I don't know the answer which is why I asked the question. My son isn't affected by it so I don't really care, I'm just wondering why (and I don't feel like scrolling through 260 pages of posts). |
No hypocrisy. Find where US Soccer has a rule for youth grouping to be grade based, otherwise you have no defendable position. |
Aug guy so hypercritical. Denying RAE while calculating these age month difference |
|
[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Current youngers in ECNL are approximately 25% according to the public data.
With the change, I highly doubt there will be more than 5-10% of grade below playing on any older team. Slightly different in Sept+ and August states but not by much since there weren’t that many kids in those months to begin with. So grade is going to be a fair proxy if 95% of kids are corresponding to the same grade in school vs 75% as is. Yes there will be edge cases with hold backs or exceptional players or random school start dates but lets stop governing by minor exception vs the rule. [/quote] 25 states have an enrollment date of 8/31 or 9/1. 6 states have an enrollment date of 7/31 or 8/1. So if half of the country starts enrollment in September, why does youth soccer use a cutoff that aligns with only 6 states? If anything choosing 8/1 as the SY cutoff is letting the minority dictate things.[/quote] You already know the answer to that……….and if you dont understand it it is because you dont want to understand it. It has been explained on here ad nauseam [/quote] I don't know the answer which is why I asked the question. My son isn't affected by it so I don't really care, I'm just wondering why (and I don't feel like scrolling through 260 pages of posts).[/quote] Its so theres almost no "Force Ups" or players that because of their birthday must play on the team thats all grade older players. This is because you cant play down. On the other side of the eligibility window there are Aug and Sept birthdays that technically can play on a grade down team. But this is easily addressed by clubs playing Aug Sept birthdays up on the team thats their grade in school. This is because playing up is allowed. See how it works? The only issue are idiots like the Age guy thats trying to convince Aug birthdays to play on a team thats a grade down. |
|
Its so theres almost no "Force Ups" or players that because of their birthday must play on the team thats all grade older players. This is because you cant play down.
On the other side of the eligibility window there are Aug and Sept birthdays that technically can play on a grade down team. But this is easily addressed by clubs playing Aug Sept birthdays up on the team thats their grade in school. This is because playing up is allowed. See how it works? The only issue are idiots like the Age guy thats trying to convince Aug birthdays to play on a team thats a grade down. |
The more nonsense you post the more opportunities it gives me to explain why Aug birthdays should play on teams that are their grade in school. The more educated parents get about SY the more they'll demand that clubs play players on the correct grade in school team. |
Nobody but you is trying to convince anyone to do anything. People are telling what leagues, clubs and college coaches said. Leagues set rules, 8/1 then clubs said only best of best get considered to play up then college coaches said in Facebook chat and 2 club announcements that you found that playing up or the age of the recruits doesn't matter to them. All this really seems to really hurt your feelings so you lash out like a toddler saying you are correct and everyone else is wrong but never offer any facts or citations, it's always just your flawed opinion. |
The problem it is very clear that you are trying to get youth soccer to go grade based to help your specific situation. You aren't trying to help anyone but yourself. If US Soccer wanted to go grade year, they would have. They didn't. Clubs are trying to push as many players as possible to the new correct age groups they don't care about grades. It is a heavy lift when many want to be special. Tell your coach your kids grade and watch their eyes glaze over with not caring. |
Keep lieing. Multiple parents have reported on this thread that clubs are asking players in tryouts when they were born and what grade if they are an Aug birthday. |
|
Uh oh....
https://www.kopsc.org/age-group-formation-for-2026-2027-season This change will not impact the Spring 2026 season and our current travel teams will remain as they were in Fall 2025. This change will begin for the Fall 2026 season such that this year's Competitive Academy tryouts will run by August 1 + grade year. Example 1 - August 15, 2015 birthday and going into 6th grade - plays with 6th grade team (U12). Example 2 - August 15, 2015 birthday and going into 5th grade (held back in terms of grade year) - plays with 5th grade team (U11). This is a significant shift that will impact every Competitive Academy team. The Board has worked tirelessly to determine best handling and will continue to work with our staff, volunteer coaches, and families to make this transition as smooth as possible |
The scariest part is your clear detachment from what's real In your mind, the League has Calendar based Age criteria for players. But in your Stephen Spielberg movie, your club can make up their own rules for you and other parents with kids who can't handle playing their assigned age group |
He just translated that to Latin he doesn't understand 😂 |
Are these parents in the therapy session with you? |
|
And another oh oh....
https://www.facebook.com/groups/scholarshipsforsocceracademy/posts/25586005637693862/ |
This is the right way to handle $500 a year, volunteer coached teams. Let them play with friends. |