It all depends on where the rest of the class is applying. |
Does LSE require APs or will they take 35/35/35/36 ACT? |
School is pushing Chicago because that is likely the highest ranked school kid can get into with the relative rank. If you do not like it, ask for other "target" options. Top boarding and day schools are all over the Boston area, and they publish their SAT ranges on profiles for families. Some of these would be considered T20 high schools. Maybe one is yours. Not a single one of these top high schools has a median SAT of 1560(many are at or just above 1500 though). In other words, your kid has a top SAT score but average grades: that says to AOs that they are not studying as hard as they could, and might not be ready for the competition of ivy-level. The average unhooked kids from these schools go to ND, Bowdoin, NYU, Emory etc. UChicago is not common for truly average, most are top-30-40%, but with the 1560 and since the CC is pushing, it must be in range for your kid. That is pretty impressive to have a shot at a T12 as an average student! Is he sure he does not like it? That school opens almost as many doors as an ivy. Ask specific colleges that would be good ED besides Chicago. Your CC will know your high school's track record better than anyone on the internet. |
Didn't OP say he doesn't want grinder culture of UChicago? That would be consistent with the grades. |
Chicago loves kids from top private schools who ED. It is true from Sidwell, STA, etc. It is very rare for a top 20% kid from these schools to attend Chicago from these schools because they all aim for the Ivies and most are successful. As such Chicago is where the kids with a 3.6-3.8 ED1 and then where some of the 3.8+ ED2 if they want a secure shot at a prestige school and didn't get into their ED1/SCEA Ivy. Chicago's admission from top privates is a very well worn pathway. |
OP said that it’s a top20 private, that is a totally different game. A 3.5 gpa but above average test score from such an elite school carries a lot of weight. Chicago would love an ED admit with this profile. True, ivy plus might be difficult for this kid except for Cornell and with that major. Dartmouth probable if it’s a feeder and maybe a higher test score (Dartmouth likes high scorers). More realistically OP would be looking at Vandy, WashU, Emory, and SLACs. Many options. |
Exactly…and how strong your peers are… |
So it’s one of these top 20 high schools?
https://www.niche.com/k12/search/best-private-high-schools/ |
If the kid doesn't like Chicago, they shouldn't apply. .There are plenty of reasons not to like a school, and especially one with a quarter system and reputations like Chicago.
It's hard to know what other colleges are willing to look down the class for ED. At our top DC private, there are LACs that fit that bill - Wesleyan, Middlebury. Vandy doesn't go that far I don't think but ours probably doesn't rank as high nationally. The CC should know that info and can tell you if you're straight w them: Look chicago is not a fit, what else could work |
Non-boarding day school list: https://thebestschools.org/rankings/k-12/best-private-schools/ |
A lot of non-grinder kids can be more attractive applicants. Top schools don’t cares if you got Bs in French all the way through if you went outside of your school to get AI related certifications, wrote an opera, or won the east coast regional intel competition division
Ironically. The more the elite the school, the more they’ll look past one element on the application |
Yes this was the case for my two private school kids. At 2 diff Ivy (RD)…. One had a lot of Bs in foreign language. |
This is a leap. At my kids boarding school, kids who came in from some schools who didn’t have algebra in 8th, for example, had pretty shitty 9th grade grades. And they did just fine if not better during college search. Uchicago is an easy placement college counselors like that. But it doesn’t need to be your priority |
Generally slacs love top privates. |
If open to SLAC, Colby or Midd love private school kids. |