No sillier than an atheist asking a believer to "prove" what he/she believes in. |
Dont recall an atheist asking a believer to prove what they believe in. Could you point out that post? |
Sigh... man you miss the point yet again, on purpose I am sure. It's a discussion forum dude. If you don't enjoy discussing the topic I don't know why you are here. The fact that you don't have a good justification for your belief is your problem. The theist who admitted they don't care what is true or not is the most honest one, and you will note no one took issue with them. Maybe you should try that? |
If your best answer is " because this is a discussion forum" then you are being no more honest than you are assuming I am to be. You want an honest answer? I do care whether or not God exists, because He is the whole reason for the Faith in the first place. If you don't think that is an honest answer, I dont know what else to say. |
Sounds like you're saying "If there's no God, then I've been a fool." Is that what you're saying? |
So you do care if it is true or not? Great. Then why is so horrible to be asked why you think it is true? |
Dunno if it's happened in this discussion, but it has happened. (DP) |
Whether or not it has happened, what si the problem of asking for evidence of a claim? Do all unsupported claims demand to be accepted silently here? Homeopathy? Conspiracy theories? Religions like Scientology? I am asking seriously. |
You could have left off "like Scientology" and just left it as "Religions" |
No. That is what you are saying. |
Reworded - I do care whether or not Zeus exists, because Zeus is the whole reason for the Faith in the first place. See how silly that is. |
Your rewording, not mine. Mine: If I follow a Religion that believes in the existence of God, I should also care about whether He exists or not. |
If I follow a creed that believes in the existence of Santa, I should also care about whether Santa exists or not. Still silly. |
Talking to people like you is a waste of time. Telling people (insulting) people telling them to grow up all the while not understanding the basic concept of faith is ridiculous. Perhaps it's you that needs to "grow up" and find other things like gardening, colleges, investing, health to discuss with others in a non-combative manner. Your position as it stands, is lame. |
Of course you should. But, since you don't follow such a creed, I'm assuming you don't care whether or not Santa exists. |