
The last thing they need to do is add more points to a system that should be much more holistic and much less point based. It also doesn't solve the problem of affluent base/LLIV middle schools effectively getting extra seats, since they get all of their regular allocation plus they get to poach a lot of center school slots from the kids zoned to the center. It would make a lot more sense to eliminate AAP centers and instead provide AAP at every single MS. Or allocate seats on a pyramid level. Or in the cases where the base school is more affluent than the center, count kids zoned to the base but attending the center against the base's allotment rather than the center's. Luther Jackson and Thoreau are a perfect example of why the current system makes no sense. Thoreau is much more affluent. But, the majority of the very top kids in AAP and zoned to Thoreau will attend Luther Jackson. It's not fair for the Luther Jackson kids to have an additional 200 relatively wealthy AAP kids swoop in and steal half of their slots. It's also not fair to hand the Thoreau zoned kids 9 extra TJ spots, since these kids largely are kids who weren't smart enough to get into AAP despite their parents' wealth and privilege, or kids who weren't motivated enough to challenge themselves at the center. |
Why don't they just pick by base school instead i.e. Thorough gets X spots. Kids whose base school is Thoroeau spots come from Thoreau's allotment regardless of AAP. |
I am the loudest and most well-informed pro-reform person on this board - and the above poster is exactly right. The only quarrel I would have is that I think the Jackson/Thoreau issue is a specific weakness of the system rather than evidence that it makes no sense - but you're well on the right track by making the point that AAP services need to be available at every middle school and that centers need to be eliminated. |
100% agree. They need to do away with the AAP Centers at the MS level. |
Why limit the diversity only at TJ? Why not in MS where MS kids can benefit from diversity too!!! |
TJ is not a neighborhood school. Middle Schools are/should be. Public middle schoolers should be able to attend their zoned middle school and those schools should be equipped to educate the students who are zoned to them, no matter how advanced or non-advanced. |
If the graders see a whole bunch of essays looking very similar... |
It's amazing that this thread is still thriving even though this case was left out of court months ago. |
absolutely. we should not have any kind of testing at any level of school. no kid is better than another. |
It's actually still active. The Fourth Circuit finally heard oral arguments on the actual appeal back in mid-September and we are awaiting a final decision from them. The previous ruling from the Fourth was in regard to an emergency stop order requested by FCPS against the ruling from Claude Hilton at the District Court level. That ruling allowed the process to continue for the Class of 2026 when the Supreme Court surprisingly declined to vacate the stop. Both appellate courts have thus signaled their intent on the matter and the Coalition is likely to lose at both levels if they choose to pursue it further. But as the case itself isn't fully settled de jure, even though it essentially is de facto, I'm not surprised the thread is still active. |
Sure, it will drag on forever if they don't drop it but it's basically dead. They don't have a case so it's going nowhere. |
They should keep a count of how many kids claim awards then compare that to the actual totals in the county to get a sense on how much lying is going on. |
#fakenews How many times have you told us this case was meritless? The Fairfax judge said he thought there was discrimination but it wasn't the issue before him. The District Court ruled against FCPS, the 4th Circuit was split 2-1 on the emergency appeal by FCPS to stay the order, and three Justice of the Supreme Court thought the emergency order should be reviewed. |
It’s not gone. I live in a TJ feeder neighborhood. There is a family a couple doors over with an 8th grader. They have teamed up with two other neighborhood families with 8th graders and rented a cheap o crash pad by an under-represented school, which the kids are attending until spring. Mom is “separated“ from dad on paper and, as a singLe parent with no income, has filled out the FARMSs paperwork. They take turns with drop off and pickup. Kids stay on same travel sports teams, sleep in their bedrooms and I know they take independent math classes on Sundays to stay ahead. No one is hiding it. And in many ways, it’s cheaper and easier than prep. |
Of course this is happening. This is exactly why it should be a lottery. |