Forum Index
»
DC Public and Public Charter Schools
Just stop already. Janney is the least racially diverse school in NW. I know that doesn't matter to you, but it is valuable information for many people looking to make a choice about where to send their kids. Also, as literally any PoC will tell you, kids being raised to be "inclusive" but who have never encountered Black or Latino folks outside a service/nanny capacity can still be incredibly cruel, even if they don't mean to be. |
|
OP here. This thread seems to have gone off the rails on the typical issues every DCUM thread does.
First, I want to thank everyone for their sincere responses. I did not know for example that there were scheduled days for tours for prospective families in DCPS. I will definitely be looking into that. Second, I want to thank the people who responded that there was good international diversity at Janney in the younger grades, where my DC is. That is important to know and in line with our current experience in MCPS, which is comforting. This type of information does not typically come out in the stats and provides a richer understanding of the underlying dynamics at the school. Third, I want to also thank the people who have responded who made similar moves from MCPS to DCPS. Your responses have been invaluable and support my hypothesis that there is a disconnect between current reputations, educational quality and outcomes. Fourth, I just want to address the people who ask "why Janney?" We currently live in an edge community near downtown Bethesda with easy access to the Red Line and amenities. We also have a yard and off-street parking. For our family, we would basically be looking to sell our house at its current value and buy a house in DC with similar amenities at the same value. Homes in AU Park/Tenley sell at the same price level, provide similar amenities that we are accustomed to now and wouldn't want to give up, with the hopeful benefits of less crowded schools, sidewalks, more control over development, and a shorter commute with more commuting options if Metro ever disintegrates. On top of that, it is just my hunch that DC will continue an upward trajectory while MoCo will continue a downward trajectory. So a home in NW DC feels like a much safer investment over the long term, particularly if the schools in NW DC are also no worse and perhaps even better in some ways as many have explained. The tuition assistance grant is also a big bonus. |
What makes you think that Janney or Upper NW kids more generally have never encountered minorities outside of a service capacity? How is that even possible in this city? Certainly not true for my kids, who have a racially diverse group of friends. |
| Op, I agree about the trajectory of DC vs. MoCo. However, keep in mind that the combo of a great elementary school that most kids in the neighborhood attend (vs. private or charter), low inventory, suburban feel, and metro access means that there is keen competition for homes zoned for Janney--take a look at some of the recent AU Park threads over in Real Estate. Actually, all neighborhoods zoned for Deal/Wilson are hot markets. In addition to a little bit more diversity, you may want to consider casting a wider net during your home search, given the competition in AU Park and other areas. |
When was the last time you heard of a white kid from the UK shot and killed by the police? #whiteprivilege |
NP here. The deplorable fact that black men are more likely to be killed by police has literally nothing to do with the question whether OP should choose Janney (or a similarly white school) or one with more racial diversity. So go find another thread for that undoubtedly important discussion. |
Sorry, unless you equate "diverse" with black, this is simply not true. Just compare the demographics of Janney with those of Shepherd: Janney: 7% Black, non-Hispanic 3% Asian 73% White, non-Hispanic 9% Hispanic/Latino 8% Multiracial Shepherd: 78% Black, non-Hispanic 9% White, non-Hispanic 8% Hispanic/Latino 4% Multiracial Janney has more multiracial kids, about the same (but very slightly bigger) amount of Latinos, and it also has a few Asians, which Shepherd entirely lacks. The difference is that Janney's majority group is white, while Shepherd's is black, but Janney's majority is 5 percentage points smaller than Shepherd's. There you have it, and I'm sure one could find other examples. This is not to say that OP's kid might not feel more demographically comfortable at Shepherd or another school with a larger PoC population. Only she can decide that. |
NP. It's definitely possible if you live in Upper NW and don't stray to far or head into MD often. "Never" is dramatic but it is true that in Upper NW that the residents are mostly white with some international, and most of the people of color encountered work in services. I say this as someone who grew up in the the area, attended Murch, Deal and Wilson, am not white, and still live in the city but could never live in that part of town again. |
I doubt there are too many who live their lives entirely within the confines of Upper NWDC. |
| Janney is 4% English language learners. That doesn't scream diversity from other countries tires to me unless all the diverse kids you're talking about are from U.K. and Australia which is not likely. Having a parent that was born in Argentina does not make a school international. Stop trying to make Janney what it's not. It's a white enclave, a way for liberal to live in the city without having to encounter specifically black people. And if Janney (and Lafayette) families could have it their way they'd remove Shepherd, Bancroft and OOB feeders too. |
+1 |
You are clueless. Just look at the educators and administrators of the schools you mentioned or are those "service" jobs to you? I tend to think of them as role models for my kids and frankly the most time they spend outside of home is at school! |
I don't think you know what the word "enclave" means. Janney and AU Park are not enclaves. The demographic differences between Janney and other WOTP elementaries are negligible, as are the differences between AU Park and its surrounding neighborhoods as well as the adjoining suburbs. I know you have a particular beef with Janney and AU Park, but they are just not that special. |
Shepherd is 78% black, sure, but actually has a good amount of international diversity within that population. There's a sizeable Ethiopian population, for example, along with West African, Caribbean, black Latino families, etc. |
The funny thing is that previous PP doesn't realize he's the one living in some little black enclave. Folks...in our country only 10% of people have black skin. |