I think you are wrong about the elite swimmers not participating except for meets. They may not be at many practices, but mine are at every "dine out", they go to the B meets to support the team even if they are not swimming, they volunteer to help with the pre-team, they are at the banquet, and every Friday night spirit events!. And they usually come from the club practice to summer practice a couple of days a week just to see their friends. Swim practice doesn't work well with outliers in terms of speed. HS teams function the same way with the faster club swimmers doing their club practice. You can't run a practice that challenges three very fast kids unless you give them their own lane (and honesly, you'd probably complain if that was done at summer league practices) Curious, . . . are you a stroke and turn official, a team rep, a referree, head timer, a starter, automation operator? Parents of non-year around swimmers can certainly do those jobs (and are often asked to), but in my experience they rarely do. They rely on the parents of yea-round swimmers, who draw on their knowledge of the sport, to make the summer league run smoothly. So if you want to do summer swimming without them, you'd need to be prepared to step it up in a mjor way. |
|
NVSL swim parent here. Any chance a team might want to run swim practices for maybe 4 weeks this summer. Give the swimmers an hour of lap swimming, friendly competition, relay games. Kid has to be mature enough to follow the rules. I could see maybe half of our usual 150 swimmers wanting to do this. So 8 and unders, 9 to 12, and teens practice separately. 6 lanes, say 25 kids at each practice. I would pay for that.
|
We are year round swimmers. Why do you assume we aren't? People like you are exhausting. We let our kids enjoy swimming. You should try it. Yes, we are certified in several areas and my spouse does every A and B meet when they let us. We would love to be team rep or more involved but we have a team parent whose kids are no longer on the team refuse to let others help which is a huge issue on the team. We do as much as we are allowed and are at every meet, A and B and do anything ask, even last minute. And, you proved the point, they should be made to do practices or they should not be allowed to compete. They aren't part of the team if they are not practicing with the team. You want your kids treated as more special. Our team gives lanes to the top A kids (low A kids don't get it) only so there are tons of kids in all the lanes and a few kids get the two A meet kid lanes. P.S. your kids aren't actually helping at pre-team. Usually they are goofing off and hanging out together. |
They could have more practices so they limit kids to 4-6 a lane instead of 10-12. They don't need the meets or can just do their own meets. Also, for us, set up the pool to do 50's for the older kids so kids are more spread out. |
We have way over 50 people. Even if they limit it to one parent per meet, its still way over 50. What they can do is set up times for age/gender. 9 and under boys at 8 Am, 9 and under girls at 9 AM, let it clear out, 9-12 at 10 AM, etc. |
We hired coaches last fall and opened up registration March 1. Not a big deal, just different. |
I agree with this PP that year round swimmers should do their summer team practice if the times don't conflict. I grew up swimming and used to do my club team's practice at 5:30 am then go to the summer league practice at my summer pool at 8 am or whatever it was. It was so easy compared to the club practice and I would get to see friends that didn't swim year round. It was swimming just for the fun of it. Oh and despite my deep involvement with the sport, my parents never for certified to do stroke and turn or any of that stuff. My mom would be a timer sometimes or maybe the snack bar and that was it. I think I stuck with it so long because my parents were not super involved... just supportive. |
We are very involved, sit at each practice, volunteer when we are allowed but its the pushy obnoxious parents who criticize all the kids who are not "top elite" kids but are trying that get old. They bully their way into controlling everything. I don't see a need to worry about times, compare our kids to other kids or worry about if they are elite or not. They do it for fun, for exercise and because they enjoy it. We are happy to pay for it all as long as they enjoy it (and we pay for winter team, summer team and weekly private lessons). One parent on our team screams at the kids, makes them get back in the water and redo things and disrupts practice. Luckily they don't come to practice much (nice kid). If a kid loses the meet, they lose electronics for the week. Other parents I've seen have spreadsheets of all the kids times and they sit there talking about each kid openly and in front of other parents. Its rude and unnecessary as not all of us care about top times or even times as long as ours progress. And, the issue with volunteering is supervising our own kids. Usually the volunteer kids run wild, act up as they are there for hours and get bored and know the parents aren't paying attention. |
| my kids are decidedly B meet on a huge team, but the super fast A kids were usually at practices, parties, B meets, "big buddies" for the younger kids, etc. I didn't realize it was a thing to not practice with your summer team before I read it on here. |
It’s not really fair to say they should go to practice if they don’t have a conflict. For us, it would mean, kids swimming 2 hours in a long course pool from 6-8 am 5 days a week and then one kid swimming from 9-10 and another kids swimming from 10-11 with those two practices way too easy. AND then swimming Monday evenings at a meet, Saturday mornings at a meet and several evenings for an hour each practice. My kids definitely go to summer swim practice but I don’t make them go based on no conflicts because they’d be at swim way too much or at way too easy practices over practices that are more level-appropriate for them. I think they should go 2 times a week or so to their summer practice. |
If your kids cannot practice and participate on the team, they should not be on team. Doing meets is taking away from other kids who actually are practicing with the team and active members. You are selfish and only in it to win. You have no idea what people say about families like you and its not good. If you just do meets, you are NOT part of the team. You are using the team for meets. You have a winter team with meets so there is no reason to take away slots from other kids who are actually participating. |
Not at our team and we only have limited slots because we are a huge team so kids don't get on the team who should because of those kids taking up slots when all they do is do meets. They are on a year round team that meets in the summer and shouldn't do both if they are not going to participate in both. We don't really have parties, the older kids who help the younger ones is only one lane and they are goofing off most of the time and only a few are actually nice and helpful. They are not at B meets and parents don't volunteer. |
| Are there neighborhood swim teams that don’t take all the kids who want to swim who can do a lap? |
yes definitely-- Overlee has time trials to get on the team. So does Chesterbrook. I don't know- but I suspect all D1 is that way. |
Remember its not just neighborhood pools but county/public teams that are much less expensive. Our team is capped at I think 200 kids. The past few years we've had to turn away kids who in years past would have qualified. They will only take a few wall huggers but mainly kids who can swim a 25 without help because there is so much demand. We had siblings who should have qualified and could do a 25 turned down for team. So, yes, its not fair for that sibling who got turned down who would have gone to every practice to have to sit on the side vs. swim as another child who only did meets took up a spot. |