This was my thought. Normal kids/people know when to say when and move on. I wonder about the posters who defend really pushy, persistent people who don't know when to back off. Clearly the app does not fall far from the tree. |
The deal here is that these kids appear to be friends, presumably the OP's daughter would like it to remain that way. You don't need to defend yourself against polite invitations from friends. If it were a rando on the subway asking to take her somewhere, your approach would be appropriate. |
| Is she going with someone else? If not, she can't say that. They are in school together, he would know if she doesn't come. Or he will ask who the person is. This does not work as a reason if it's not true. I think she should just say that it's really nice that he asked, but she is unable to go with him. I also do not think it is mean to say, if pressed, that she thinks he is a nice person but she does not have feelings for him. |
OP did say that the daughter had another invitation from some one that she does want to go with, I assume that she has accepted that one. |
| Say she has already accepted another invitation and just wanted to tell him quietly. |
Nothing about the OP indicates they're friends. OP indicates he asked her two years ago and she said no then. |
x100. "No, thank you" is all that is required. She can drop the "thank you" if the boy persists. |
| If they are friends at school, DD can says, "I have another plan but I will see you at the dance." |
She's a teenage girl, if they weren't friends, or at least part of the same friend group, she would not be worried about a polite decline. Also, someone she doesn't see regularly would not be likely to ask twice 2 years apart. |
Hopefully the girl in question doesn’t have any of those issues either. |
+100 Honestly, there’s always someone just *looking* for a problem where none exists. People like the PP are constantly on the offensive and it’s absurd. OP, I agree with the posters who suggested nicely telling him she had already been asked by someone else and didn’t quite know how to tell him. But if there’s a similar situation again, she should be straightforward and kind immediately by saying thank you so much for the invitation, but (insert excuse). The most important thing is to be kind. It’s SO hard for boys to put it all out there and then get rejected, no matter how kindly. |
|
Next time she should politely turn him down right away. Saying “I’ll think about it” only drags it out and makes it more awkward.
Or was he her fallback plan? |
| I think he already knows there is little chance she would say yes. If she had other plans, she would have just said that. If she wanted to go with him, she would have said yes. Short and sweet..no big deal Will thanks for the invite but I have other plans. She should do it as soon as possible so he can regroup with someone else if he wants. |
Thank goodness there are people who understand nuance in certain situations. It is difficult for anyone guy or girl to ask another person out or express feelings. It is perfectly to acceptable to gently let someone down without being cold and abrupt. This is an ask to a dance not an unwanted sexual advance, stop teaching your children that being assertive means being rude. You can be kind and firm and still allow a person to keep their dignity. Sheesh! |
Thanks for asking but I’m already going with somebody. It’s a nice no. |