No, actually that’s me. I’m one of the pro M posters who still doesn’t think you actually live here. Why is it so important to you for people to say what they don’t like about Mamdani? Weird. As you’ve pointed out over and over, he doesn’t have much experience, so there isn’t much to be upset with him over. Fwiw I ranked Cuomo first but he lost, so I’ve moved on. |
Ok you are obviously clueless and/or a troll. Again, you show a remarkable ignorance of actual city life. The decline of publishing houses (what a strange thing to reference) has zero to do with the mayor, and everything to do with business realities. It’s not 1920 anymore. And parks are doing just fine. There is a huge park project right now on the east side along the waterway and it’s been wonderful. And of course the high line a few years back. And revitalization projects on the west side and Brooklyn. West side even has a beach now. So fun. Galleries? No idea what you’re even talking about. They are all over the city. Flourishing. |
It is so fun living rent free in your head with your obsession about whether all of the anti-Mamdani people actually live in NYC. And the one good part about Mamdani is that since I am living rent free in your head, my rent won't go up. I think you have thrown this at several people and several have given extremely specific details that would make it very clear that they live in NYC. Not that they should have to prove this. But you go on with your bad self. |
Banks are getting out of NYC as quickly as possible. They have all realized that a lot of the top talent has to be here, but most other roles can be filled elsewhere. So many jobs are being near-shored or off-shored. Goldman has tons of people in Salt Lake City and elsewhere. Citi just announced a big new complex in Charlotte and has huge (and growing) complexes in Dallas-area, Tampa and Buffalo. Morgan Stanley in Alpharetta. And so on. |
I really don’t care where you live, but I think it’s laughable you post on here so obsessively, claiming NY will be ‘ruined’ under Mamdani, yet you don’t seem to have even a basic grasp of the current state of the city. So please explain to me. What’s your plan for schools since you’ll be staying in Palm beach? Funny that you can’t even begin to answer that, whereas every other NYC parent obsesses over these issues for months and years in advance. And let’s hear about all of these parks that are so awful now? Where’s that exactly? Genuinely curious because I want to make sure I avoid them!! And the ‘publishing houses’ in decline? I’d love to hear more about those. Which ‘publishing houses’? That’s really good info, so again, please let all of us know. |
You really have your fake talking points lined up, don’t you? Banks and other co have been opening up satellite offices outside of NYC for years, even before COVID. Like all big co, they learned many of their back office people can be anywhere. This has nothing to do with Mamdani. Charlotte, as one example, is a tech hub where lots of co have moved their IT and tech employees. The move has accelerated because 95% of tech is now cloud based, instead of on prem. And you’re almost making the point of working on more affordability in NYC. It would be great if tech, hr and similar back end employees could afford to live in NYC. |
You are replying to multiple people. Not all of us agree on all of these issues. And posting obsessively? Pot. Kettle. Black. I happen to live near a very nice NYC park (though it could use some work). I am heading out to enjoy the beautiful weather here today in the park. Staying far away from the parade in Brooklyn - I wish them well but it is often chaotic (do you think that makes the news in Palm Beach?). Thanking my lucky stars that my kids are on the older side so we have had a great run in NYC publics (with some private mixed in) and will largely be done with schools before publics go downhill. This is NYC so I think there will always be some really good schools as the parents will make sure it will happen, but I'm not sure how many. The press has been awful about not pushing Mamdani about plans for schools. And I'm not just referring to SHSAT schools which everyone obsesses over even though they only impact a tiny percentage of kids. I'm talking about schools in general. He has said nothing and no one has asked. He does seem to want to expand programs for younger kids which I think is a good idea (see - I'm not 100% negative about him!). |
100% agree that this pre-dates Mamdani. But it will accelerate under him. I am not opposed to affordability. I think it is critical and a great idea. I am opposed to how he plans to accomplish it. Rent freezes are short-sighted and a dumb idea. Again - those who support Mamdani show a complete lack of understanding of why others oppose him and just assume that we are all evil. And again, there are several of us here and we are not totally unanimous on these things. |
Well, I’m sure there are real anti Mamdani posters, of course, but there is clearly at least one who is full of BS and doesn’t seem to understand NYC at all for someone who claims to live here, and with children no less. So what’s your view on the decline of publishing houses here? Very curious about how your average NYC resident feels about that. Oh so you’re avoiding the Brooklyn parade today? lol it must be really difficult to do that from your place, right? Wow, good luck with that! Glad your dc made it through schools. How was their experience? There are tons of school options in NYC. Tons. I don’t always like the process myself but I can’t say that my dc didn’t have a number of really interesting options. |
If the move to satellite offices outside of NYC accelerates under Mamdani, it will have little to do with him and much more to do with tech/structural issues of how modern day companies are run. Have you worked at a major company in the last decade? If you had, you’d know exactly what I mean. I wouldn’t need to explain it at all. I don’t assume anti M people are evil, but I’ll say they tend to fall into two categories. The very wealthy and/or Jewish who don’t like his stance on Israel. But what I especially don’t like is people pretending to care about NYC posting nonsense about my city and this race. |
DP. They are all flawed candidates. He’s the best of the bunch. |
I am not telling an internet stranger where my child is going to school. Don’t be weird. |
If you stopped the “if you don’t agree with me you don’t live here” garbage you would get more mileage with your other slightly more intelligent arguments.
The beauty of NYC is its diversity. Your refusal to admit that there are plenty of people here who dislike Mamdani and it is not because we are super rich or racist or stupid shows a lack of understanding and appreciation of that diversity. There are many of us highly educated moderate Dem UES/UWS (and elsewhere) professionals who are politically engaged and pragmatic who don’t just vote our pocket books who feel this way. But you just insult us. Unfortunately, there are not enough of us to really move the needle much. But we should not be ignored or insulted. But you be you. I’ve wasted enough time being insulted, spoken to like a child, treated like a self-interested morally devoid Trumper, and so on. As I said, to his credit, Mamdani is making some effort to reach out to others. But I hope he is truly listening and getting a major reality check. |
People aspire to move to New York to be around cultured professionals, the types who work for publishing houses (many of which have left the city). New York’s share of high culture has declined tremendously since the Bloomberg years. Smart recent grads primed to make money don’t think living in Jackson Heights and eating 15 dollar takeout in a cockroach infested rent controlled apartment is the dream. That is Mamdani’s New York. |
Remind me who has been the mayor for the last 3+ years? |