
I'm the PP who wrote that post. I'm the mom of an Aspie and was relaying the early warning signs that we missed as our daughter was very similar to OP's at 18 months and 2 years, that's all. |
With all due respect, the problem with OP's attitude is that her daughter is TWO. She is not "gifted" - perhaps she will be when she gets older, but maybe she won't. Who knows? Her TWO YEAR old is an early talker and very communicative. Great. But she also sounds like she has gross motor skills issues and social problems. Let's not pretend we are talking about an elementary aged school kid, okay? There really is no such thing as a gifted two year old. |
OP, I have a child (a boy) who is very precocious and very verbal. Full sentences by 15 months, paragraphs by 18 months. Fascinated by history by age 2. Negative and square numbers by 3. Etc., etc., etc.
The thing is, it was never an issue in his playgroup, with my mom friends, or at preschool. Everyone knows he is very bright, but I didn't make a big deal of it, and neither did they. The commonalities are much bigger than the differences. So yes, maybe you stumbled across an odd group of insecure moms who feel their children are somehow inferior, but maybe you are somehow sending out messages that are off-putting. Honestly, I've never gotten this "but gifted kids are so different..." stuff. Yes, they are, they are very different from each other. Some are intense and some are laid-back. Some are analytic and some are observers. Some are sarcastic and some prefer slapstick. In fact, if you look at research on cognitive testing, the variability between different abilities is higher at the upper end of the scale - so maybe the commonality is in how different they are. So take your daughter for who she is, strengths and weaknesses, and take the other kids for who they are, strengths and weaknesses. |
Here is another good article on sensitivities of the gifted....
http://www.sengifted.org/articles_social/Cronin_AsychnronousDevelopmentandSIIntervention.shtml |
OP, if you don't get how your post was obnoxious nothing can help you. |
|
Actually a gifted elementary school aged child was once a gifted two year old and will one day be a gifted adult. It's not something you grow into or out of. |
OP here. I appreciate the link, but yeah, we are not there. DD is precocious. I though that was the right word to use. She speaks like a five year old. Her syntax and vocabulary are advanced and she also loves to learn facts and can easily memorize them. For example, she knows at least half of the presidents and can tell you a couple simple facts about each one. We don't drill her. We don;t videotape her. I have never shared this with my friends. It is just one of her many interests. She is also like this about continents, states, animals, planets, and car models of all things. She is also starting to sound out words, which I have to say is scary. But none of this is shared with other parents. They jsut see her verbal ability. We cannot hide that. Her gross motor skills are fine. And, I would not call her social issues problems yet. Like you said, She is 2. |
OP, I haven't read all of the responses, so pardon any redundancy.
You're obviously hyperaware (naturally) of your child's advanced development. Could it be that you're projecting that hyerawareness onto your friends? I may notice a something about a friend's child but then will usually just forget about it or not pay much attention. Are you sure your perceptions about shunning are correct? |
OP you sound like a nice mom with an interesting child. I think folks articulating some nasty things about your being "obviously" overbearing or bringing this on yourself are projecting their own experiences and insecurities on you. You've already articulated an interest in doing what's best for your own child and even your own adult friends, and you've chosen words that make you seem humble and open to useful information.
Honestly, I think that the suggestions to find easy-going parents, to find a social group that focuses on promoting the social (rather than the academic) cohesiveness of the kiddies, and just enjoying your own kid (attending to her strengths as well as her more fragile areas of development) are the way to go. As you've already mentioned, maybe your child is "gifted" or "precocious" or whatever, and you don't seem to be too hung up on terminology at this point -- which is good. I think you've got the right idea: happiness and social adjustments are important to you and to your child. Find your niche! It doesn't sound like you're overbearing or a mommy-monster, so this niche won't be too hard to find, I bet. ![]() |
Yes, I do think I must be hyperaware. Someone mentioned above how the women in their playgroup would react to DD and that is something that I want to strive for. Not just for my DD but for all the kids in the group setting. I think I will let this group of moms go. I know a couple will remain freinds, but it does seem time to move on for everyone. I think it is a dawn of a new age for DD and me. we don't need this playgroup anymore. Thanks for the help. Time to make dinner. |
God, what a pretentious bore. |
Thanks. Can I have your number? lol j/k. ~OP |
What the fock are "baby signs"? And who gives a shit?
Smells like another fake coming down the pike. |
Actually, no, this is an incredibly common misconception, but a misconception nonetheless. In the sense that "once singled out as a G&T child, always treated as a G&T child" you are correct. But that's actually a faililng of the system. What we've learned in the last few decades is that gifted two-year-olds aren't necessarily gifted eight-year-olds...or gifted twelve-year-olds. At least by objective measures. Like in all other metrics, some kids hit their "growth spurt" faster than others. Of course, the "tracking" does take place early, and regardless of how "normal" a child is in later years, school districts and educators are loathe to "kick" a child out for mediocrity. |