First bolded point: Assuming that the point is winning, maybe. Second bolded point: I disagree. Why should a kid have to speak up to a coach to figure out what he's doing wrong? He should know, based on respectful communications from the coach at practice and through periodic player evaluations. "Get better" doesn't cut it. |
You're off the team. Get out. Wrong sport. This is not for you. We don't want you or your kid. Go away. Karen. or Chad. |
I think how much communication should be only the player depends a bit on the age group, and, like it or not, the parents are the final customers -- they are paying the bill. It's not fair to ask a younger child to be their own SOLE advocate. For instance, when our DD was U11, she had been coming off an injury and was frustrated that she was not getting play opportunities. Trying to teach her to speak for herself, we said, "go talk to Coach XXX after practice and say 'I'm disappointed I'm not playing more, could you give me some help in learning what I need to focus on to get back to where I was'".... Sounds like a good way to develop as a human, not just a soccer player, right? She did that and Coach XXX's response was something to the effect of "You have sucked lately at X, Y, and Z. You should be grateful for the playtime you get. You will stay on the bench until I decide you suck less." And it was actually more pointed than that -- I just don't remember the exact words anymore as it's been several years. She left the field that day in tears, and my husband and I felt compelled to contact the coach, which we did. Our question was -- "Sometimes kids misinterpret what was said -- did she? If so, what did you mean say? If not, why would you think it is at all okay to speak that way to a 10 year old who is just trying to respect you as a coach and get better." His response -- He is the coach, we are the parents, and we should shut up -- and he DID say what she heard.... Point being, PP's argument that ONLY the player should be communicating can't be true in all cases. Parents aren't protecting a snowflake when they speak up against something truly unacceptable. And younger kids can be scarred by this sort of experience -- it shouldn't be tolerated. Good communication is good business and good human relations. |
Wrong let me say it again WRONG.... A parent should be part of a meeting a team manager (if a volunteer parent) has no business being present. If a parent a player and a coach all have regular meetings and communication. The expectations for improvement can more easily be met. Whether the parent can help keep the player following the coaches plan from home. If the coach can help with the players and parents expectations to help the player in his goals. Communication is the one single thing that most travel coaches and clubs all need to improve on. If the excuse is there are too many kids to keep up with. Thats not acceptable period. Clubs dont spread your coaches too thin that your players are the main focus. Coaches if you dont have time to focus on what your players need your failing them and therefore failing as a coach. Parents if you cant help the team by having your kids on time and available for all training and games. encouraging them to work other own time to get better you are failing the player and the team your a member of just as much. We all need to work in accord with each other to achieve the goals we set as a team not just what the coach wants and not just what the parent and player want. |
Same thing we have done with our sons. My HS kid can now role into tryouts anywhere confident. He is now seeing the fruits of that grit and hard work pay off. He handled some pretty sh*tty situations much better than I would have at his young ages and didn't let it get him down. Along the way, I made sure to find mentors for him that truly believed in him. One happened to be the U9 Coach his first year of travel. He trained with him for years after they both left the Club and he left Coaching completely. He has been a great role model all of these years and could always make him feel better about a lot of the nonsense that goes on in travel soccer. There are good people in this sport. |
Perhaps you should take inventory here of what people think a "bad coach" is. Perhaps if you find yourself exhibiting the described behavior you should actively work to correct and improve that behavior. Just like you would want kids to work on their own to improve perhaps you should not consider yourself a finished project and realize that coaching is a learning and growing process as well. |
One thing I always did for my son was to show how things that seemed crappy at the time, ultimately ended up making him a much better player because it forced him to go find other options. Every.single.one of those times were for the better. He ended up in better situations and grew more as a player and got what he needed in that point in time. Adversity can be very good for growth and mental toughness. Those are truly great life lessons. |
There is something immensely satisfying in proving people wrong. |
| OP, if you are my son's coach in Alexandria, perhaps the reason that you identify us is that so many of us based on our posts is that we are united as a front in being opposed to you cursing at 13 year old kids during a soccer practice. If you are someone else, I apologize. |
| There were no player-coach or player-coach-parent or coach-parent conferences back in my travel days and I turned out fine. The coach coached, the kids played (some more than others), and the parents watched. And if the coach was pissed, the coach communicated that to the players with emotion but also constructively, even if it involved colorful metaphors. It was rare, so the players listened. We were not verbally or mentally abused at practices, but when it was time to call out the team for playing poorly it was done. |
Not a recipe for a happy life. |
Why? If he's someone else, you haven't attacked him. |
Quite the contrary. Everything in those last two posts builds resilience which is the key to happiness. |
Scoring a hat trick against the former douche coach that wronged you is fun! |
Or even better hearing he was fired!!!! |