No, that is not quite how we make public health decisions. |
There are benefits for both businesses (like hospitals) and the community. It's in all of our best interests to have as many people healthy as possible. |
Sure, it is. Wearing masks isn't perfect, but they help. Wearing seatbelts isn't perfect, but they help. Vaccines & boosters aren't perfect, but they help. |
Well then, I certainly hope you vocally support an anti-obesity mandate. Losing weight likely has even more of a protective factor and keeps as many people healthy as possible. Yet, I’m not hearing any mandates for that. |
|
It was obvious in April 2020 that every single person in our ICU was either frail elderly or fat. I predicted that this would be the death knell for "fat acceptance" and doctors would encourage patients to lose weight in time for Covid season (which we all knew was going to be a reality for years to come). How wrong I was.
|
More high risk? Yes. Everyone? No. I mean, really which do you think Nick Cordero was? He was in his early 40s and a Broadway dancer, incredibly fit. |
I fully support businesses/government mandates to provide whatever we need to eliminate obesity. Restrict junk food, soda taxes, etc. Subsidize gym memberships. Mandate businesses offer breaks for exercise & offer healthy food options. Great. So we will mandate vaccines & offer healthy lifestyles.
|
That’s not the same at all. Taxes on soda? That’s just trying to disincentivize people. It’s not a mandate. A mandate would be more equivalent to a: Soda Ban - no soda sold at any store anywhere Junk Food Ban Yet, you’re not advocating for that? Just taxes to disincentivize people from buying those items. You want to offer bonuses to people for getting vaccinated? Go for it. I have no issue with that. But mandates? No way. |
No, you means you will mandate vaccines and MANDATE healthy lifestyles. If you want to crack down, you don’t get to pick and choose. |
Awwww. Don’t be a spoil sport. I was just playing along with PP’s dumb strawman. Guess we should back up. What does PP mean by an “anti-obesity mandate”? Let’s hear it. 🍿 |
Why should the government pay the unvaccinated to get the vaccine. That would punish the people who got the vaccine. A better incentive would be to have a covid surcharge on your health insurance. Let insurance charge unvaccinated people market rates for covid related treatment. So you go to the ER because of covid you are responsible for the bills. I am all for that! |
How do you “mandate lifestyle” exactly? Because we already do mandate vaccines. So there is a precedent there… |
Somehow, this gets lost in the shuffle every time discussion around a COVID vaccine mandate comes up. The vast, vast, vast majority of Americans were perfectly comfortable with mandated vaccines for polio, measles, Hepatitis B, etc, until Trump came along and broke Republicans' brains. |
| You voted for this. |
No. Most people in the DC area did not vote for this. |