It depends on the context. In context, Jeong's "marking up the internet" tweet -- which you don't even quote correctly -- may not be not humorous, but it is also obviously not racist. In context, she is clearly referring to specific tweets and the (presumably) white authors of those tweets. She wasn't referring to all white people. It's also pretty obvious to anyone with a brain that she doesn't really want to cancel all white people. You seem to want to read her tweets in a vacuum without any context and without any additional knowledge of her. That is a mistake. To address your question, if a white person made a joke about the opinions of specific black people (not sure why you want to pick on black people when they had nothing to do with this, but you be you), I'm not sure anyone would even flinch. That sort of thing happens all the time. Look at all the criticism of Maxine Waters and people who support her. Do you consider that entirely racist? If a white person used a "cancel black people" hashtag, it would most likely be considered racist. The US being what it is, the idea of cancelling white people is clearly absurd and not serious. Sadly, the idea of cancelling black people has some historical resonance and cannot clearly be understood as hyperbole or not literal. Again, these things can't be looked at in a complete vacuum. History and the existing power structure need to be considered. |
This is the skewed, sick mindset we’re dealing with. Of course, it’s perfectly fine for liberals to dig up offensive remarks made YEARS ago and use them against people today (Trump, etc.). No double standard at all! |
....and the poster rightfully banned. But here, the racist is being defended, with a weak attempt to paint her as "funny," |
You can thank Sarah Jeong for that. |
| This discussion is making me question how much of the outrage about Jeong's tweets is manufactured for partisan purposes and how much is really a result of acute snowflakeism. Are you folks really this threatened by someone picking fun of you? She is basically turning a mirror on you and you are having a heart attack. It's astonishing. |
Just when I thought your empty rationalizations couldn’t get any lower... -DP |
Why don't you take time to explain your disagreement? |
See? Even your remark about your not knowing why I'd "pick on black people" but "you be you""stinks of an accusation of racism on my part. Look at how you twist things around in an attempt to defend the anti-white racist, while "hinting" at racism at the white girl who objects to what she sees as obvious racist hate speech And the reason I used black people as an example is because....duh.... it is the perfect counterpoint. It's "funny" when it's against whites and racist against blacks. Would you have preferred I used Muslims or Hispanics as an example? (I didn't, because it's not as obvious a comparison.) But if I did that, dollars to donuts you'd ask me why I was "picking" on Muslims or Hispanics. I could go on, but what's the expression about teaching a pig to sing? You simply will not admit you were wrong on this one - obviously wrong to everyone but a few extreme progressives around here - so I give up. |
Considering I’ve never spoken about anyone, regardless of race, the way she has - and I don’t know anyone who speaks like that - she’s not turning a mirror on decent people. She’s simply exposing herself as a hater of white people with an enormous chip on her shoulder. She deserves to be fired from the NYT. |
Kind of like how all the outrage about Trump's tweets, statements and policies is manufactured for partisan purposes, and how much is really a result of Trump Derangement Syndrome. |
Don't you get it? It's not about this one racist. It's about the revelation of the double standard that liberals, and the NYT is particular, have when it comes to racism - and which you demonstrate again and again with each of your posts. Against blacks: Completely unacceptable. Against whitey? So funny! |
Yes, I think your choice of black people for your example is revealing. Your entire list of blacks, Muslims, or Hispanics are groups that face daily prejudice. Obviously, kicking people when they are down is not funny,. Jeong herself is Asian, but for some reason you didn't consider using them for your hypothetical. This is an important part of what Jeong was illustrating -- she was simply showing white people how minorities get treated every day. |
Trump routinely questions the intelligence of black people. Yet, you support him. Jeong compares the opinions of a few white people to dog droppings and you want her fired. Tell me again who is deranged? |
|
It's more about the fact that such a person, if making fun of any other ethnicity, would not only be not hired by the NYT, but leftists would make sure she never worked again. But because she was making fun of white folk, she's to be lauded. |