Overrated Music Artists That I just don't get...

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I can't believe we got this far and Olivia Rodrigo hasn't been mentioned

I can't stand her music. It's so whiny and he voice is like nails on a chalkboard.

I feel similarly. But I'm in my 40s.

Her gift is expressing the super intense emotions of girls in their teens (and early 20s?) in an authentic and relatable way. Similar to Taylor Swift.

12-22 year olds are a HUGE target audience for pop music. And their life experience is driven in so many ways by intense (and confusing) emotions. Olivia Rodrigo and Taylor Swift are truly gifted at tapping into that - crafting stories and phrases that resonate with many.

Reminds me in some ways of the Cure, Depeche Mode, and similar bands back in my day. And EMO rock in the 80s. It's less about the musicality than the feelings. The insecure, brooding, mercurial, itensity of teens and young adults.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I can't believe we got this far and Olivia Rodrigo hasn't been mentioned

I can't stand her music. It's so whiny and he voice is like nails on a chalkboard.

I feel similarly. But I'm in my 40s.

Her gift is expressing the super intense emotions of girls in their teens (and early 20s?) in an authentic and relatable way. Similar to Taylor Swift.

12-22 year olds are a HUGE target audience for pop music. And their life experience is driven in so many ways by intense (and confusing) emotions. Olivia Rodrigo and Taylor Swift are truly gifted at tapping into that - crafting stories and phrases that resonate with many.

Reminds me in some ways of the Cure, Depeche Mode, and similar bands back in my day. And EMO rock in the 80s. It's less about the musicality than the feelings. The insecure, brooding, mercurial, itensity of teens and young adults.

I meant EMO rock in the 90s and 00s. Linkin Park, Fall Out Boy etc.

[Anonymous]

Olivia Rodrigo's voice makes me irritable. Her music is so whiny. I just want to slap her.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Dolly Parton

I pray that you are being facetious.

Dolly Parton overrated????? Them's fightin' words!

DON'T MESS WITH DOLLY!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Kanye West - He is awful, I don't get why his music is so popular. His music sucks. He is a weirdo and the opposite of a genius. There I said it.

I loathe to say this….because I really don’t like Kanye West as a person and he appears to be a straight up a$$hole in ever sense of the word, but creativity he really is a genius. Have you listened to his non radio play music? Right now I’m listening to The College Drop out of constant repeat. Spaceship is fire.

NP: Who he is as a person is SO much louder than who he is as an artist to the point that all I hear about him is how mentally unhinged he is and that he needs medication. And that part is so abhorrent that I have no interest in seeking out his music, or anything else to do with him. (Secondarily to his personality I have seen some of his fashion and have always found each piece ugly.)

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taylor Swift -- basic white girl bubble gum pop with a side of instability

Beyonce -- her music is fun, but I don't get the "Queen Bey" levels of worship for it

+1

DP. I beg you both to watch this "Saturday Night Live" video, "The Beygency." It is hilarious. It's what happens to any of us who DARE to diss the Queen Bey. I guarantee that as fellow "I don't get the worship" people like me, you will get this....If you're reluctant to click a link here, search YouTube for it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGxe83lXgJg

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Olivia Rodrigo's voice makes me irritable. Her music is so whiny. I just want to slap her.

I thought she was a one-hit wonder this time last year and has faded out since then? Regardless, my favorite part about her popularity was the 30-somethings jumping around, claiming that they’ve “loved her music forever.” Tell me you’re desperate to be relevant without explicitly telling me!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Taylor Swift -- basic white girl bubble gum pop with a side of instability

Beyonce -- her music is fun, but I don't get the "Queen Bey" levels of worship for it

+1

DP. I beg you both to watch this "Saturday Night Live" video, "The Beygency." It is hilarious. It's what happens to any of us who DARE to diss the Queen Bey. I guarantee that as fellow "I don't get the worship" people like me, you will get this....If you're reluctant to click a link here, search YouTube for it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGxe83lXgJg

Thank you for sharing!! This is soooo true, especially online and on Twitter in particular.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Olivia Rodrigo's voice makes me irritable. Her music is so whiny. I just want to slap her.

I thought she was a one-hit wonder this time last year and has faded out since then? Regardless, my favorite part about her popularity was the 30-somethings jumping around, claiming that they’ve “loved her music forever.” Tell me you’re desperate to be relevant without explicitly telling me!

She has more than one hit. At least three?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Olivia Rodrigo's voice makes me irritable. Her music is so whiny. I just want to slap her.

I thought she was a one-hit wonder this time last year and has faded out since then? Regardless, my favorite part about her popularity was the 30-somethings jumping around, claiming that they’ve “loved her music forever.” Tell me you’re desperate to be relevant without explicitly telling me!

You got this so wrong. Olivia Rodrigo heavily sampled (aka stole) from Paramore, a band that was popular when the 30-somethings were in high school. She had to retroactively add them to the song credits because of it. So, nobody was saying they’ve loved her forever. If anything, it was more of a “WTF, Olivia, that’s Hayley’s song.”

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Katy Perry

Her voice is not great. She's not a dancer (and actually moves in some pretty awkward ways on stage). She's not a songwriter.

She seems sweet, and her concerts seem like they are probably amazing spectacles, but she writes terrible songs.

A lot of people mentioned here aren't my cup of tea (I am using that phrase so you will know how incredibly old I am), but it seems more likely to me that they are talented and also not my thing. It's weird that people are assuming that millions of fans are wrong and they're the only one with real taste.

[Anonymous]

Bob Dylan

[Anonymous]

Billie Eilish. Moopy, unmelodic, dirge-like whisper pop.

[Anonymous]

Cold play

[Anonymous]

Ed Sheeran. I really don’t get his whole appeal at all.