I am not that poster but now that another thread shows the lousey SAT scores from the local Catholic school, yeah public is better. Facts do not lie. You want to pay for a religious private for the religious aspect fantastic but don't be deluded in thinking your kid is getting the best education offered. Any religious private is indoctrination before education. |
Character and happiness can’t be measured by an SAT score. As long as nearly all of a private school’s 11th graders hit college ready benchmarks it’s all gravy. The kids are equipped to handle the rigors of university. It’s not like you need to be a 1560 SAT scoring grind to become a fed, teacher, RN, PA, dentist, lobbyist, corporate drone, lawyer, engineer or even surgeon. |
Character can’t really be assured to be successfully taught by going to Catholic school either. It’s a huge leap to assume so. |
^ Yes, there is no guarantee that Catholic school will help them become decent, compassionate human beings, but the hope is that the school will reinforce the values taught at home, and like-minded people who want to have children here to serve and help their fellow neighbors will send their kids as well. I am a product of Catholic school K-top 20 college then noncatholic gradschool and the difference between the values and the people was shocking. This is why we are sending our kids to Catholic school because you should NOT define your worth as a parent based on "society's definition of success" but on who your children become and the character and values they demonstrate. |
Better odds than your Godless ethos. |
Religion doesn’t play a part in AP Physics, AP Chem, AP Bio, AP Stats, AP Calc BC, etc. I’m fairly confident my 12th grader is learning math and science. These classes got her accepted into 100% of the colleges she applied to and I know she’s prepared. As for religion, she has been taking World Religions this year and learning about Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, and Buddhism. She just wrote a massive paper about one of them, which incorporated a field trip to a mosque. So you can keep spouting off anti-Catholic rhetoric. Those of us with actual experience aren’t going to believe it. And posters here who may be considering Catholic schools will be reading about our real experiences versus your perceived judgments. |
OP this is the exact reason you don't engage with your neighbors about switching schools. The vitriol is real and I hate to say it, but I really think a lot of it is jealousy. Not that they want to attend the school you chose, but that you have options that they don't. I posted earlier that we switched many years ago, and we simply told neighbors it was for the religious education. We're Catholic. My youngest ended up doing 8 years of parochial school and is now at a highly sought after top Catholic all girls school. My son attended pubic through middle school and switch to a top Catholic all boys school for HS. He is now at a top 15 university -- admitted with no hooks. All I can say is that we feel the move we made to Catholic schools has made all the difference in our kids' futures. I can't imagine what it would have been like if we kept them in our very strong "W" school district. It has really gone downhill since covid, so I feel we made the right move at the right time. |
Boy that whole “love thy neighbor” and “judge not lest ye be judged” goes out the window fast when challenged even a little bit, doesn’t it? So much for the whole Catholic values, character, integrity spiel. |
Oh come on. That comment clearly got their point across to the doubter. Clearly anti-Catholic in tone and, yes, Godless. NP |
|
PP here. I'm not Catholic FWIW, but I send my kids to Catholic schools. And I don't tolerate bigots either. So your insights are not as accurate as you may think. |
| My neighbor is moving her kid to private next year. The only time it bothers me is when she veers into trashing the public school my son goes to—it’s clear she thinks that leaving her child there means he’ll end up on drugs. Which makes me roll my eyes, because private school *never* do drugs. It’s all minor crap—but if you care how you’re perceived, or about the other people’s feelings, just be cool and leave your feelings about the unsavory-ness of the public school out of it. |
| I'll take Catholic school over the non-binary fad our girls in independent private school are fed nonstop in middle school. Public school isn't much better. |
+1 our neighbors are doing this and I really just wish they’d stop taking about it. Their kids keep talking about how much better it is going to be and my DD is upset. It’s also becoming clear they don’t want their kids in with kids with special needs and “lower income problems,” which hurts my feelings because one of my kids is AuHD… they’re basically saying they don’t want to be with kids like him. |
| Just say it in a factual way and don't try to "justify" it with all these things that are unique to your kids (unless it's truly special needs) or worse yet saying negative things about the public school (have been in those conversations, totally unprovoked). Most people don't care and if they judge they will do so silently. |