Dr Sneha Philip mystery - did she die in 9/11 attacks?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

Lots of people on the street and in nearby buildings died. People on the street were hit by falling bodies and debris, I specifically remember reading about people in nearby buildings dying in elevators and I think on top of WT7 I think. I assume when the towers fell more people were hit by debris but by the time they were found (or not found) they were buried under a pile of rubble so how would anyone know if they were in the building or on the sidewalk?

If someone wasn't actually inside the building though, it seems like their body maybe wouldn't have been burned up and would have been uncovered during rescue and recovery, no?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

Lots of people on the street and in nearby buildings died. People on the street were hit by falling bodies and debris, I specifically remember reading about people in nearby buildings dying in elevators and I think on top of WT7 I think. I assume when the towers fell more people were hit by debris but by the time they were found (or not found) they were buried under a pile of rubble so how would anyone know if they were in the building or on the sidewalk?

If someone wasn't actually inside the building though, it seems like their body maybe wouldn't have been burned up and would have been uncovered during rescue and recovery, no?

Tons of rubble. There are a lot of people whose remains have never been retrieved--around a 1,000.

[Anonymous]

Yup, about 1,000: https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/9-11-anniversary/still-missing-unidentified-remains-leave-lingering-void-9-11-families-n642076

[Anonymous]

Where did her packages go? She bought a number of items at Century 21 on 9/10. She must have left those packages somewhere; she didn't bring them home. Presumably she spent the night with someone, friend or pick-up, and left them there. If she had died on 9/11, why would the person who she spent that night with not come forward to the grieving family to give them some answers about her last day on earth?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Where did her packages go? She bought a number of items at Century 21 on 9/10. She must have left those packages somewhere; she didn't bring them home. Presumably she spent the night with someone, friend or pick-up, and left them there. If she had died on 9/11, why would the person who she spent that night with not come forward to the grieving family to give them some answers about her last day on earth?

I think that remains the question.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

People on street did die. Know of federal employee who had meeting in one of the towers that morning but was hit by falling debris while on street outside. In hospital for long time after and then died.

[Anonymous]

I think she was murdered the night of September 10th and the murderer lucked out in all the pandemonium from 9/11. Also, her family let the police astray by issuing about false statement about how she had called from the towers. They were trying to be helpful by making the police look in the towers for her, but all they did was waste valuable time that could have been spent investigating the real circumstances under which she died. I think that all the time wasted looking for Sneha near the twin towers gave the murderer a chance to dispose of her body and cover his or her tracks.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

Lots of people on the street and in nearby buildings died. People on the street were hit by falling bodies and debris, I specifically remember reading about people in nearby buildings dying in elevators and I think on top of WT7 I think. I assume when the towers fell more people were hit by debris but by the time they were found (or not found) they were buried under a pile of rubble so how would anyone know if they were in the building or on the sidewalk?

Here is the official list of classifications: https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2004/07/federal-investigators-classify-wtc-victims-locations-within-collapsed

Only 18 bystanders killed and 17 unknown. They really were able to match people up with their location.

[Anonymous]

I'm curious on the story for the other 16 unknown location victims. Sneha must be number 17 in that count.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Where did her packages go? She bought a number of items at Century 21 on 9/10. She must have left those packages somewhere; she didn't bring them home. Presumably she spent the night with someone, friend or pick-up, and left them there. If she had died on 9/11, why would the person who she spent that night with not come forward to the grieving family to give them some answers about her last day on earth?

I think that remains the question.

I'm leaning toward the theory that she overdosed, and her party buddies just dumped her body and her packages somewhere they wouldn't be found.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I think she was murdered the night of September 10th and the murderer lucked out in all the pandemonium from 9/11. Also, her family let the police astray by issuing about false statement about how she had called from the towers. They were trying to be helpful by making the police look in the towers for her, but all they did was waste valuable time that could have been spent investigating the real circumstances under which she died. I think that all the time wasted looking for Sneha near the twin towers gave the murderer a chance to dispose of her body and cover his or her tracks.

Which is why I keep going back to the husband.

He got the brother to lie. He could have easily killed her, dumped the shopping bags and her. He filed her death under the victim's compensation fund. He put together the narrative of her disappearance. He "found" the 'very grainy' video of someone that he says may have been her without bags standing at the elevator and then going back outside on 9/11.

She went shopping during the day. No purchases were made on the credit card after that. Nothing to eat, nothing to drink? All night. And she carried around shopping bags with her on her night on the town? Partying in NYC meant drinks on tab and Yadigan's at 3 am without hauling around shopping bags. There was nothing. There is also nothing showing that she didn't just go home to her husband that then killed her.

[Anonymous]

Has anyone in the public ever seen the apartment camera footage from the morning of 9/11? I've only seen quotes that her family and the PI saw it, and thought the woman could have been her. Is it posted somewhere?

[Anonymous]

Why is the location of her bags a crucial piece of info?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Where did her packages go? She bought a number of items at Century 21 on 9/10. She must have left those packages somewhere; she didn't bring them home. Presumably she spent the night with someone, friend or pick-up, and left them there. If she had died on 9/11, why would the person who she spent that night with not come forward to the grieving family to give them some answers about her last day on earth?

I think that remains the question.

I'm leaning toward the theory that she overdosed, and her party buddies just dumped her body and her packages somewhere they wouldn't be found.

Was it established that she had a drug problem, or just alcohol?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Where did her packages go? She bought a number of items at Century 21 on 9/10. She must have left those packages somewhere; she didn't bring them home. Presumably she spent the night with someone, friend or pick-up, and left them there. If she had died on 9/11, why would the person who she spent that night with not come forward to the grieving family to give them some answers about her last day on earth?

I think that remains the question.

I'm leaning toward the theory that she overdosed, and her party buddies just dumped her body and her packages somewhere they wouldn't be found.

Was it established that she had a drug problem, or just alcohol?

All I saw was that there was evidence of an alcohol problem. But, in my experience, if you're out partying all night in NYC, there's a good chance other substances are involved in addition to alcohol.