up. And a ton of people just got omicron so we have a really high level of immunity from vaccine and natural infection. |
That's right. And that's a sensible rule for return to school post vomiting. I assure you I always abide by rules like this. But this has zero to do with so-called "preventative" masking, which is what we're discussing here. It's not up to me -- fully vaxxed and feeling fine - to assume that I might be shedding a few cells of cornavirus, and wear a mask to protect you or anyone else. |
Virginia did do a crazy irresponsible thing by banning mandates so no one can respond if a new variant means masks are necessary again. The law isn’t about whether now is a good time to unmask — it’s pretty close to that — it’s about preventing the use of successful strategies in the future. That’s what’s crazy and irresponsible about it. It was a political stunt; not a public health approach. |
They inserted a clause that the Gov can declare an emergency and say that everyone needs to mask again, and under the law - masks are optional - so you can always wear your own good mask. https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-kids-face-masks/ |