Christians, do you believe that pets will be in Heaven?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Former Lutheran here. My Sunday school teacher told me my dog wasn't in heaven because animals don't have souls.

And you won't miss your pet because you'll be in the dazzling presence of God.

Well then it ain’t paradise. End period.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Former Lutheran here. My Sunday school teacher told me my dog wasn't in heaven because animals don't have souls.

And you won't miss your pet because you'll be in the dazzling presence of God.

Well then it ain’t paradise. End period.

Maybe God is a dog? Or a cat or both! That would be awesome!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Dogs are love in a fur coat. God is love. So yes, there are dogs in heaven. I’m a former Catholic. Those who’ve had NDEs say they’ve met up with dogs at the end of the tunnel of light.

Ever heard of a bad NDE? I haven't.

My cousin did. He saw a vision of Hell. It changed his life. He didn’t become religious, but he did make amends with a number of people he had hurt.

Threadjack, but I would live to hear more. Convince your cousin to do an AMA!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Dogs are love in a fur coat. God is love. So yes, there are dogs in heaven. I’m a former Catholic. Those who’ve had NDEs say they’ve met up with dogs at the end of the tunnel of light.

Ever heard of a bad NDE? I haven't.

Yes, people who just almost die (no visions or anything) and then have to go through extensive recovery/PT. Those people had bad NDEs.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’m Catholic. I think Heaven is a state of peace and joy. If animals are a part of that for you, you will experience them there.

+1

I actually had a dream that I was in a weird gray world after 1 of my dogs passed away who I loved like a brother. He also acted like a brother! I was with my living pup and we were walking together and saw the one who passed away want us to follow him then he ran off.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So do all animals on Earth go to heaven? And stay their forever? What is the difference between your dog and a cockroach? Fun times!!!!!

Only animals that humans love go to heaven. If you had a pet cockroach, you will find it when you die and go to heaven.

Signed, an expert on these matters

Well that is pretty terrible for all the unloved pets that are born and euthanized every year. Are they consigned to hell with the rest of the sinners?

People make up comforting stories about their beloved pets and don't care or think about all the other dead animals.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So do all animals on Earth go to heaven? And stay their forever? What is the difference between your dog and a cockroach? Fun times!!!!!

Only animals that humans love go to heaven. If you had a pet cockroach, you will find it when you die and go to heaven.

Signed, an expert on these matters

Well that is pretty terrible for all the unloved pets that are born and euthanized every year. Are they consigned to hell with the rest of the sinners?

People make up comforting stories about their beloved pets and don't care or think about all the other dead animals.

The worst take on this question I think I've ever seen was in the children's book God Needed a Puppy, where a little kid's dog dies because God killed it to take it to heaven and give it to a different kid who had recently died and wanted a puppy. Our kid got a copy and after I previewed it, I hid it. I should probably just throw it out.

I have no idea what happens to animals who die, but considering the question definitely drives some really terrible theology.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So do all animals on Earth go to heaven? And stay their forever? What is the difference between your dog and a cockroach? Fun times!!!!!

Only animals that humans love go to heaven. If you had a pet cockroach, you will find it when you die and go to heaven.

Signed, an expert on these matters

Well that is pretty terrible for all the unloved pets that are born and euthanized every year. Are they consigned to hell with the rest of the sinners?

People make up comforting stories about their beloved pets and don't care or think about all the other dead animals.

The worst take on this question I think I've ever seen was in the children's book God Needed a Puppy, where a little kid's dog dies because God killed it to take it to heaven and give it to a different kid who had recently died and wanted a puppy. Our kid got a copy and after I previewed it, I hid it. I should probably just throw it out.

I have no idea what happens to animals who die, but considering the question definitely drives some really terrible theology.

You think God could find a better way.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So do all animals on Earth minutes.

heaven? And stay their forever? What is the difference between your dog and a cockroach? Fun times!!!!!

Only animals that humans love go to heaven. If you had a pet cockroach, you will find it when you die and go to heaven.

Signed, an expert on these matters

Well that is pretty terrible for all the unloved pets that are born and euthanized every year. Are they consigned to hell with the rest of the sinners?

People make up comforting stories about their beloved pets and don't care or think about all the other dead animals.

I mean would you want to be greeted by strangers when you go to heaven? Or would you first want to see your beloveds?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So do all animals on Earth minutes.

heaven? And stay their forever? What is the difference between your dog and a cockroach? Fun times!!!!!

Only animals that humans love go to heaven. If you had a pet cockroach, you will find it when you die and go to heaven.

Signed, an expert on these matters

Well that is pretty terrible for all the unloved pets that are born and euthanized every year. Are they consigned to hell with the rest of the sinners?

People make up comforting stories about their beloved pets and don't care or think about all the other dead animals.

I mean would you want to be greeted by strangers when you go to heaven? Or would you first want to see your beloveds?

Heaven is crawling with beetles.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Former Lutheran here. My Sunday school teacher told me my dog wasn't in heaven because animals don't have souls.

And you won't miss your pet because you'll be in the dazzling presence of God.

Well then it ain’t paradise. End period.

No, some people will end up in hell.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Former Lutheran here. My Sunday school teacher told me my dog wasn't in heaven because animals don't have souls.

And you won't miss your pet because you'll be in the dazzling presence of God.

Well then it ain’t paradise. End period.

No, some people will end up in hell.

Hell - where the bad pets live on for eternity, screeching in agony with their evil dead human masters.

[Anonymous]

I believe pets have souls and they are waiting for us in heaven. Nondenominational Christian.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I believe pets have souls and they are waiting for us in heaven. Nondenominational Christian.

But only in Heaven, right? Are good pets abandoned when their bad owners are consigned to Hell?

[Anonymous]

Yes (I'm Orthodox and have heard various opinions from different priests). Heaven is a new glorified earth that will be made at the last judgment. It wouldn't make sense for animals not to be there. That said, people who say "It won't be heaven if X isn't there" aren't ready for heaven. Heaven is about being with Christ and worshipping him. If you're more concerned with whether or not Fluffy the cat is there than being with Christ, that's a problem. I'd recommend reading The Great Divorce by CS Lewis.