Dr Sneha Philip mystery - did she die in 9/11 attacks?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think she died in the attacks.

Doesn't look like it.

The husband may have killed her, she might have killed herself, she might have been randomly killed by someone she picked a fight with at a bar, or she may have left to live a new life. It's coincidence that it happened to be September 11.

She could have gotten drunk and fallen in the river

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Crime of opportunity?

Someone killed her late on the 10th, and then the 11th came around and the answer to "what do I do with this body now?" was obvious: it was the perfect opportunity to dispose of a body. I'd imagine there were piles and piles of garbage and burnt things, right? Were they searching everything for bodies? Would anyone notice a large garbage bag or duffel amidst the mess?[/quotei

I was in NYC at the time and worked nearby.t No way could a rando get close enough to dump a body. There were blockades blocks and blocks away.c

The weirdest thing is the 4 am call from the house to his cell phone. Was he really home?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I can't believe I never heard this story before.

Wow, I feel badly for that mom who's son with the pizza place job disappeared.

Where is the story about the pizza place son?

http://nypost.com/2003/11/02/anguish-over-2-off-the-911-list/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Crime of opportunity?

Someone killed her late on the 10th, and then the 11th came around and the answer to "what do I do with this body now?" was obvious: it was the perfect opportunity to dispose of a body. I'd imagine there were piles and piles of garbage and burnt things, right? Were they searching everything for bodies? Would anyone notice a large garbage bag or duffel amidst the mess?[/quotei

I was in NYC at the time and worked nearby.t No way could a rando get close enough to dump a body. There were blockades blocks and blocks away.c

The weirdest thing is the 4 am call from the house to his cell phone. Was he really home?

The 4am call was weird, he wasn't sure if he made it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think she died in the attacks.

Doesn't look like it.

The husband may have killed her, she might have killed herself, she might have been randomly killed by someone she picked a fight with at a bar, or she may have left to live a new life. It's coincidence that it happened to be September 11.

She could have gotten drunk and fallen in the river

Or that. I think any of these scenarios more likely. I feel bad for her family for lack of closure. Either way they've lost her, even if she's still alive.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Not op, but I knew Sneha. She was nothing like the person described in the NY Mag article, clearly she was at a real low point right before September 11. My opinion is that she was not the person on the security video, and did not die at the World Trade Center.

She was not seen by anyone after the afternoon after the 10th. So she either met with foul play that night or saw an opportunity to escape a life that was making her miserable. If she simply stayed with someone Monday night and died at the wtc, that person would have come forward.

What was she like?

Very charming, very sophisticated, very smart. Always dated men when I knew her, but never Indian men, that was her form of rebellion.

Her family does have closure, they truly believe that she did a hero at the wtc.

[Anonymous]

http://www.rediff.com/news/special/snehas-room-has-been-kept-the-same-way-for-the-past-15-years/20160911.htm

Thought this was a good read.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The most logical explanation is that she was at breakfast at Windows-she had said she wanted to check it out.

By herself at a restaurant? Weird.

Then who was she with the night before?

That's not so weird. People go alone to restaurants all the time. Especially if her intent was just to see it in advance of her friends' wedding.

They know who was at Windows on the World because they all lived through impact and had phone contact with emergency services. They identified everyone present and she was not there.

[Anonymous]

Her husband is very close to her family still. He remained a decade later and has a daughter.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The most logical explanation is that she was at breakfast at Windows-she had said she wanted to check it out.

By herself at a restaurant? Weird.

Then who was she with the night before?

That's not so weird. People go alone to restaurants all the time. Especially if her intent was just to see it in advance of her friends' wedding.

They know who was at Windows on the World because they all lived through impact and had phone contact with emergency services. They identified everyone present and she was not there.

That's why her family hasn't been insisting she was there, they believe she was rendering aid.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Crime of opportunity?

Someone killed her late on the 10th, and then the 11th came around and the answer to "what do I do with this body now?" was obvious: it was the perfect opportunity to dispose of a body. I'd imagine there were piles and piles of garbage and burnt things, right? Were they searching everything for bodies? Would anyone notice a large garbage bag or duffel amidst the mess?[/quotei

I was in NYC at the time and worked nearby.t No way could a rando get close enough to dump a body. There were blockades blocks and blocks away.c

The weirdest thing is the 4 am call from the house to his cell phone. Was he really home?

That 4am call stood out to me, too. But he said that he may have groggily been using the home phone to check messages on his cell phone and didn't have a clear memory of doing that because he was half asleep.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I don't believe that the Poster in this thread just happened to know her and happened upon this thread instantly. Lies

I clicked on the thread because I do know her. She went to college at Hopkins, not weird that a poster here would know her. Her disappearance is something I think about every 9-11 as do many of her friends. Wouldn’t you if a friend went missing?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The most logical explanation is that she was at breakfast at Windows-she had said she wanted to check it out.

By herself at a restaurant? Weird.

Then who was she with the night before?

That's not so weird. People go alone to restaurants all the time. Especially if her intent was just to see it in advance of her friends' wedding.

They know who was at Windows on the World because they all lived through impact and had phone contact with emergency services. They identified everyone present and she was not there.

That's why her family hasn't been insisting she was there, they believe she was rendering aid.

She was out walking around in day old clothes with packages and rendering aid.....unlikely, I suppose that's possible but still seems unlikely. Maybe she had another reason to be inside the Trade Center (friend? professional contact?), but she would have been wearing clothes that she had put on the day before...so a business meeting seems unlikely.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Not op, but I knew Sneha. She was nothing like the person described in the NY Mag article, clearly she was at a real low point right before September 11. My opinion is that she was not the person on the security video, and did not die at the World Trade Center.

She was not seen by anyone after the afternoon after the 10th. So she either met with foul play that night or saw an opportunity to escape a life that was making her miserable. If she simply stayed with someone Monday night and died at the wtc, that person would have come forward.

What was she like?

Very charming, very sophisticated, very smart. Always dated men when I knew her, but never Indian men, that was her form of rebellion.

Her family does have closure, they truly believe that she did a hero at the wtc.

Did you ever meet her husband?

[Anonymous]

Is it possible that the time is wrong on the 9/11, 8:43am video from her apartment building? Have experts studied the tape to ID her?

I also find the 4am call fishy. Do phone records show that this is something Ron did regularly: middle of the night cell phone message checks? And if his wife were missing, wouldn't he be sleeping next to his cell phone in case she called?

I smell the husband.