Asian students are not just good test takers (that is like saying blacks are just good runners). Asians are good students and study diligently. |
But the test scores seem to still be the determining factor most times. The Asians have higher test scores for whatever reason. My guess is they prep more. They will continue to compulsively prep and this will remain, until everyone else gets the memo and decides to follow suit. |
It’s not only Asians though, do you think that students of other races don’t work hard and study? I am not Asian, I worked my butt off in HS and college, studying, sometimes all night, it wasn’t possible to study anymore than I did, I did this because I wanted to succeed, not because my parents made me. I never took a prep class of any kind. Many nonAsians are doing the same today, but seem to be lagging behind for some reason. |
|
Asian parent here, a relative new comer to the US and our school district (not in the DMV) doesn't have test-in schools so I guess I don't really have a stake in this, but I'm intrigued by this discussion about 'leveling the playing field' so I've been following similar topics for a while.
Can someone explain why or how this idea of test prepping = cheating came about? From the other threads (plus other sources I've read) it seems like this idea doesn't exist for sports or the arts. I've also noticed that white parents tend to gravitate towards spending money on writing tutors/ writing camps or supplementing in other enrichment activities (ex. performing arts) compared to Asian parents. So if prepping for say math is considered to be unfair and cheating, then I wonder why prepping for writing good essays isn't also considered to be cheating? If money were the discriminatory factor, then shouldn't all private school students (not on financial aid) be considered to be cheating, as they have used their financial privilege to 'game the system'? What is it with only standardized test prep that gets the reputation of cheating, when other disciplines that require comparable amounts of resources (money, time, effort) are never touched on in the same way? |
Whites prep more than Asians. |
We are not supposed to get into intelligence on this board. |
Ah, but what are many Asians doing when the nonAsians are practicing a sport and traveling for sport? I think many nonAsians do take sports way too seriously, to their detriment. It’s wasted time for many. |
|
+1 bar is set much higher for Asian Americans. As my white DH says, "Asian Americans are a victim of their own success". |
Actually, you're wrong about this. Blanket statements are almost always used in discussions about Muslims and Blacks. So, welcome to our world Asians. |
My experience with my ES school child, the bar is the same, if not higher, for others. There is absolutely nothing extraordinary about the Asian children in my DC’s class, except they do play piano. It’s a pervasive thing though, we all assume the Asians are geniuses. I don’t find that to be accurate though. |
This is like saying why is regular PE time not enough to those kids who can play at varsity level sports. |
+1 Yes, this is true. When are the lotteries going to begin for sports? |
Right after they begin lotteries for AAP. |
So you mean really soon. |