It's not abuse, but it's not great. I was watched by an older sibling a lot and it was a lousy thing to do to both of us. If it's unexpected and temporary because life circumstances changed, that's one thing, but if you go into having a kid with the plan that your tween is going to provide significant child care for you, you're likely to end up with a teenager who moves out as early as she can and blames you for her lack of a normal childhood. It's one thing when this was normal, but your kids can look around and see that being a regular source of child care for your younger siblings is not just a thing that happens to older siblings, it's a weird choice that her parents made because they weren't willing or able to take care of the kids they had themselves. |
You know the answer - just to piss you off. |
LOL honey you don't usually need three spots at daycare at the same time. |
There are so many posters on DCUM who constantly droll on about older kids watching younger siblings as being abusive, unfair, or some other idiotic yarn. All I have to say to these parents is - you're an idiot. This is possible one of the dumbest points on DCUM, and there are many. And if you report parents for having siblings watch siblings, you're a self-entitled Karen who wastes valuable county resources. I can't imagine the type of kid you raise where they have no responsibilities. Build character. Stop filling society with worthless kids who can't do crap for themselves because parents were too inept to give them any real responsibilities. JFC! |
|
So, does the OP just leave her 12 year old at home alone all of the time while she goes out with her friends?
I would rather be left with a sibling. |
I also don't really think this is true. Most moms with 3+ kids have them because they just really like babies and little kids. Many probably SAH at least partly for that reason. |
|
Something I don’t think has been mentioned here is that the 12 year olds in large/low resource families are not only babysitting their siblings, cousins, and neighbors especially in working poor neighborhoods. Can you imagine the time suck?
Plus the chores, after school activities, and homework? Theirs a difference in having the said 12 year old as a date night/going-out sitter vs aftercare. In poorer families it’s often the later. |
THIS I know a mom of four who has her life together and is super fun. I know another mom of four who is a constant mess and is always complaining. I know a mom of one who has her life together and is super fun. I know another mom of one who is a constant mess and is always complaining. Having three kids doesn't mean you are a particular kind of person, OP. It's actually sad that you have such a narrow worldview that you think it is. |
My two closest friends with three kids are both doctors. One is an OB/GYN and the other is a Pediatrician. |
Well, they want to hang out with you as long as they have the ability to use their children as an excuse to get away... Also, finding plane tickets and hotels for a family of five is like...the easiest thing ever? It's not like there are 15 of them. |
It's they're, not their. And I have twins and it's the best thing ever. I'm probably in the top 1% of the happiest moms I know. And I work! |
I think it’s okay IF the child has a choice and gets paid for babysitting. I am all for giving responsibility and building character but sometimes parents who do this are offloading actual parenting on their children and that is totally unfair. Of course this can happen in lots of ways, like if a parent leans on a child for emotional support or something, so it’s not just confined to parents who have lots of kids. When you give chores that kids have to do for no money, I think you should give them a job that doesn’t require care of another developing human being. I make my oldest do the dishes, but she can earn money for babysitting if she wants (and often she does want to. Not always but often). |
It's not hard, but expensive. |
I don't know if I'm crazy here, or if you are. I grew up UMC, but I babysat my younger siblings after school when I was a teenager. I wasn't doing crafts or enriching activities with them. We had a snack (everyone got their own), and watched The Simpsons. If I had a bunch of homework, then I worked on my homework while they watched TV or played outside. I'm not at all sure that I would have done much different if I had been an only child. What was everyone else doing after school in eighth grade? |
It's a single line of text made up of three sentences. Your desperate attempt at a comeback...failed. Idiot. |