Well, I live in Charlottesville now and they don’t do it, but by all means continue with the sour grapes on a thread about acceptances for 2026 |
From-here vs. Come-here throwdown! (Which, incidentally, was kind of the general undercurrent I encountered when I went to UVA.) |
| For those interested in stats of students selected and not selected go the College Confidential “UVA RD 2022/class of 2026” and Reddit. It’s all there |
It's just as helpful as many other sustained activities--because sustained activities often move towards leadership. It's helpful, just not uniquely helpful. And the fact is that many boy scout troops are quite small these days--esp. at the older ages-- so the leadership activities are not as telling about a person's capacity for leadership as they may have been when it was a more widely popular activity. |
I don't think a couple dozen people posting stats, which may or may not be embellished, is all that informative when thousands were accepted. |
It does vary by school. The Scouts did a survey of colleges a couple of years ago and asked how they viewed Eagle Scouts. The answers were pretty wide ranging, from "it's viewed as any other activity" to "very important." I have observed that many selective schools like to say that 100% of their students have had "leadership" roles in HS, and the list that I saw at one school re: what qualifies included things like "President of the Student Body, athletic team Captain, Eagle Scout." So my assumption is that these things are pretty equivalent, and, at a minimum, it checks a box for some of these very competitive schools. FWIW, my DS is an Eagle Scout and at least one of his acceptance letters this year mentioned that they liked that he was an Eagle Scout, so there's that for an anecdote. |
Perhaps they don't now, but it was very common back in the day. |
That’s nice. It isn’t distinguishing to get your kid into a top college in 2022. |
And are we "back in the day"? Are you? |
Thank you for posting this. |
And your point is? |
| God I’m happy my DC was accepted to Virginia. |
“Couple dozen people”. Good heavens, you don’t have a clue about CC or Reddit! |
Same here. It took the entire pressure out of waiting for the rest of the decisions. DD and we know she has a good place to go that is within our financial possibilities. |