DP, but wanted to add something similar. If something unexpected comes up DH and I will compare schedules. For instance if he has a big morning meeting and I’m giving an afternoon presentation, then we split our day. Or we will trade things around (e.g. if I handle this unexpected day off, will you handle the next teacher workday?). This absolutely requires a spouse who is a good partner and values your career. I make about 45% of our HHI + benefits so neither of us is in a position to blow off our jobs without majorly affecting our lifestyle. Either both jobs matter or you have 1 high earner and the other with a fun or part time job. You can’t have 2 co-earners and a default parent without destroying your marriage. |
So your kids spent like 8-6 in childcare? I get it is sustainable (probably with some negative side effects) if you have no other choice, but I think most people (especially now that workplaces are offering more flexibility) do not aspire to this lifestyle. And I especially can’t imagine kids of a former SAHM transitioning to this well. |
I am a different PP and so agree with this. I make 60% of our HHI but we've leapfrogged around and DH has outearned me in the past. Both jobs matter (for income but we also like our careers substantively). This is a real split and it works for us because we have that mutual respect but also we both have some flexibility. |
I went to undergrad with a child of FSOs and my god, she was the most entitled person I had ever encountered (even more than the moneyed "W" kids) from having servants her entire life. |
For awhile we did the trade off of me having a lower paying but flexible job. DH was also able to go in early and be home by 5:30 every day. Then I got a more intense job but kids were older so didn’t need direct supervision, I was able to WFH, we arranged elaborate carpools, and DH cashed in on flexibility from seniority and does a ton for the family (ortho appointments, leaving at 3 once a week to drive carpool, etc). We also let a lot of stuff go. Our house is kind of a mess, taxes get filed at the 11th hour, we don’t cook the elaborate meals that we used to.
I think the key is someone needs flexibility, or you need family help, or you need outside help, or your kids spend long days in aftercare and only do extracurriculars through school or on weekends. |
I don't think that PP said it was "aspirational" nor is that what OP asked for. She asked what people do as a practical matter. The PP shared one common example. It's not everyone's experience (I am a WFH PP above, so it's not even my experience) but I don't think you need to be so judgmental about it. Also aftercare varies. Ours has clubs, sports you can sign up for. It's not some kind of bad monolith like some make it out to be. Not necessarily that different than being shuttled to an afterschool activity by a SAHM or nanny. |
I doubt anyone can do it all. The people claiming that they do it all because their nanny is looking after their kids are only doing the work. They are not spending time with their children to the same degree a SAHM is. So, no one is doing it all. Plus, what is doing it ALL even means. What are your priorities?
I am a highly educated SAHM. I only have two kids who are NT and high achieving. I am not doing the work that a mom with ND kids is doing. I am not juggling the needs of more than 2 kids. We do not have pets. I am not looking after the needs of pets. I am not providing elder care currently. We live in an average neighborhood with average schools, but it is a nice, large SFH. My kids go to magnet public schools that are 45 minutes away and I drop them and pick them up every single day. I spend 3 hours on the road, my kids spend 1.5 hours travelling. But I save the cost of private school and get an amazing education for my kids. I pay for tutors for EC and acceleration for my kids, but I spend more to have them come home. This costs more but saves my kids travel times. I pay to get some of my domestic chores outsourced. But, I am still managing this and my time goes in that. We host pretty consistently and I do all the planning, entertainment, decorating and cooking elaborate meals for 30-50 people at times - but I pay for servers, cleaners, bartenders. So, who is doing it ALL? No one. My kids were raised by me so I saved money on childcare and my kids got excellent care. BUT, I did not earn money for this. Thankfully, my DH makes enough that we do not need my paycheck for their college and our retirement, but if he didn't then my not earning a paycheck would have cost my family and jeopardized my children's future. |
When the kids were younger than all day school we had an aupair who did their laundry. She worked all but 1 Saturday a month so I could go out with H or friends. I ran errands every Wednesday and/or went to the gym and/or happy hour. My H knew he had to do Wednesdays. My kids did aftercare which is not 11 hour days, it's a school day with a built in play date after. Even SAHM's used aftercare because their kids were jealous that everybody was playing together after school. It's just a big recess. I never worked till 6 I went into work at 7am and was home by 5. But I cooked M/T/W Th was leftovers, F was pizza or chinese or whatever. Saturday was usually date night or cook out or something social that involved food. Sunday H cooked. My kids did 2 travel sports and we did carpools and most our coaches were men with jobs so practice was after work. High school the kids are essentially independent with activities after school at school and kids get home at 7 or 8 pm. We had a cleaning person come once every 2 weeks. Laundry went in every morning, home went in drying, then I folder before i went to bed, 1 load of laundry / day. Did sheets and towels on the weekend. I get up at 6am every morning naturally so 6am-8am or 10am or 12 (when they were teens) was coffee and "mom stuff"... planning, ordering Amazon (actually there was no Amazon I went to Target), grocery shopping (which is now delivery). If you are worried about food get a meal plan for a few days a week. You seem to be catastrophizing or making excuses. |
SAHM's are not spending all their time with their kids and if they are why even.. that's more odd than spending a couple hours a day with them. It's so weird, your kid gets home from school at 3pm and you stay by their side... every single one of them from 3pm-9pm. That's weird. You homeschool? |
Part of it is also having 1 or 2 kids. 3 seems impossible to do any activities that arent together. I see lots of siblings at martial arts waiting for their session while the other kid is in. |
No |
After care and work from home (to the extent possible). We’ve managed to go without a nanny/Au pair for several years because of aftercare, and we are not at all alone. Sometimes my kids whine about it, and sometimes I pick them up early just because. But overall I don’t think the long day at school is that bad. My kids get their homework done in aftercare and they have friends to hang out with. Easy dinners, even having my junior chef children cook them sometimes. Having a nanny/Au pair was on balance more trouble than doing it “all” but I’m also not good at managing people and am an introvert. |
|
Awww, Honey!! |
Are you lacking reading comprehension? No, I do not homeschool but my kids are enriched and accelerated in subjects and ECs that are not covered by the school. I want them to have succeed in college and career, so I spend time in making sure that opportunities are identified or created for them so that they have an edge, ![]() |