Trans Non Binary - minority?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:1. Everyone should be called by the name and pronouns they want to be called by.
2. No one should be shamed for their gender presentation.
3. Probably more research is needed on cross sex hormones and puberty blockers in minors before we determine that they're 100% safe and reversible.
4. It's not worth destroying women's sports.
5. AMAB rapists in women's prison is a bad idea.

This is all most of us want. I'd also like male culture to be the one that has to change, not female, but frankly perhaps we are all of us, trans and not trans alike, too scared and cowed by masculinity to push back.

Easier to blame the caregivers. The soft ones. The women.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

This is hilariously delusional.

MEN are the ones who are by in large against trans people.

GAY MEN are the leaders. The Paris is Burning contingent (boomer, genX) inspired a generation of emo AFAB often troubled tweens/teens who were especially radicalized in the 20-teens.

From where I sit — at a hospital that performs a ton of gender-related $$ surgery under general anesthesia— it’s still the GAY MEN leading the case

[Anonymous]

Iran is interesting as an example because Americans like to say we are more enlightened... And we are .... in takoma park. In Oklahoma? Not always. What many miss in this unquestioned acceptance is how many parts of America would prefer a trans daughter to a gay son.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

This is hilariously delusional.

MEN are the ones who are by in large against trans people.

GAY MEN are the leaders. The Paris is Burning contingent (boomer, genX) inspired a generation of emo AFAB often troubled tweens/teens who were especially radicalized in the 20-teens.

From where I sit — at a hospital that performs a ton of gender-related $$ surgery under general anesthesia— it’s still the GAY MEN leading the case

You sure they're not transmen? Because the gay men I know are really not into the whole no penis thing.

On the other hand, gay male culture has a lot of misogyny so this may be just people who've been told they're good people and who don't really care about things like uterine atrophy or PID because they're never going to have them.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

Don’t forget shaming and excommunication of exiles aka the detrans community.

I'm glad you brought this up because I've wanted to speak on this for a while. Trans people do not have an issue with de-transitoners. The problem they have is when de-transitioners hold the belief that, because they were wrong about being trans, that everyone else is too.

✔️Heretic

Thanks for playing.

Nope!

Why do some de-transitoners get to speak for all trans people? Their personal experiences are theirs alone, and don't represent everyone else.

And yet I keep being told that transwomen are just like me and I have to accept it, embrace it and affirm it lest I get called a transphobe.

My lived experience has been that human males can be violent towards women, why do I have to ignore that lived experience at the expense of my own feelings and safety?

This is where the mystical part of the religion kicks in. Wishing something to be true, does not make it a true.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

Don’t forget shaming and excommunication of exiles aka the detrans community.

It is my own opinion that quite a lot of our current "correct" gender ideology boils down to the reductive ugly truth that many cultures don't like effeminate men. They're not always fond of masculine women, either, but it's this real fear of men not being men *enough* that seems to drive a lot of this.

And that's just more misogyny.

This is the clearly the case in places like Iran where it’s a solution for gay men.

But it doesn’t explain why gender ideology demands the affirmation of falsehood that humans can change sex.

To understand this, you need to understand the driver of the movement-which is not to shame gay effeminate men, it’s to normalize the falsehood that trans women are exactly like non trans women.

This movement is led by middle aged males who usually become trans women. Their motivation in doing so is that they can only get off on being validated as a woman. Once you understand that these people can only have their sexual desires satisfied by this farce, everything makes sense.

Of course you are correct. it often goes back to a shame and humiliation kink because that is how they see womanhood. It’s pure misogyny.

It doesn't, you made that up!

Of course it does. That is why they are fighting for removing legal protections for women as a sex class and basing it on gender identity instead.

Hence our daughters get to compete against males like Lia Thomas in athletics. And those of us who face incarceration may be required to share a cell with a male sex offender.

Women are adult human females. Men are adult human males. The trans lobby is doing everything they can to change this definition of sex in legislation to remove women’s sex based protections

[Anonymous]

Why has this not been moved to the LGBQT forum? It’s not been about colleges, basically, ever.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

Don’t forget shaming and excommunication of exiles aka the detrans community.

It is my own opinion that quite a lot of our current "correct" gender ideology boils down to the reductive ugly truth that many cultures don't like effeminate men. They're not always fond of masculine women, either, but it's this real fear of men not being men *enough* that seems to drive a lot of this.

And that's just more misogyny.

This is the clearly the case in places like Iran where it’s a solution for gay men.

But it doesn’t explain why gender ideology demands the affirmation of falsehood that humans can change sex.

To understand this, you need to understand the driver of the movement-which is not to shame gay effeminate men, it’s to normalize the falsehood that trans women are exactly like non trans women.

This movement is led by middle aged males who usually become trans women. Their motivation in doing so is that they can only get off on being validated as a woman. Once you understand that these people can only have their sexual desires satisfied by this farce, everything makes sense.

Of course you are correct. it often goes back to a shame and humiliation kink because that is how they see womanhood. It’s pure misogyny.

It doesn't, you made that up!

Of course it does. That is why they are fighting for removing legal protections for women as a sex class and basing it on gender identity instead.

Hence our daughters get to compete against males like Lia Thomas in athletics. And those of us who face incarceration may be required to share a cell with a male sex offender.

Women are adult human females. Men are adult human males. The trans lobby is doing everything they can to change this definition of sex in legislation to remove women’s sex based protections

Again sex is not gender

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

Don’t forget shaming and excommunication of exiles aka the detrans community.

It is my own opinion that quite a lot of our current "correct" gender ideology boils down to the reductive ugly truth that many cultures don't like effeminate men. They're not always fond of masculine women, either, but it's this real fear of men not being men *enough* that seems to drive a lot of this.

And that's just more misogyny.

This is the clearly the case in places like Iran where it’s a solution for gay men.

But it doesn’t explain why gender ideology demands the affirmation of falsehood that humans can change sex.

To understand this, you need to understand the driver of the movement-which is not to shame gay effeminate men, it’s to normalize the falsehood that trans women are exactly like non trans women.

This movement is led by middle aged males who usually become trans women. Their motivation in doing so is that they can only get off on being validated as a woman. Once you understand that these people can only have their sexual desires satisfied by this farce, everything makes sense.

Of course you are correct. it often goes back to a shame and humiliation kink because that is how they see womanhood. It’s pure misogyny.

It doesn't, you made that up!

Of course it does. That is why they are fighting for removing legal protections for women as a sex class and basing it on gender identity instead.

Hence our daughters get to compete against males like Lia Thomas in athletics. And those of us who face incarceration may be required to share a cell with a male sex offender.

Women are adult human females. Men are adult human males. The trans lobby is doing everything they can to change this definition of sex in legislation to remove women’s sex based protections

Again sex is not gender

And gender is made up nonsense; usually based on sex stereotypes.

Hence why trans extremists are fighting to change references in legislation from sex to gender. Because we are a sexually dimorphic species, saying otherwise is clearly nonsense.

But, that reality really hurts the feelings of men who want to be women. So now we all have to pretend that gender a.k.a. made up nonsense, is more important than sex aka reality.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody gets more angry about pronouns than Gen x/boomer women who were bullied for not being feminine enough when they were little girls.

That’s not me. I just simply do not accept the religious component of pronoun demands. I do not believe people have mutable gender identities, any more than I believe people have souls that needs saving. Gender ideology is a religious belief akin to a belief in a soul. I am an atheist and don’t believe in either.

I love you and believe we were separated at birth. Everything you said is true.
The whole trans thing has every marker of a religion:
Heretics/nonbelievers - normies
Blasphemy - dead naming/ wrong pronouns
Dogma that cannot be questioned
Patriarchy - this is 100% male lead with females as it ardent followers and enforcers
Mystical beliefs

It is all there.

This is hilariously delusional.

MEN are the ones who are by in large against trans people.

GAY MEN are the leaders. The Paris is Burning contingent (boomer, genX) inspired a generation of emo AFAB often troubled tweens/teens who were especially radicalized in the 20-teens.

From where I sit — at a hospital that performs a ton of gender-related $$ surgery under general anesthesia— it’s still the GAY MEN leading the case

Is gay men or AGP men?

Clearly we agree it is men leading the charge.