*Especially* underage she won't get in big legal trouble for pot. My possession charge was dropped after taking a course in drugs & alcohol. |
| There will not be drugs or alcohol in my house while I have minors living with me. It's not going to happen (probably won't after they're gone, either). Oh, and I teach kids to respect their bodies and minds, and let them have time to develop. |
Link? |
You have set the standard with your attitude toward pot. You say it is safer than alcohol. How so? Pot can be laced with all sorts of chemicals and has a detrimental effect on memory. As long as you send these messages, you will have a hard time managing your DD's behavior and drug/alcohol use. |
OP didn't say they thought pot was innocuous...she said they believe it's safer than alcohol. Many reputable doctors/researchers espouse the same idea--they agree that neither alcohol nor pot should be used by teens--but still think pot is the lesser of the two evils (for teens). To answer your question "How so?" Everyone has a right to their own opinion, but OP's opinion (backed by some in the medical community) isn't wrong just because it doesn't agree with your sensibilities. "The first answer always has to be neither," Dr. Aaron Carroll, a professor of pediatrics at Indiana University School of Medicine, told CBS News. But then he acknowledges they're not exactly equivalent -- and he considers alcohol much more dangerous. Carroll wrote a provocative piece for the New York Times exploring what's known about the risks of these two popular but easily abused substances. And while doesn't advocate underage users trying either one, he says it's clear that overall, alcohol causes a lot more harm. "After going through all the data and looking at which is more dangerous in almost any metric you would pick, pot really looks like it's safer than alcohol," he said. "So I guess if I had to choose, that would be the answer." Though many people associate drugs with crime, Carroll notes that most of the criminal activity tied to marijuana has to do with illegal distribution, not violence committed by people who smoke it. "On the other hand, the number of crimes that are committed that have some sort of alcohol component related to them are massive -- hundreds of thousands a year, if not more," he said. "It's far worse than what's going on with pot." Violent assaults, in particular, are often fueled by alcohol. In contrast, Carroll says research shows rates of interpersonal or domestic violence are actually "lower in people who smoke marijuana than people that don't." Also tipping the scales against drinking is the fact that 1,800 college students die each year from alcohol-related accidents and almost 600,000 are injured while under the influence of alcohol, according to the National Institutes of Health. A study published last year, looking at data from more than 7,400 U.S. high school seniors who said they had used alcohol or marijuana at least once, found drinking alcohol was associated with more unsafe driving, damage to relationships with friends and romantic partners, and regret about actions while under the influence of alcohol, especially among females. "We always worry about pot as a gateway drug," Carroll said, "but research shows us that about 9 percent of people who experiment with pot will become dependent or abuse it. The percent that later become dependent or abuse alcohol is greater than 20 percent. So more people who use alcohol are actually going to have a problem with it later in life." http://www.cbsnews.com/news/which-is-worse-booze-or-pot-a-doctor-weighs-in/ http://www.salon.com/2015/07/08/7_facts_that_prove_alcohol_is_way_more_dangerous_than_marijuana/ |
|
I have small kids, but I work with teens as a psychiatrist and have some experience in adolescent rehab centers. My problem with pot isn't that it causes people to do dangerous things, but just that it causes apathy. Kids who are smoking don't really care about doing well in school, playing sports, relationships with friends and parents. I can usually tell within twenty minutes of meeting a kid in my clinic if they are a regular pot smoker. They just don't care about stuff that most adolescents get all in a tizzy about.
And besides the impact on future career prospects if a kid tanks high school, there are developmental implications as well. Kids are supposed to get all depressed when they break up with their first boyfriend or go through any number of high school dramas. If you choose not to deal with these things and just get high instead, you are going to be far behind your peers if/when you do decide to cope with normal ups and downs of daily life. It also puts kids at higher risk for developing psychosis as they get older. So, no, finding your daughter smoking pot in her room on a Sunday afternoon isn't as bad as finding her passed out drunk in your front yard on Saturday night, but it is something to take seriously. |
You have some valid points, but LOL at the bolded above....as a psychiatrist, it must be good for business when kids "get all depressed" with their breakups and high school dramas. Let me ask you this--do you prescribe your teenage patients things like Adderal, Ritalin, Xanax, etc.? Just an FYI--nearly every coke head at my competitive university was prescribed (and abused) those "legal" drugs in high school. If you think the majority of your teenage patients are taking those drugs as prescribed, you are sadly mistaken. Many of them are crushing them up and snorting, passing them out to their friends like Skittles, and looking for more aggressive stimulant options (like coke) once they reach college. |
"Many of them" isn't really a quantifiable number. Is there research to prove this? Or is it anecdotal experience. Another issue with pot is that it's fat soluable, where as alcohol is not. Alcohol passed through your system fairly quickly. Pot hangs out, which is why you can flunk a drug test 2 weeks after smoking. There are long-term effects on memory, learning and even IQ for even occasional pot smokers. |
| ^^cite your last sentence |
My observations are anecdotal, just like the psychiatrist's are. As for the abuse of drugs like Ritalin/Adderal (prescribed by psychiatrists)--this is well-documented. http://www.cnn.com/2014/04/17/health/adderall-college-students/ If you are so concerned about the long-term effects of pot on memory, learning and IQ, why don't you at least acknowledge the long term effects of alcohol on teens? |
| Alcohol kills more brain cells than cannabis. |
This. And that's what I'd tell her. First, she should not be engaging in illegal activity in my house. Second, she needs to be aware that her behavior can put others at risk (in this case, of job loss). And third, she may not fully understand the risks to herself. I mean, the first two would apply to any adult staying in my house. And the third isn't freaking out about pot, it's doing your job as a parent to help your kids learn to make good decisions; in this case, by explaining why pot is especially risky for teenagers with still-developing brains. |
I provided some later in the thread |
|
Replace the pot with oregano and see what happens.
Seriously, the PPs who said to treat it like alcohol are right. |
| Leave a note where you found it. 'We need to talk." Then ground the fuck out of her unless you want her to only get in to safety colleges. |