Your comments are spot on. |
I do have inside knowledge. My son was one that turned 19 before he graduated. There are many boys that are fine, upstanding students at Landon. Every school has some bad eggs. Unfortunately, Landons seem to get an unfair amount of attention. That is what I find peculiar. |
Well of course the public schools "had way less supervision". The publics are in no way responsible for beach week. In fact, our Principal went so far as to tell parents at PTA meetings NOT to send their kids, not to sign leases, not to believe their kids when they say "everyone is doing it" because 'everyone is not doing it". Beach week is an excuse for inappropriate behavior and dangerous activities. We didn't participate and DC had no interest in doing so. |
The problem with Landon is that it seems every time a scandal starts to die down a new one pops up. So, the good that Landon does is, again, outweighed by the bad. It's the frequency of scandals. Every school has them but it seems Landon has much more than its fair share of scandals. |
So were literally half the boys in your son's class at Landon held back, redshirted, or whatever you want to call it, so they were 19 in June of their graduating year? that would mean even more were held back but just had not turned 19 by June. When was this? Can you say for certain that's the norm at Landon? If so, that's very different from my kids' school. Maybe it starts to explain what's happening at Landon. |
|
Former Landon family here. Yes, there are lots of older kids
in Landon classes. Lots of redshirting . |
More than half the class, as PP suggested? |
| It's not unusual to see several boys 12 - 15 months older than their classmates. Often times it appears to be for sports and there is a lot of internal debate about the issue. |
| A graduating class from Landon is about 80-85 boys. Are 40+ boys per class redshirted/held back? |
I think it's fair to say the SAT cheating that occurred more than a decade ago was a "scandal" even if kids from other schools at the testing site were able to get away with cheating. The "everyone was doing it" excuse doesn't hold up - especially at a school that prides itself on an honor code. As for the other other "scandals?" Hmm, not so much - except to those who are scandalized by everything Landon. In this latest instance, the supposed scandal isn't that high school grads had a wild beach party - like it or not , that's not a scandal. The supposed scandal is that the Maryland Attorney General was at a wild beach party in Delaware and didn't break it up. Landon will be just fine. As a parent, one important consideration that none of the supposed scandals involved a teacher or school official - those who you entrust your children to. I don't blame schools that have allowed teacher/student abuse - it's not easy to detect such deviants - but I'd think twice before entrusting my DC to their care. |
Ah, yes. The ubiquitous "everyone else does it" and "why are they picking on Landon?" defenses. Pathetic. |
|
Landon just doesn't handle these issues as well as peer schools such as STA. Recall the "BB gun" incident when two boys drove to school and parked the car for the day. A non-lethal "BB gun" rifle replica was left in the back seat. One boy went to class while the other boy went into the woods. Having never shot a gun, the STA student tried it, put the gun back in the car and went to class. A mom saw the "shooter" in the woods with a 'sniper rifle', and made a 911 call the police. NCS, Sidwell and St. Albans were locked down within minutes. The BB gun was found in the back seat of the car and the car was traced to the boys. The boys were taken out of class in cuffs and the incident was widely reported with dramatic video on the web.
STA responded quickly. The boys were barred from school for the remaining few weeks of the year, but allowed to graduate. Both boys faced DC gun charges. Some said that STA's quick action was too harsh, but it was a lesson learned for the entire STA community. |
|
Sidwell took a similar proactive approach when one the most beloved Sidwell teachers was found to have fondled a student. Though the teacher was among the most highly ranked at the school:
http://www.ratemyteachers.com/pete-peterson/513066-t/3 Sidwell wasted no time in putting him on leave and reassuring the family. The final outcome was the best possible under the difficult circumstances. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/09/20/AR2010092005889.html |
| Meanwhile, Beauvoir let a pedophile walk away free from the campus. |
and your point is?????? |