Honestly I'm surprised they got as far as an indictment. There are far too many unknowns in this case. Although I find the intruder theory hard to swallow, for all the reasons outlined on this thread, I don't think there is enough evidence to determine what happened and who was responsible if it was a family member either. Looks like we'll never know. That poor child. |
Exactly . Social psychologists call this “the just world hypothesis.” |
But JB had her fingernail marks in her neck whee she clawed at it to get it off. It was a torture device. To choke her, then let her breath. It was not a set up after the fact. It was used in her for a specific purpose. Sorry but I can’t see Burke doing that. |
Some loon on Reddit did a recreation with the same model of train tracks and it did seem to line up perfectly with the size and appearance of the marks. But there evidently wasn't a lot of attention paid to the marks on her back or face by the medical examiner because they were viewed as incidental in relation to the attack and murder. So the skin tissue wasn't closely analyzed and train tracks were not collected as evidence because this theory didn't even come up until years later. So it remains yet another intriguing but inconclusive piece of the puzzle. |
The marks on her neck were from an altercation prior to the garrote being applied. She was wearing a turtleneck which her attacker grabbed in a fist and twisted. It is speculated that jonbenet clutched at her throat at that point defensively (hence the defense marks) and shortly thereafter was hit in the back of her head with the flashlight rendering her unconscious. Once she was unconscious, she was poked at with the electric train tracks, experimented with the paintbrush and ultimately the paintbrush and string were used to fashion some of garrote or ligature which is what ultimately killed her. Autopsy stated that she died between 45 minutes-2 hours post brain injury. Her bladder emptied on the carpet outside the cellar where she was ultimately found. The paintbrush and train tracks were in the basement and belonged to patsy and Burke, respectively. Patsy had purchased the string at a hardware store several weeks prior which was confirmed by the store and a receipt they produced. After she died, JB was wiped down (stated in the autopsy), duct tape was applied on her mouth and string was loosely applied on her wrists to make it look like she’d been abducted. A multi page ransom note was written using a pad of paper and marker found in the kitchen. All evidence and logic points to the family’s involvement. |
Yes, agreed, but there still isn't enough evidence to convict. |
They were distraught upon finding out Burke did it. The 911 call pointed to this. They had to go into survival mode to protect their remaining family. |
|
She knew John was guilty of something. Linda Arndt.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y3hT8hn9Y6M |
I just can't envision a 9 year old hitting with enough force to cause an 8" skull fracture. Or breaking the paintbrush to use it in different ways in the assault. But I also can't see an intruder hanging around the house for hours, when Burke and Patsy seem to have been awake at various points, either. |
My thoughts exactly. Every time you walked down stairs, you’d feel cold air pumping in. |
Exactly. One person was not distraught: Burke. When they arranged for him to go to their friends house the day JB was missing, he grabbed his game boy and asked no questions. When a police officer went over to informally interview him, Burke said he was hungry and asked for a sandwich. Every family members picture was taken that day - Jon and patsy looked exhausted and anguished. Burke smiled. There isn’t enough evidence to convict the family, and Burke was under 10 when it happened, but family involvement is pretty clear. |
Those of us with autistic kids don't find Burke's reaction at all unusual. These kids live in their own world and are pretty emotionally detached as a rule. |
Okay and it’s not a huge leap to believe that the brother who had a history of harming jonbenet and behaviors (like his fecal matter that was found in two places in her bedroom) was responsible for harming her and remaining detached from it. And while Burke may have been on what would today be defined as the spectrum, he was verbal and in a mainstream classroom - so, high functioning so to speak. It was a lot less common for similarly afflicted kids to be diagnosed and treated with psychiatric medications in the 90s. |
|
Lou Smit seemed the competent investigator on the whole lot so in inclined to believe him.
That wide eyed Linda Arndt from the boulder police force looked like something straight out of central casting. What a loon. And Steve Thomas went to work in the private sector after resigning in disgrace. Speaks volumes that he never returned to police work. |
It actually is a huge leap to go from sibling fighting to sadistic ritual killing. |