My opinion is that her doctor should have been able to give her all of the information about her condition and all of the information regarding best treatment. Texas has made that illegal. If she had all the information to make a decision, that would be fine. She was not. |
Early in her pregnancy when her first serious complications appeared she should have been counseled of the dangers of continuing the pregnancy and offered and abortion. If she chose to continue she should have had the insurance coverage and social safety net to make she she got the care she needed including paid bed rest so that she didn’t have to make a decision to work against medical advice; at 21 or so weeks when it was really really bad she should have been offered to have the pregnancy terminated. If she said no she was taking her chances she should have been kept in the hospital —paid for so she didn’t worry about $$$$ — and then delivered once she got past viability around 24 weeks. With all her preemie bills paid for by decent health insurance. That’s what we are advocating for. Try getting conservatives to agree to that. Ya’ll just blame her for being obese and getting pregnant and say not on my taxpayer dime and then pay yourself on the back for being “pro-life.” Hypocrites. |
Women are not offered abortions by their ob-gyns or family doctors because they are obese and/or diabetic. |
There you have it folks, the conservative talking point about dead mothers: it’s their fault. Shouldn’t have gotten pregnant in the first place. Shouldn’t have been so poor, so unhealthy. No insurance? Too bad so sad, not our fault. Nothing we can do but force sick women to go to term even if it kills both them and the fetus. At least it would be god’s will and not a human killing the baby. Somehow that is “pro-life.” And “for the people.” |
|
People moving to Texas
Feeing California |
No but when they have a life-threatening pregnancy they are. Except in Texas and other red states. |
There are many way better alternatives than Texas. |
If you want to have the best care for pregnant women, avoid Texas. |
| And her doctor should have had the entire range of medical options available for the patient, including abortion. |
|
Why couldn’t they deliver her early at 23 weeks? That seems to be when this situation could have had the best possible outcome available.
Yes, I realize that is extreme prematurity. But that would have given both the best possible chance of survival. After having read this, the obvious answer here is pregnancy was the condition that was causing her other conditions to escalate and lead to her and her daughter’s death. Maybe she would have chosen to remain pregnant, but it is pretty clear that being in TX limited her care. |
Did you miss the recent case where the Texas AG personally went after a woman who wanted to end a much-wanted pregnancy to save her life? She ended up having to go to another state to get that abortion. Oh we know, you ghouls think she should be bleeding out in a parking lot before the state gives the green light to the abortion. Disgusting. |
|
Maternal Health Conditions
For people with certain severe medical problems, the biological stress of pregnancy can be dangerous or deadly. These situations could include a severely compromised heart or a new diagnosis of dangerous cancer requiring immediate treatment. These cases are unusual and recommending a termination is not done lightly. Your doctor should thoroughly assess the risks and benefits of continuing your pregnancy, including your wishes, and work with you to choose a satisfactory treatment plan. It's important to note that it is possible for some women to receive chemotherapy during pregnancy, at least during the second and third trimester. If you are diagnosed with cancer during pregnancy it is important to work with both an obstetrician who specializes in high-risk pregnancies and an oncologist who is comfortable treating women who are pregnant. Severe Pre-Eclampsia Rarely, a woman can develop severe pre-eclampsia before a fetus is viable (can live outside the womb). Because the only known cure for pre-eclampsia is delivery, it may be necessary to end a pregnancy to save a mother's life.13 Continuing a pregnancy with severe pre-eclampsia can lead to seizures, kidney failure, stroke, liver complications, and death. Selective Reduction In multiple pregnancies, your doctor may recommend a selective reduction, or terminating one or more of the fetuses. This is intended to decrease risk to the other babies or the mother. For example, if in vitro fertilization is done and seven embryos implant, a woman may choose to reduce this to two or three in order to prevent the likely loss of all the embryos. Premature Rupture of Membranes Premature rupture of membranes (PROM) is a condition in which the bag of waters (amniotic sac) breaks before the pregnancy reaches full term.11 There are many reasons why this happens. If PROM occurs prior to 24 weeks gestation, physicians may recommend a therapeutic termination because the lack of fluid will severely impair the normal development of the baby’s organs. There is also a high risk of infection for the pregnant person. If you become infected, ending your pregnancy may be the only cure. https://www.verywellfamily.com/reasons-for-therapeutic-termination-2371295#:~:text=It%20is%20only%20recommended%20in,death%20by%20continuing%20the%20pregnancy. These are reasons doctors generally recommend women terminate their pregnancies for the sake of the health of the mother. Being morbidly obese, diabetic and not taking your medication aren’t reasons for pregnancy termination. The most important issue everyone here is avoiding is this: Attitudes toward termination of pregnancy are a matter of individual conviction and conscience that should be respected. If a woman does not want to abort her baby, even if she is facing death, or the baby is facing disability and/or death, the mother will not be forced to abort her baby. You all are 100% all in on upholding the individual conviction of a woman to have an abortion, even if she is healthy and the baby is healthy. You all respect a woman’s decision to abort her baby at any time. Some women even believe a baby who is born should be allowed to be “aborted.” "[Third trimester abortions are] done in cases where there may be severe deformities. There may be a fetus that's nonviable. So in this particular example, if a mother is in labor, I can tell you exactly what would happen," Northam, a pediatric neurosurgeon, told Washington radio station WTOP. "The infant would be delivered. The infant would be kept comfortable. The infant would be resuscitated if that's what the mother and the family desired. And then a discussion would ensue between the physicians and the mother." https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2019/01/31/politics/ralph-northam-third-trimester-abortion/index.html But should a woman choose to continue a high risk pregnancy, nobody is out there fighting for her to keep her baby and both baby and mom receive the best care possible to both live. This woman’s death and her baby’s death: why aren’t medical professionals and women who are concerned with their deaths bringing attention to Texas women who are geographically isolated and the lack of medical facilities that specialize in maternal care? Ask the Texas State government to study her case specifically and others like hers. Women deserve good care for their pregnancies. Find a way to try and help Texas women get that care. Women should not have to abort their wanted babies because their hometown is geographically isolated. Texas is a big, big state. I have lived in South Texas, West Texas, and New Mexico. The challenge of providing pregnant Texas women with high risk pregnancies good medical care during their pregnancy is a big, big issue that will need big, big solutions. But something other than telling pregnant women to either abort their babies or die can be done. I refuse to believe that’s all we as a society can offer our pregnant women and their babies. Even if women with high risk pregnancies in isolated areas are admitted to their closest hospital that provides the level of maternal care they need to continue their pregnancy safely. No mother should be told she has to abort her baby if there is medical care available to allow her to safely continue her pregnancy. Texas has a lot of issues with providing medical care to citizens in isolated and geographically remote areas. There are not enough medical doctors to provide care to the huge state and population. Even in larger areas, obtaining medical care, finding a family pcp, is sometimes impossible. Doctors are overwhelmed and it has been made worse by the overwhelming number of immigrants who have come into America. This woman was an immigrant. If you care about women, offer them more than killing their wanted babies. |
They didnt' offer that to her, most likely because of Texas's draconian laws. 23 weeks is still super early and 40% of babies delivered then don't survive. No one wants the state coming after them. |
Sure, but therapeutic abortions should be one of the options available for patient and doctor in life-threatening situations. The state should not be restricting options. It should be making more options available. Did you know that Texas rejected accepting expanded medicaid benefits? https://www.texasmonthly.com/news-politics/medicaid-expansion-benefits-legislature/
|
^^^Willful misreading. It's been said time and again in this thread that this woman should have had a better social safety net, had better health insurance, had paid sick leave so that she could go on bed rest, have doctors who could talk to her about EVERYTHING including the option of terminating, should have had the option of delivering at the point of viability. But you conservatives refuse to engage with those issues at all. Besides her death, what is horrifying is the reality and consequences of a state refusing to give women the choice of continuing or ending a pregnancy. If they choose to against medical advice there should be safeguards to help them. But if they decide they don't want to risk dying they should also have the option of ending their pregnancy. You are making this specifically about this one horrific story. When it's a much larger story about what pregnant women in Texas face. Will you step up and speak if there's a story about a woman who wanted to terminate a pregnancy, was not given that option, and then died? Will you? Doubtful. You'll find a way to blame her for her own death. |