DP. This is a crazy statement. No one who takes a wider view will agree with you. |
Wow. Your privilege is showing. You clearly have no idea how hard this has been and will continually be for single parents, esol students, immigrants, low income families etc... My prediction is that once school starts back we are going to see news stories of kids dying Or being seriously hurt from being left Home alone when Their parents had to make the difficult choice to go to work to be able to afford food or stay hike with their kids and starve. The fact that you think these families are worried about their Netflix accounts and insurance levels is laughable. People who are already struggling don't have those things to cut back on. Try to look beyond yourself and realize that school closures are causing much more than an "inconvenience". |
Pp, it is commonly known that kids know what they need to know by 14 and that high school is just warehousing |
Ask me how much I care? I am right. It is immaterial whether others agree with me. My objective is not persuasion but explaining to others HOW things will be, not asking whether they agree with it. People like the pp seem to believe their views on this are valid and worthy of being heard. They’re not. |
Slight distinction: the answer is easy, in fact. It's just not pleasant. |
Yeah, “no significant impact on mortality” is not the same as saying that the benefits don’t outweigh the costs. Also, this is not what bioethicists do, they research the ethics of bio research, e.g. stem cells etc. I just hope you are not in a position to influence things as you seem to be ready to condemn the elderly and the already ill to not just any, but a horrible death. |
Must be nice to go through life with such a simplistic, black and white view of the world, and such certainty of your own righteousness. Fortunately for DCUM, your forum is DCUM, and not any context in which thinking about these dilemmas actually leads to real life decisions. |
| *fortunately for everybody I meant to say |
You are wrong about that. Educate yourself. Bioethicists's work is not confined to stem cell research and related fields. |
| I keep hearing that schools in NJ and and NY (city suburbs, no idea about upstate) are planning for in person. Why can’t the DMV schools?? |
Right, those are two separate parts of the argument. But "no significant impact on mortality" doesn't mean the closures have "no effect", which is what you claimed I said. It means that the effect will likely not be large, and probably not big enough to justify the overall harms. We can debate whether they will or not, and then whether the benefits outweigh the harms, but the fact is, nobody knows what impact school closures have in THIS pandemic. Experience from past flu pandemics (where schools were closed for much shorter periods of time) is of limited value, because the flu is much more transmissible by children and affects the age groups who generally populate schools more severely. |
I’m sure it was just an oversight that you didn’t mention the millions of people that protested in May and June. The BLM Cloak of Virtue didn’t extend to people you disagree with amirite? Houston is a blue city, had 60,000 + protesters AND and Floyd funeral and their hospitals are busting at the seems. But obviously it was only republicans that caused this. |
Schools are not daycares. Suggest you start making childcare arrangements; you're going to need them. |
Actually, schools IS daycare as well for younger kids. The PP might be able to afford making arrangements, millions of people do not, and it's going to have ripple effects all around society: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/07/03/big-factor-holding-back-us-economic-recovery-child-care/ |
This is the norm. We can keep talking about privileged and the unprivileged. The reality is the virus doesn’t care. People are expecting to get back to the way things use to be but that’s not going to happen. Living in this delusional realm that things will go back to normal will hurt more people. Folks need to adapt. What folks don’t want to hear is that this virus will cause a larger division between the haves versus the have nots. Social programs are not going to be able to lessen the gap as revenue for these programs (ie taxes etc) will be taking a huge hit as the economy slides into a Great Depression error. Folks need to start arranging for their own support systems if they want to try to survive this without relying on social programs and yes that means numerous sacrifices that people don’t want to accept. This is our Great Depression era and people need to start to face this head on a figure out how they can make it work for their families. |