No, I think you are confusing support and benefit. I support loan forgiveness but I won’t benefit from it. The person in your fantasy scenario making $200k wouldn’t benefit either. High earners won’t get their loans forgiven but support the bills for others. There are people who are ok with some people receiving a benefit when they personally do not get the benefit. For example, I supported the childcare subsidy during the pandemic because it helped low income families feed their kids during the pandemic. I didn’t receive the money because I could easily feed my family. Sometimes it isn’t about me. I wish conservatives would understand that and stop being so self-obsessed. |
It is not self-obsession. I think about the truck driver or the waitress or the construction worker who couldn't afford college. They decided to find a job and earn a living so they could pay THEIR bills. Why should we require them to pay for the bills of others? |
Construction worker, truck driver and waitress most likely does have a college degree, just doing that job in the meantime because cannot find work Unemployment among the college educated is real |
You do not think about the truck driver or waitress (who both may have high-interest loans). You think of you, who either didn’t need loans, worked your way through college 25 years ago when such a thing was possible, or already paid them off so you won’t benefit. |
The waitress and truck driver also could have taken out student loans. Look there are many things our taxes go to that do not have the full support of the entire population. Many people feel the military industrial complex is given to much money. Others feel the NEA is given too much money. Others feel that corporations get too much money. Part of living in a society is accepting that sometimes the government finds things we don’t necessarily agree with for the good of society. |
You have no idea whether that’s true or not. And since this administration was giving households earning up to $400K free money - almost certainly a lie. |
I'm a high earner and all of my loans are likely to forgiven within the next six months. I didn't ask for this program and don't support it. But of course, people with significant loan balances are almost all high earners. |
You’re a troll. You’re purposely conflating grad/prof loans vs undergraduate loans. There are over 35 million undergraduate borrowers — nearly all of them are poor to middle class. There are 10 million grad/professional school borrowers — they are poor to affluent and their avg balances are far higher because there’s no cap. Undergrad fed debt is max ~$30k lifetime for traditional students. |
Hmmm, I’m a high earner with graduate school debt. I’m under zero illusions that mine will be paid off by a Biden forgiveness program. |