
Vary your news sources - the cases have been out there. There have been multiple lawsuits against schools, here’s just one example. https://www.cpr.org/2024/08/09/adams-county-parents-sue-over-teens-hidden-gender-transition/ |
The simple answer is that they don’t. |
It's not just me...it's many people...and not just Rs...Dems and Independents too. It's not just Americans it's people all over the world. We are only talking about gender "identity"....not biological sex. The belief that gender identity matches biological sex is tied to religious and cultural beliefs and values. Fact. |
No compromise. Keep this stuff out of the schools and respect parental rights. Keep biological males out of women’s sports, locker rooms, bathrooms, jails and shelters. Just stop. |
Biological sex is real. Gender identity is a concept - outward expression based on societal expectations and stereotypes. Fact. |
Opinion. |
African immigrant here. This has been my exact experience as well. I am constantly approached by very strange and disturbed people, who have a range of far leftist beliefs. These are mostly white people but also African Americans whose blackness is entirely academic. They're always strangely excited by me and assume that I share their beliefs and priorities. Unfortunately for them, I believe in society and its traditions and do not seek to deconstruct or "queer" anything. I immigrated for economic reasons, not to have my time monopolized by unwell people who see an actual, authentic African woman with an accent as the ultimate find to add to their collection of human misfit dolls. The "social justice" movement in this country is overrun by grasping types who crave power, but can't attain it in polite society. They're too mentally ill, sexually depraved, socially obtuse, aggressive etc. So, they reinvent themselves as "champions" of the "marginalized" and build their self-esteems around the assumption people like me need their protection and guidance. We don't. |
Fixed it for you. So we agree. You are born biological male or biological female (or in rare cases intersex) and a parent's belief that the gender identity match that of their child's biological sex should be respected. |
This. The simple answer to OP's "why?" Is "because we said so." We don't want it, we don't like it, and we aren't going to go along with it. Not with the idea that doctors randomly assign gender, or that gender is fluid, or that your soul can be mistakenly deposited into a body of the wrong gender, or that it makes any sense to have drag queens read books to children. We just don't like it. End of. Go back to 2008 era gay activitism talking points if you want people to nod along. |
Actually, I'd say gender identity is a belief. |
This whole thread is why many people abstained from voting, voted independent or held their noses and voted for Trump.
If Dems continue down this path I see a similar fate in 2026 and 2028. |
I’ll accept your proposal when you accept mine: eliminate the baggage that goes along with sex and criminalize sex based discrimination, both overt and implicit, everywhere it appears. Medicine. Rights. Schools. Workplace. And most importantly, churches. No more indoctrinating little girls to submit and devote their lives to breeding. No more teaching boys that they are inherently superior. If you want to pull that crap, you lose your tax status. No more subsidizing regressive behavior that limits both boys and girls. If it’s separate, it had better be equal and based on a sound determination of necessity that would pass the strict scrutiny test. Everyone signs up for the selective service. Medical exemptions only. Modern combat looks a lot different than it did 200 years ago. Men and women get child leave and are expected to take it. Companies that have executive ranks that don’t generally track the sex composition of their workforce will pay a tax off their net with a % that reflects the difference. Same with salary differentials. If the company is “unprofitable”, the Board, shareholders, or executives are liable. Anything merit based is done blinded. Candidates and applicants get assigned numbers. Sex crimes are investigated promptly and punished harshly. This includes hate crimes against LGBQT individuals. The gay/trans panic defense is officially banned and treated as an admission of guilt. Stalking, harassment, domestic violence? Automatic 5 years. And police will be regularly audited and subject to customer surveys to ensure they are not ignoring cases or letting backlogs grow, and their pay adjusted accordingly. Poor performers are promptly terminated. That sound good to you? Or were you hoping to keep a sex based system where you’d be sure you’d always come out on top regardless of your merit? |
But one that is based on some fact, unlike most religions. |
DP. Why are you writing as if this is a negotiation and society has to entertain you? Gender and mentally ill people's ideas are out. Sex and objective fact are back in. No one cares how you feel about that and we don't need to accommodate you on anything. You'll deal because you have no choice. Majority rules. |
Brilliant post of the year right here. Soo many mediocre men that just crumbled and decided you know what, I want the guy that makes me feel good, even if he is a felon and a rapist and working overtime to destroy the country and get revenge on the loyalists he threw under the bus in 2020. America deserves what it gets. |