11:49 was a hypothetical guess at a possible other side of the story.
We had a nanny for more than three years who behaved in much the same way as that hypothetical scenario, and who also had increasing unreliability, growing depression, etc... She is a lovely person and she dearly loved our kids, but she was no longer the best solution. We debated putting the kids in an early preschool, because frankly that would have been MUCH easier than telling her she was no longer good enough. It wasn't the best solution for our kids though, so we fired the nanny and replaced her with someone more appropriate and suited for their current ages and needs. It was very hard. Lots of parents don't have experience hiring and managing other people, much less in such personal circumstances. So putting a child in preschool can be an easier way for them to end a nanny relationship that wasn't working. Whether that's right or not for the child(ren) in question is for the parents to decide. But it is pretty unlikely that serious harm will be done given a stable home life. It might even be a real improvement for the kid. |
OF COURSE IT IS FOR THE PARENTS TO DECIDE!!! Who is debating that?! This is simply an educated nanny worried about her charge adjusting to daycare. Christ, DCUM is really bugging me today. So many fricking Drama Queens! The nanny feels bad. I get it. She will miss her charge. She doesn't thing the parents have made the right decision. THAT IS ALL THAT OP SAID. She wants ways to best handle the transition. Maybe one or two MBs and no nannies gave her any suggestions on how to best handle it for her charge! The rest of you just gave noise. |
Nanny here. I've worked with temp single parents (one deployed or is out of country for a month+ at a time) and full-time single parents. I nanny and tutor, so I'm at every conference, and frequently schedule extras. If the parent writes a list of questions and has the opportunity to listen to the taped conference (including my questions) and make a call later for follow-up, why would they be less involved than the parent who goes, nods and leaves without caring? |
Actually, a few nannies did. Telling her to get out is valid, as the child hasn't moved yet, and daycare won't start for a few weeks, so the child can start to get over losing her first, before dealing with the other changes. |
My son started his excellent home daycare at 20 months and was done with adjustment by the end of his first week. |
You have no idea what their financial situation is, and you have no business telling other families how to organize their financial priorities. I would personally never touch my savings for childcare. |
You have no idea what's more important for that boy. And if he stayed with the nanny for one more year, she'd still be here hand-wringing about having to say goodbye and how she is SO emotional. |
And this is why I would never have 4 kids and work FT. You cannot parent them properly without a partner who is present. Not making it to parent teacher conferences. Pitiful. |
Maybe MB is 12 weeks along with a second child.
Maybe they were hoping to put off daycare a little longer, but know they can't afford a nanny for two small children. Excellent daycares are difficult to get into, and it's much easier to get a sibling in than snag an open spot as a FTP. It would make sense, then, they'd take the opportunity of this spot opening up so they can have quality, secured childcare for both their children. There are just so many possibilities here, I absolutely do not believe previous outraged posters are MBs. Let's all assume every mom we know is doing the best she can for her family. |
They just aren't as important as you think. |
I am not telling anybody anything, PP. I am relaying my experience, situation and opinion. You know - what people do on opinion boards like this. Since I do not know OP's employers I can only take her word for it. I put my child FIRST above all else. I guess not everyone else does. |
^^^^^^^ |
Actually the nanny was the one left apologizing for her silly tantrum. |
Yes, you are the bestest mother in the world. No one else can approach your mothering abilities. Everyone else is simply incapable of your level of devotion. You said you are in your salad years. You know what, it totally shows in how black and white your vision of the world is. |
You not only missed the point, PP, - you also missed OP's subsequent posts. I also think that OP's MB is making a huge mistake with her child. She should wait a year. And it will be hard for OP after a year as well but at least then she won;t have to worry about her charge. I get it. |